EPT[TV/BOOK] *SPOILERS* Game of Thrones Discussion - Page 370
| Forum Index > Media & Entertainment |
SPOILER WARNING If you only watch the show, this thread will spoil you of future events in HBO's Game of Thrones. Thread contains discussion of all books of the series A Song of Ice and Fire Click Here for the spoiler-free thread. | ||
|
Asol
Sweden109 Posts
| ||
Flyingdutchman
Netherlands858 Posts
On June 05 2013 05:33 SamsungStar wrote: Wait, WHAT? That makes ZERO sense. How exactly would Tywin's wife getting raped on her wedding night lead to the birth of Tyrion the THIRD of Tywin's children? Or did people forget that Tyrion's birth led to the death of Tywin's wife?? Did Joanna birth Cersei and Jaimie from the grave then? What kind of monkey shit is this? It's not even theoretically possible. Aerys took liberties in the bedding cerimony, so basically copping a feel or two. Planting Tyrion in there would have happened a lot later obviously. | ||
|
Carras
Argentina860 Posts
also, they just show how 3 guys go into Meeren and kill 10 guys, next scene they announce the city is taken... i liked the Jon and Bran/Rickon scenes much more, and i usally hate those.. | ||
|
Maxyim
430 Posts
I doubt that Tyrion is a Targ, although I would not put it past GRRM to make it happen. More likely is that he will end up riding a dragon because of his weight / need for vantage point. | ||
|
rrdz
United States20 Posts
| ||
|
youngminii
Australia7514 Posts
Watching it was... awkward... It was more of an "uhh wtf..............." than an "OMG I CAN'T BELIEVE THIS" The whole scene was pretty sub-par with some exceptions (Catelyn in particular was great). | ||
|
jigga
Canada1141 Posts
On June 05 2013 08:25 youngminii wrote: While I was happy that the Red Wedding wasn't completely shit, I was hoping it would be a lot better. With the books my head was rushing as I was frantically reading, couldn't stop until I completed that (and the next few) chapters. Reading it was exhilarating. Watching it was... awkward... It was more of an "uhh wtf..............." than an "OMG I CAN'T BELIEVE THIS" The whole scene was pretty sub-par with some exceptions (Catelyn in particular was great). I think a big part of the reason is because you have read the books and know what is coming. The tension building up to it was amazing, but I felt the same way about the event itself (slightly underwhelmed). However, after looking at the reaction videos and all the "backlash" online, I can safely say that the Red Wedding did its job well. The tv viewers would have had the same feelings as a first time book reader. Some scenes were awkward at first viewing (like Cat just standing there shocked for 10 seconds before some random Frey slits her throat), but on second viewing you realise it was done that way for dramatic effect. | ||
|
Sabu113
United States11075 Posts
I guess how they did it made sense but for some reason I was expecting a lot more noise and chaos. I guess it was shocking enough for the nnewbies though. | ||
|
jinorazi
Korea (South)4948 Posts
On June 05 2013 08:56 Sabu113 wrote: Red Wedding was solid. Catelyn's actor was good. I guess how they did it made sense but for some reason I was expecting a lot more noise and chaos. I guess it was shocking enough for the nnewbies though. book readers should always keep in mind there is a budget to meet. little details here and there could have been done, more people, bigger set, more cgi, lightning flashing as they fought, brann's group walking across under water platform to the tower, heavy rain with visibility through flashes of lightning, grey wind killing few man at the wedding, etc. but it'll increase cost. | ||
|
kidleaderr
365 Posts
| ||
|
Zozo
Brazil2579 Posts
| ||
|
LilClinkin
Australia667 Posts
I do wish they showed an oblique side-on shot of Bolton stabbing Robb through the heart though. | ||
|
Dfgj
Singapore5922 Posts
On June 05 2013 08:25 youngminii wrote: While I was happy that the Red Wedding wasn't completely shit, I was hoping it would be a lot better. With the books my head was rushing as I was frantically reading, couldn't stop until I completed that (and the next few) chapters. Reading it was exhilarating. Watching it was... awkward... It was more of an "uhh wtf..............." than an "OMG I CAN'T BELIEVE THIS" The whole scene was pretty sub-par with some exceptions (Catelyn in particular was great). It's almost like you already knew what was going to happen and no longer had the same emotional investment or sense of shock! | ||
|
FrostedMiniWheats
United States30730 Posts
On June 05 2013 11:12 Zozo wrote: I like how Michelle Fairley has been giving interviews and even announced a new role right after Cat's death. Little do they know... I'm wondering if Fairley will even play Stoneheart. Given her disfigured appearance, and the fact that she does not speak would you even need the same actor? Though I would like her to, I liked her as Catelyn. | ||
|
Lord Tolkien
United States12083 Posts
On June 05 2013 11:12 Zozo wrote: I like how Michelle Fairley has been giving interviews and even announced a new role right after Cat's death. Little do they know... Episode 10 is titled after a fictional Ghiscari word for "Mother". I wonder... | ||
|
FrostedMiniWheats
United States30730 Posts
On June 05 2013 11:46 Lord Tolkien wrote: Episode 10 is titled after a fictional Ghiscari word for "Mother". I wonder... It'd be wayyy to soon to reveal her I'd say. I mean they could but that ruins the shock of it all. You need more time to miss Catelyn and not expect it, thinking she's long dead. Actually, despite it not quite happening at this point in the book I'm wondering if they'll just skip right to Joffrey's death. The "Mother" title is either for Cersei's maternal fury at the sight of her son dying, or Daenery's image as a motherly figure to the liberated slaves (she's supposed to finish up her conquest of Yunkai next episode). Maybe both even.. | ||
|
SKC
Brazil18828 Posts
Joffrey's death still need more development imo. It's more likely they will do both next season though. | ||
|
Mataru
Norway356 Posts
| ||
|
NPF
Canada1635 Posts
On June 05 2013 11:59 SKC wrote: I think it will make more sense to show UnCat's revival than Joffrey's death. She doesn't appear until much later one, but her actual revival could be done much soone than that. It takes away some of the surprise, but also would be much more unexpected, since less people will be spoiled and you won't have issues as the people knowing the actress was casted for that season. Joffrey's death still need more development imo. It's more likely they will do both next season though. I'm betting Joefrey dies first episode of season 4. Get all the people that stopped watching after the last episode get back into the show fast with the news of Joeffrey demise. That's how I see it. As for mother, I'm thinking more about Danny, since didn't Dario give her a a quilt of her being a virgin marie mother like woman.... | ||
|
itkovian
United States1763 Posts
On June 04 2013 23:08 zatic wrote: Martells so far have been entirely useless. I mean the grand scheme of Doran was to keep peace with the Lannisters until Quentin can secure the dragons? This brilliant plan kind of failed when Quentin traveled over half the world only to get laughed at by Dany and then roasted by her dragons. GG great strat. At this point this entire story arc could just be cut without any impact on any of the other story lines. That was the most disappointing story arcs for me in the series. They wait so long to introduce the mysterious Quenten, and the only thing you really hear about him beforehand is how he's being groomed for an important mission. And with a mind like Doran behind it, you feel like its going to have a legitimate chance at working. And then you're finally introduced to him, and his character is so unfulfilling and unexceptional. And then he dies. Random thought about the show: why don't they ever show Tyrell guards? It seems like that would be an easy way to display Tyrell power. | ||
| ||
