|
To ensure this thread won't be closed, you must adhere to several a number of simple rules; - Please use spoilers when quoting a post with pictures and/or videos.
- When posting large quantities of media (pictures or videos), please begin spoilering after the first piece. Grouping related videos in the same spoilers & labeling is recommended.
- No reposting of old material unless justified
- Posting any material with little or no relevent discussion accompanying it
- No passion-induced flaming of each other because 'x said y sucked' etc.
- Keep the expression hate of music individuals/groups to a minimal level
- No 'pagetopping' in any form whatsoever, as it constitutes spam equal to posts similar to 'first'.
- No vulgar fan fics or wet dream stories. It is creepy, weird, and it dehumanizes the people who you are here to celebrate/discuss.
- Normal posting standards that you find throughout the rest of the site still apply and will be enforced more strictly from here forward (2012/03/11)
Due to the poor nature of this thread in the past, temporary two-day bans will occur more than often if people slip up. |
On January 02 2013 02:06 Sableyeah wrote:
I'm not too sure why there is so much hate going on again. I thought the song was pretty good, that being said, I also thought The Boys was alright. So I'm generally on the higher end of fandom.
The one thing I read a lot is the fact that this song has ALOT of elements, and it does, no doubt. But these parts aren't bad in their own way, if they could make separate songs out of all the elements, I could still see pretty decent songs. Also, the parts actually link quite well, as in they edited it rather well. Let's take Bohemian Rhapsody from Queen, that's the epiphany of MIXED song... Well, that worked out. Ok ok this is where people will stop reading because I'm comparing Queen with SNSD but please don't because I still have some things to cover.
I love that some sones are trying to play this off as a new, edgy/experimental song that's 3deep5you.
which is utterly stupid, because if snsd, and in extension any of the groups in the entire industry, had any inkling of artistic talent they wouldn't be in this business in the first place.
why can't they just admit this song is garbage and the retards at sme hired producers that fucked up?
And this song does have 'elements', that's obvious. regardless of how terrible each part is on its own, they're simply put together like Frankenstein or humpty dumpty.
|
Please don't fucking compare this atrocious IGAB to fucking Bohemian Rhapsody. Jesus christ, freddie mercury is probably turning in his grave.
|
So andy, what business would talented artistic people be in then? Because clearly in this game, you can be talentless and still rake in the dough. Pretty easy to do too once you have a fanbase. Actually, don't even need a fanbase. A pretty face will do and that isn't that expensive either. Where are these talented people going then? Why aren't they here raking in the dough too?
|
I'm assuming you're playing devil's advocate because otherwise you'd seem pretty anal retentive.
anyways, definitely not the idol industry. I guess you could make the argument that yonghwa is talented but that's a tangential discussion and proof is circumstantial at best.
talented people are in the music industry. yes, I consider them separate.
on a side note, it actually takes a degree in Korea to get a job in acting.
|
Anyone here heard of or know what/who BubbleFeetMusic is?
|
2NE1 already did it, and it worked a lot better.
|
^ i am the truest; name an idol group that i ain't influenced
|
This thread needs to be deleted.
|
On January 02 2013 07:01 Zhuu wrote:
This thread needs to be deleted.
This is why I actually supported the "give SNSD their own thread like Naruto and Bleach" argument a couple months back. Because shit like this happens.
On January 01 2013 23:08 kakaman wrote:SNSD producers biting off of Kanye's concept. 3 songs in 1? Been there done that. + Show Spoiler +
It's funny cause Ye actually did compose the instrumentals for his own part separately from the instrumentals for the rest of the song, so it was deliberate on his part. Probably not true for this song?
On January 02 2013 05:58 wei2coolman wrote:
Please don't fucking compare this atrocious IGAB to fucking Bohemian Rhapsody. Jesus christ, freddie mercury is probably turning in his grave.
Seriously. I don't even care if people like the song but Queen is fucking untouchable. And that's not just for SNSD, that's for kpop as a whole.
On January 02 2013 06:40 Lonyo wrote:
2NE1 already did it, and it worked a lot better.
I really hope this isn't a "trend", like retro concepts in '11, cause I really hate this/2ne1's style/concept or whatever.
|
Roffles
Pitcairn19291 Posts
I'm glad some people are starting to come to their senses. Thread's always entertaining when SNSD releases a new song.
|
On January 02 2013 05:58 wei2coolman wrote:
Please don't fucking compare this atrocious IGAB to fucking Bohemian Rhapsody. Jesus christ, freddie mercury is probably turning in his grave.
Could this be added to the rules >.>.
IGaB just sounds...too disjointed for me, like all the parts sound ok on their own, except maybe the gangsta rap at the start, but the rest gets ruined by awkward transitions.
And the live was good, I liked the ballads and covers, IGaB is still terrible song wise, but at least watching the lives will be better then watching the MV -.- .
|
You know... if you cut out the intro and the random bit towards the mid/end where it goes downtempo, it's STILL a 3:40 song.
I wonder what we might see in music show performances... since they don't always play full versions of songs.
http://soundcloud.com/lonyo/01-i-got-a-boy-short
Cut out the intro, the bit at the start, and the bit at the mid/end, all only roughly.
Now it's just 2:30 of somewhat samey-ness.
|
Some people just like to create hateful comments. This is Pop music, SNSD is on the 'good side' of things generally.
I agree I can't compare the songs with each other but you guys attack me for nothing. My point with Queen is what you guys skip entirely and just flame, this community... lols, almost 9yo. It's about the fact that Bohemian is totally fucking random, like sooooo random. And fyi random =/= bad incase some people jump to conclusions again. It's useless to defend something that's hated so hard. I just thought that I had a decent point so I posted but people stomp it right down anyways.
edit* am I the only one that finds this funny? Bunch of hypocrites
On January 02 2013 07:24 Sunaj wrote:Show nested quote +On January 02 2013 05:58 wei2coolman wrote:
Please don't fucking compare this atrocious IGAB to fucking Bohemian Rhapsody IGaB just sounds...too disjointed for me
Bohemian Rhapsody is totally jointed :D
|
On January 02 2013 07:35 Sableyeah wrote:
Some people just like to create hateful comments. This is Pop music, SNSD is on the 'good side' of things generally.
I agree I can't compare the songs with each other but you guys attack me for nothing. My point with Queen is what you guys skip entirely and just flame, this community... lols, almost 9yo. It's about the fact that Bohemian is totally fucking random, like sooooo random. And fyi random =/= bad incase some people jump to conclusions again. It's useless to defend something that's hated so hard. I just thought that I had a decent point so I posted but people stomp it right down anyways.
Bohemian is random in a way that feels both deliberate and good/catchy.
Ok you can argue good/catchy for SNSD's new song but I don't feel it.
and it's still not even comparable.
As for your first line, the thing that always gets me is that, yes, troll "FUCK SNSD" comments are bad, but SONEs respond by saying that ANYONE who didn't like the song are haters/trolls and that's not true either...some people just don't like the song.
And I feel like I say this every release but guess what? People in this thread tell their honest opinions about every release. The bigger the release, the more people view it and post about it. SNSD is the biggest group out there. They get the most opinions. Big fanbases are going to have the most trolls. Ignore the trolls. But a lot of pro-SNSD comments in this thread seem to ignore that plenty of other releases get negative reviews from this thread too and they're not "trolling". They just don't fucking like the song. There's a difference.
|
Are you seriously trying to compare IGAB to a rock opera masterpiece and expect not to be ridiculed? Need new modnote on top 'never compare any kpop music to Queen, ever'
|
Was wondering if its just me but recently embedded youtube videos don't work for me. I can watch them on youtube though.
|
|
|
|
|
Oh... okey I'm gonna stop comparing apples to oranges, or apples to architecture or apples to gold, or apples to stories. I don't care at all what you compare something with, it's the reason that matters, and the reason was damn good, it is random just that SNSD did terrible, and Queen did great.
|
Cool, sooo Jing during Mystic White:
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/JPx8v.jpg)
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
