|
Keep the discussion ON TOPIC. This thread is for discussing the terror attacks in Paris. |
On November 14 2015 15:52 KwarK wrote:Show nested quote +On November 14 2015 15:30 Yuljan wrote:On November 14 2015 15:02 DeepElemBlues wrote: What's worked in the past has been completely overwhelming the guerrilla force which usually takes a while and involves killing lots of people (most of whom had nothing to do with the guerrillas), like the Soviets in the Ukraine in the 1920s (and again after WW2), or getting the locals on your side so they inform on the guerrillas to you and don't give them supplies or shelter. The guerrillas show up and want food and to stay the night and the village people tell them to screw off and start shooting or come running for you. They give up (or you give up) and a political accommodation is reached.
It's a global guerrilla force that is attacking the West and just about everybody else. The locals supporting them could be anything, from a youtube channel with radical videos turning young men nutso, to a mosque controlled by radicals turning young men nutso, to a Saudi noble pumping millions into radical schools or giving loads of cash to a contact knowing it will be used for terrorism, to a Pakistani intelligence agent running money and guns to a Taliban faction, to an entire government like Iran with Hezbollah, to a Western-"friendly" government that dumps huge amounts of anti-semitic and anti-western propaganda into the national media and political and popular and religious culture to keep people distracted from how crappy their government is (which happens to varying degrees in almost all Islamic countries).
Any strategy against this kind of ideology - basically, they say that there was a glory age wherein "true" Islam was practiced that has been strayed from and the situation is so bad we have to kill the Westerners and Jews and traitors that made it that way, or that those people are preventing "true" Islam from spreading its glorious bounty over Muslim countries/the world - has to defeat a lot of misinformation that people believe that makes them receptive to the guy who says kill all these people and things will be better in the first place. The common people in a lot of Muslim countries have been subjected to decades of indoctrination intended to make them suspicious and hateful of foreigners and heretics and alleged threats to their religion. It wasn't Nasser's or Egypt's or anybody Arab or Muslim's fault that Israel kicked his butt twice in 1956 or 1967, it was those sneaky Jews and their American backers and it wasn't a fair fight. The West has no morals and wants to destroy the morals of our Islamic culture to make money because they're controlled by greedy Jews and are quite greedy and lacking in morals themselves anyway. Not all Arab or Muslim countries have that kind of stuff occupying a large part of their culture but a lot do and have for a long time. Kind of makes it easy to recruit for terrorism which the dictators were too short-sighted to see, or to see that the terrorists would aim at them too.
It's going to take a lot of effort and a long time to reverse the attitudes about foreigners and particularly Westerners that have been reinforced by widespread and prolonged circulation of anti-Western stereotypes, stories, myths, rumors, etc. And when the West does do something dumb or bad it's just confirmation of all the accusations that really are crazy to the type of people who wind up becoming terrorists. The dictators/military did quite well surprising the Islamist's until the US/the West decides that supporting islamic rebels would be a great solution to make these countries love the West. This is backwards. We supported the dictators while they could discreetly keep their shit together because it wasn't too embarrassing. We didn't create the rebels to depose the dictators. The rebels happened as part of a broader cultural and demographic issue. It's just once the rebels happened we couldn't openly support the people gunning them down so we went with plan B, arm the rebels, wait for them to become the new dictator, do business with them. The west didn't support dictatorships for decades only to change their minds. We supported anyone who could discreetly keep the population under control while selling us natural resources and the scale of the Arab Spring was beyond our dictators so we decided to try and get some new ones.
Agreed, which makes the recent keystone decision so bizarre.
|
On November 14 2015 13:40 Deathstar wrote:Show nested quote +On November 14 2015 13:21 parkufarku wrote: How do you exactly initiate war on terrorists though? They are hiding out within their country as regular citizens. This is similar to the Vietcongs where soldiers couldn't tell the difference between the civilians and the terrorists.
I'm all for engaging in war against them but how would it be done - effectively? Unless you just nuke the entire country / wipe out the entire population, I don't think it's gonna work. (not saying they should) The issue is that the terrorists are in your country to begin with. For one, don't let the population that's breeding jihadis into your country. That'll help things along. Two, you NEED to increase policing and surveillance, and act on the information that you receive. For example, there were two people in the US who routinely expressed preparation for a race war and armed themselves to shoot up black churches. The FBI didn't wait for them to actually blow up the churches. They went in and arrested these two guys after evidence of them arming themselves. http://www.cnn.com/2015/11/10/us/white-supremacist-bomb-plot-virginia-fbi/The two points I outlined will go a long way in protecting civilians from terrorist attacks, be they jihadi or home brewed right wingers.
this doesnt solve the problem though and it does undermine the very values of our society. a couple of hundred dead isnt worth threatening a free society, never.
what should be done is two-fold:
one: give minorities real chances in the country. this means specialised programs to give the poor a decent education and with that decent jobs, but also to break up ghettos with sophisticated housing programs. dont let dumb stupid idiots live only near other dumb stupid idiots because they will breed among each other and create super dumb stupid idiots.
second: de-extremise by getting the monopoly on religious teachings. this means getting rid of every religious teacher who isnt from a western university or hasnt undergone a thorough screening.
with those two difficult and expensive policies in place you can probably severly cripple religious extremism directed at us in about 20 or 30 years or so. until then you just wait.
|
On November 14 2015 15:52 KwarK wrote:Show nested quote +On November 14 2015 15:30 Yuljan wrote:On November 14 2015 15:02 DeepElemBlues wrote: What's worked in the past has been completely overwhelming the guerrilla force which usually takes a while and involves killing lots of people (most of whom had nothing to do with the guerrillas), like the Soviets in the Ukraine in the 1920s (and again after WW2), or getting the locals on your side so they inform on the guerrillas to you and don't give them supplies or shelter. The guerrillas show up and want food and to stay the night and the village people tell them to screw off and start shooting or come running for you. They give up (or you give up) and a political accommodation is reached.
It's a global guerrilla force that is attacking the West and just about everybody else. The locals supporting them could be anything, from a youtube channel with radical videos turning young men nutso, to a mosque controlled by radicals turning young men nutso, to a Saudi noble pumping millions into radical schools or giving loads of cash to a contact knowing it will be used for terrorism, to a Pakistani intelligence agent running money and guns to a Taliban faction, to an entire government like Iran with Hezbollah, to a Western-"friendly" government that dumps huge amounts of anti-semitic and anti-western propaganda into the national media and political and popular and religious culture to keep people distracted from how crappy their government is (which happens to varying degrees in almost all Islamic countries).
Any strategy against this kind of ideology - basically, they say that there was a glory age wherein "true" Islam was practiced that has been strayed from and the situation is so bad we have to kill the Westerners and Jews and traitors that made it that way, or that those people are preventing "true" Islam from spreading its glorious bounty over Muslim countries/the world - has to defeat a lot of misinformation that people believe that makes them receptive to the guy who says kill all these people and things will be better in the first place. The common people in a lot of Muslim countries have been subjected to decades of indoctrination intended to make them suspicious and hateful of foreigners and heretics and alleged threats to their religion. It wasn't Nasser's or Egypt's or anybody Arab or Muslim's fault that Israel kicked his butt twice in 1956 or 1967, it was those sneaky Jews and their American backers and it wasn't a fair fight. The West has no morals and wants to destroy the morals of our Islamic culture to make money because they're controlled by greedy Jews and are quite greedy and lacking in morals themselves anyway. Not all Arab or Muslim countries have that kind of stuff occupying a large part of their culture but a lot do and have for a long time. Kind of makes it easy to recruit for terrorism which the dictators were too short-sighted to see, or to see that the terrorists would aim at them too.
It's going to take a lot of effort and a long time to reverse the attitudes about foreigners and particularly Westerners that have been reinforced by widespread and prolonged circulation of anti-Western stereotypes, stories, myths, rumors, etc. And when the West does do something dumb or bad it's just confirmation of all the accusations that really are crazy to the type of people who wind up becoming terrorists. The dictators/military did quite well surprising the Islamist's until the US/the West decides that supporting islamic rebels would be a great solution to make these countries love the West. This is backwards. We supported the dictators while they could discreetly keep their shit together because it wasn't too embarrassing. We didn't create the rebels to depose the dictators. The rebels happened as part of a broader cultural and demographic issue. It's just once the rebels happened we couldn't openly support the people gunning them down so we went with plan B, arm the rebels, wait for them to become the new dictator, do business with them. The west didn't support dictatorships for decades only to change their minds. We supported anyone who could discreetly keep the population under control while selling us natural resources and the scale of the Arab Spring was beyond our dictators so we decided to try and get some new ones.
Of course I'm simplifying the actual dynamics of the Arab spring but the knee jerk let's be the good guys reaction ("not letting the dictators gun them down") lead to massively higher casualties and new centers of instability that will even more trouble in the coming decades. The West did just change their mind based on public outcry to keep their electorate happy. The weakness of democracy and weekly popularity polls.
Even now I do not see any willigness to make unfortunate and hard choices by our leaders so the problem will remain. Let's see how long it will take until the extrem right rules most of Europe.
|
This is tragic! May all be safe and protected. Praying for everyone.
|
Are the identities of the terrorists known/released? (i.e. do we know if they were ISIS or Syrian refugees, or just normal citizens etc.?)
|
On November 14 2015 16:11 synapse wrote: Are the identities of the terrorists known/released? (i.e. do we know if they were ISIS or Syrian refugees, or just normal citizens etc.?) The last i have heard in the German news is: noone knows yet but they THINK they have connection to ISIS.
Prayers to France, they really get hit hard with this stuff.
|
On November 14 2015 16:11 synapse wrote: Are the identities of the terrorists known/released? (i.e. do we know if they were ISIS or Syrian refugees, or just normal citizens etc.?) According to current reports, 8 terrorists dead, 7 of them in suicide explosions. Identification will probably require DNA tests, which should take some time (and won't give anything if they are not already in police files). There might be some security camera images, but they haven't been analyzed yet. Unsure about the 8th one.
|
On November 14 2015 16:21 Oshuy wrote:Show nested quote +On November 14 2015 16:11 synapse wrote: Are the identities of the terrorists known/released? (i.e. do we know if they were ISIS or Syrian refugees, or just normal citizens etc.?) According to current reports, 8 terrorists dead, 7 of them in suicide explosions. Identification will probably require DNA tests, which should take some time (and won't give anything if they are not already in police files). There might be some security camera images, but they haven't been analyzed yet. Unsure about the 8th one.
the 8th one was killed by police during the assault on bataclan.
|
I guess Germany will close the borders for sure now, and with Austria and Slovenia doing the same, it's time for Croatia to start closing as well. Too bad we don't have any government at this moment.
Really don't know how to fight shit like this, if you go down there with ground troops and raise everything, you still won't remove the threat of terrorism. And you can't fight it on your own ground because with the massive immigration waves, most of the EU countries have no idea who exactly is in their cities.
You can close the borders, but that's not really a humane thing to do. Still, not saying all refugees are terrorist but if you are a leader of terrorist cell and have the opportunity to send 100-200 sleeper agents to some of the EU countries toghether with real refugees, you'd be stupid not to do it.
|
Let's not be confused here, there is a high probability that they are people born and raised in France. It's a multi layered problem: how this population feels like they are mistreaten here (and somehow they are) and how some extremist build on this feeling to bring this shit.
|
holy shit
is this fucking real life
|
This is terrible and totally unacceptable on a goverment level. High-class police officers better retire immediately and the whole surveilance system should be upgraded as soon as possible.
Don't understand what Terrorists are going to achieve here for their countries and religion, at all. Shoot people in Counter Strike, not in real life, please.
|
On November 14 2015 16:58 Furikawari wrote: Let's not be confused here, there is a high probability that they are people born and raised in France. It's a multi layered problem: how this population feels like they are mistreaten here (and somehow they are) and how some extremist build on this feeling to bring this shit.
Your apologist mentality is also a huge part of the problem. Nothing justifies murdering innocent people on streets. Throughout the history, immigrants were threated badly all around the world.Exceptions are rare.Immigrants have to win hearts & minds of the host nation & contribute to that society. If you come to have a better life to a foreign country, you have to adapt to that societies norms & values and make sure to raise your children that way too. If you want to see immigrants being extremely badly mistreaten, look at millions of South East Asians living in labor camps in Gulf countries.
|
On November 14 2015 16:58 Furikawari wrote: Let's not be confused here, there is a high probability that they are people born and raised in France. It's a multi layered problem: how this population feels like they are mistreaten here (and somehow they are) and how some extremist build on this feeling to bring this shit. That's why being born and raised in France or speaking French perfectly is not enough.
If there are people who don't feel like they are part of their country but rather its enemies and feel more loyalty towards a very different ideology than the one their state propagates, then something has gone seriously wrong.
|
On November 14 2015 17:17 fromtenedos wrote:Show nested quote +On November 14 2015 16:58 Furikawari wrote: Let's not be confused here, there is a high probability that they are people born and raised in France. It's a multi layered problem: how this population feels like they are mistreaten here (and somehow they are) and how some extremist build on this feeling to bring this shit. Your apologist mentality is also a huge part of the problem. Nothing justifies murdering innocent people on streets. Throughout the history, immigrants were threated badly all around the world.Exceptions are rare.Immigrants have to win hearts & minds of the host nation & contribute to that society. If you come to have a better life to a foreign country, you have to adapt to that societies norms & values and make sure to raise your children that way too. If you want to see immigrants being extremely badly mistreaten, look at millions of South East Asians living in labor camps in Gulf countries.
Yeah, Asians worked hard and integrated themselves to the local society with no problems and still are doing it.
|
i'm sort of lost for words right now. one thing is for sure, if i see hollande's fat mug on my screen today i'll break something
i'm pretty angry right now
|
Also #fuckreligion and all culure associated with it. It simply does more harm than it does (if it ever does) good. If you believe in any kind of supernatural God, please stop promoting it and following the cult and start believing in humanity instead.
It's the queston of a proper education only, sadly. Religion unfairly divides people instead of uniting them for the greatest challenges.
|
I'm shocked. Still checking whether all my family and friends in Paris are safe.
|
On November 14 2015 17:20 sharkie wrote:Show nested quote +On November 14 2015 17:17 fromtenedos wrote:On November 14 2015 16:58 Furikawari wrote: Let's not be confused here, there is a high probability that they are people born and raised in France. It's a multi layered problem: how this population feels like they are mistreaten here (and somehow they are) and how some extremist build on this feeling to bring this shit. Your apologist mentality is also a huge part of the problem. Nothing justifies murdering innocent people on streets. Throughout the history, immigrants were threated badly all around the world.Exceptions are rare.Immigrants have to win hearts & minds of the host nation & contribute to that society. If you come to have a better life to a foreign country, you have to adapt to that societies norms & values and make sure to raise your children that way too. If you want to see immigrants being extremely badly mistreaten, look at millions of South East Asians living in labor camps in Gulf countries. Yeah, Asians worked hard and integrated themselves to the local society with no problems and still are doing it.
You see Filipino caregivers running amok with AK-47's in street of Jeddah?
|
On November 14 2015 17:26 fromtenedos wrote:Show nested quote +On November 14 2015 17:20 sharkie wrote:On November 14 2015 17:17 fromtenedos wrote:On November 14 2015 16:58 Furikawari wrote: Let's not be confused here, there is a high probability that they are people born and raised in France. It's a multi layered problem: how this population feels like they are mistreaten here (and somehow they are) and how some extremist build on this feeling to bring this shit. Your apologist mentality is also a huge part of the problem. Nothing justifies murdering innocent people on streets. Throughout the history, immigrants were threated badly all around the world.Exceptions are rare.Immigrants have to win hearts & minds of the host nation & contribute to that society. If you come to have a better life to a foreign country, you have to adapt to that societies norms & values and make sure to raise your children that way too. If you want to see immigrants being extremely badly mistreaten, look at millions of South East Asians living in labor camps in Gulf countries. Yeah, Asians worked hard and integrated themselves to the local society with no problems and still are doing it. You see Filipino caregivers running amok with AK-47's in street of Jeddah?
No, that's my and your point isn't it?
|
|
|
|
|
|