|
If you come in here looking for "anime recommendations" then please refer to this chart before posting: Anime Recommendations (as of may 2014). We also have an IRC channel called #tladt where we all hang out. The channel is on Rizon, not QuakeNet! Feel free to check it out. TLADT discord is Discord.ggFor currently airing anime, please see Anichart.net |
On February 19 2013 12:00 Meiya wrote:
LoGH, I have all the episodes saved but I have no idea how I'm going to get around to watching that many episodes...
Just started working on my backlog after a few weeks of no watching, I'm on ep. 17 of Hyouka from a few seasons ago. A lot of people liked it and it has fantastic art and animation, but my lord it is boring the hell out of me...
That's a pretty accurate description of the show.
|
Canada4481 Posts
On February 19 2013 12:22 killa_robot wrote:Show nested quote +On February 19 2013 12:00 Meiya wrote:
LoGH, I have all the episodes saved but I have no idea how I'm going to get around to watching that many episodes...
Just started working on my backlog after a few weeks of no watching, I'm on ep. 17 of Hyouka from a few seasons ago. A lot of people liked it and it has fantastic art and animation, but my lord it is boring the hell out of me... I never understood why people watched some animes solely because of art and animation.
Because anime is a VISUAL medium.
|
For me, it kind of depends.
There is still a level of appreciation for the art and animation styles in various anime that I believe has merit, especially since anime is really the only place to experience it. Animated movies in the states has more or less disappeared in favor of CGI. I don't really have TV, but outside of Avatar, I really don't know what else has decent animation and art on TV anymore, because family guy and whatnot sure aren't worth mentioning in that department, imo.
However, I haven't had much issue getting through anime on a weekly basis, but some of them I would dread marathoning. Hyouka was fine on a weekly basis, but I dunno of marathoning it would be that fun.
|
On February 19 2013 12:27 Nagisama wrote:Show nested quote +On February 19 2013 12:22 killa_robot wrote:On February 19 2013 12:00 Meiya wrote:
LoGH, I have all the episodes saved but I have no idea how I'm going to get around to watching that many episodes...
Just started working on my backlog after a few weeks of no watching, I'm on ep. 17 of Hyouka from a few seasons ago. A lot of people liked it and it has fantastic art and animation, but my lord it is boring the hell out of me... I never understood why people watched some animes solely because of art and animation. Because anime is a VISUAL medium.
I think the word solely is important there. -3-
|
Art/scenery and animation is always a plus but for me characters, plot (if applicable for specific show) and audio/music is more important. Music maybe a bit less so, since in the end it too is like icing on the cake.
Or icing on a turd in the case of Guilty Crown.
|
On February 19 2013 12:34 Elem wrote:
Art/scenery and animation is always a plus but for me characters, plot (if applicable for specific show) and audio/music is more important. Music maybe a bit less so, since in the end it too is like icing on the cake.
Or icing on a turd in the case of Guilty Crown.
We were set up by the music.
|
konadora
Singapore66170 Posts
Is "Another" a good show? I happened to come across it on YT so I'm wondering if I should watch it (12 episodes) or finally start watching SAO (which apparently is very good? o_O)
|
On February 19 2013 12:49 konadora wrote:
Is "Another" a good show? I happened to come across it on YT so I'm wondering if I should watch it (12 episodes) or finally start watching SAO (which apparently is very good? o_O)
Another is a great comedy.
SAO is a great action/drama/romance/mystery/adventure/psychological/deep/dark/pretentious/comedy/sci-fi/fantasy/supernatural story. It excels at everything!
+ Show Spoiler +You're better off watching neither of them, though at the very least SAO is a fun watch because it has some nice animation and fight scenes + Yuki Kajiura, though I'd argue that Kajiura's tracks in this anime were pretty subpar and lacking.
|
On February 19 2013 13:03 Zergneedsfood wrote:Show nested quote +On February 19 2013 12:49 konadora wrote:
Is "Another" a good show? I happened to come across it on YT so I'm wondering if I should watch it (12 episodes) or finally start watching SAO (which apparently is very good? o_O) Another is a great comedy. SAO is a great action/drama/romance/mystery/adventure/psychological/deep/dark/pretentious/comedy/sci-fi/fantasy/supernatural story. It excels at everything! + Show Spoiler +You're better off watching neither of them, though at the very least SAO is a fun watch because it has some nice animation and fight scenes + Yuki Kajiura, though I'd argue that Kajiura's tracks in this anime were pretty subpar and lacking.
Well Kajiura said at AX that she writes the music based off like rough scripts of the scenes so she probably looked at them and was confused by how bad the writing was so the music was subpar as a result.
|
On February 19 2013 12:29 Zergneedsfood wrote:Show nested quote +On February 19 2013 12:27 Nagisama wrote:On February 19 2013 12:22 killa_robot wrote:On February 19 2013 12:00 Meiya wrote:
LoGH, I have all the episodes saved but I have no idea how I'm going to get around to watching that many episodes...
Just started working on my backlog after a few weeks of no watching, I'm on ep. 17 of Hyouka from a few seasons ago. A lot of people liked it and it has fantastic art and animation, but my lord it is boring the hell out of me... I never understood why people watched some animes solely because of art and animation. Because anime is a VISUAL medium. I think the word solely is important there. -3-
Exactly lol. It's cool if you think an anime looks nice and if you like it for that, but to ONLY watch it because it looks nice just doesn't make sense to me.
|
On February 19 2013 12:49 konadora wrote:
Is "Another" a good show? I happened to come across it on YT so I'm wondering if I should watch it (12 episodes) or finally start watching SAO (which apparently is very good? o_O)
Never watched Another, but SAO is pretty bad. The first half had horrible pacing issues, and the second half was just laughably bad. But its nice to look at, at least.
|
Just watched the Battle Royale movie (after reading the manga). The movie was pretty lacking compared to the manga. But I guess you can only fit that much in a movie. The movie also had its WTF moments...
|
On February 19 2013 12:49 konadora wrote:
Is "Another" a good show? I happened to come across it on YT so I'm wondering if I should watch it (12 episodes) or finally start watching SAO (which apparently is very good? o_O)
Don't listen to what other people say, just watch and decide for yourself. If you enjoy/like both of then, good for you!
|
On February 19 2013 12:34 Elem wrote:
Art/scenery and animation is always a plus but for me characters, plot (if applicable for specific show) and audio/music is more important. Music maybe a bit less so, since in the end it too is like icing on the cake.
Or icing on a turd in the case of Guilty Crown.
For me, anime is just like food or any other piece of art. The components help me think or talk about the piece, but how I feel is ultimately determined by how I absorb the gestalt.
So usually if any one part is glaringly awful or even incompatible with the rest, I have a negative reaction to the whole.
|
On February 19 2013 14:47 OutlaW- wrote:Show nested quote +On February 19 2013 12:49 konadora wrote:
Is "Another" a good show? I happened to come across it on YT so I'm wondering if I should watch it (12 episodes) or finally start watching SAO (which apparently is very good? o_O) Don't listen to what other people say, just watch and decide for yourself. If you enjoy/like both of then, good for you!
That's fine and all, but uhhh, he sorta explicitly asked for other people's opinions, so saying "Don't listen to any of the answers you get for your question" is kinda a bad response to what he asked. Plus, of course he would decide for himself if he likes them or not, lol.
|
I cant say Another was good, because it wasnt. The scares were pretty bad and the plot points never got explained. Pretty good example of how NOT to do a mystery horror. You're better off watching Higurashi which was actually good imo.
|
On February 19 2013 15:09 Sentenal wrote:Show nested quote +On February 19 2013 14:47 OutlaW- wrote:On February 19 2013 12:49 konadora wrote:
Is "Another" a good show? I happened to come across it on YT so I'm wondering if I should watch it (12 episodes) or finally start watching SAO (which apparently is very good? o_O) Don't listen to what other people say, just watch and decide for yourself. If you enjoy/like both of then, good for you! That's fine and all, but uhhh, he sorta explicitly asked for other people's opinions, so saying "Don't listen to any of the answers you get for your question" is kinda a bad response to what he asked. Plus, of course he would decide for himself if he likes them or not, lol.
Yeah, but at least for me, I don't like reading other peoples opinions on shows because I either think its considered shit (this makes the show worse for me) or my expectations of it get high which also makes the show worse than it could have been.
If he's not like that, good for him! But there's the possibility if he simply wanted to know whether the shows are worth his time or not.
|
On February 19 2013 15:28 OutlaW- wrote:Show nested quote +On February 19 2013 15:09 Sentenal wrote:On February 19 2013 14:47 OutlaW- wrote:On February 19 2013 12:49 konadora wrote:
Is "Another" a good show? I happened to come across it on YT so I'm wondering if I should watch it (12 episodes) or finally start watching SAO (which apparently is very good? o_O) Don't listen to what other people say, just watch and decide for yourself. If you enjoy/like both of then, good for you! That's fine and all, but uhhh, he sorta explicitly asked for other people's opinions, so saying "Don't listen to any of the answers you get for your question" is kinda a bad response to what he asked. Plus, of course he would decide for himself if he likes them or not, lol. Yeah, but at least for me, I don't like reading other peoples opinions on shows because I either think its considered shit (this makes the show worse for me) or my expectations of it get high which also makes the show worse than it could have been. If he's not like that, good for him! But there's the possibility if he simply wanted to know whether the shows are worth his time or not.
Honestly, I think people should go into any anime, regardless of what it is, with low expectations. The easiest way to enjoy an anime is to have low expectations, and then find its better than what you thought. Similarly, the easiest way to not enjoy an anime is to have high expectations, and then get disappointed.
|
On February 19 2013 15:37 Sentenal wrote:Show nested quote +On February 19 2013 15:28 OutlaW- wrote:On February 19 2013 15:09 Sentenal wrote:On February 19 2013 14:47 OutlaW- wrote:On February 19 2013 12:49 konadora wrote:
Is "Another" a good show? I happened to come across it on YT so I'm wondering if I should watch it (12 episodes) or finally start watching SAO (which apparently is very good? o_O) Don't listen to what other people say, just watch and decide for yourself. If you enjoy/like both of then, good for you! That's fine and all, but uhhh, he sorta explicitly asked for other people's opinions, so saying "Don't listen to any of the answers you get for your question" is kinda a bad response to what he asked. Plus, of course he would decide for himself if he likes them or not, lol. Yeah, but at least for me, I don't like reading other peoples opinions on shows because I either think its considered shit (this makes the show worse for me) or my expectations of it get high which also makes the show worse than it could have been. If he's not like that, good for him! But there's the possibility if he simply wanted to know whether the shows are worth his time or not. Honestly, I think people should go into any anime, regardless of what it is, with low expectations. The easiest way to enjoy an anime is to have low expectations, and then find its better than what you thought. Similarly, the easiest way to not enjoy an anime is to have high expectations, and then get disappointed.
good idea
|
What do you guys think about Mirai Nikki. I just started watching it and while I have a few mild complaints I still enjoyed it.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
