| Forum Index > Brood War Tournaments |
|
KazeHydra
Japan2788 Posts
On February 16 2013 09:06 EchOne wrote: If puppykiller is joining we'd like to recruit snipinpanda and Wala.Revolution as well. They've both been inactive for almost a year now. Can we also recruit Fold if he offraces? :D I've beaten his zerg so clearly it's D- level. | ||
|
arb
Noobville17922 Posts
On February 16 2013 09:27 puppykiller wrote: Hey guys BIGsandwich88 will stay out of ace matches if it makes you feel more comfortable. As for his skill level... he fluctuates. He's managed to take two games off of C terrans before but he's also lost to d- players before (even recently) too. He's really hit and miss depending on his opponents play style. Ill send a few of his reps if its needed. this guy talking in the third person l0l | ||
|
puppykiller
United States3137 Posts
| ||
|
Pyre_Fly
United Kingdom31 Posts
ICCUP account: PyreflY Race: TvZ, TvP, ZvT | ||
|
Sentenal
United States12398 Posts
On February 16 2013 06:57 L_Master wrote: Yea, I don't think any of those teams need more players. My plan for the draft (feedback is good btw) is basically to gather up the captains in skype and have them alternate from the pool of players. Pick order would be either 1,2,3,1,2,3 or 1,2,3,3,2,1. As of now there are two or three teams that have a couple players to them, if it stayed that way I would get all the people that are captaining and have them decide amongst them who still wants to captain, and then merge teams until we have a matching number of teams as their are draftable players (i.e. if we end up with 20 players not assigned to a full size team we would pick two captains, merge "mini-teams" and draft from there. Drafting priority would probably be scaled based on team size. Needs to be 1,2,3,3,2,1, no question about it. 1,2,3,1,2,3 would be fine if there was seeding or ranking for the draft, but if its supposed to be fair to all teams involved, no other way but 123321. | ||
|
Prince_Stranger
Kazakhstan762 Posts
So now our team: Phoenix ProForward  (Captain)sonic1991  herokiller__  _Animus_ SNSD. PM me who wants to join us. | ||
|
Cpt.beefy
Ireland799 Posts
| ||
|
Prince_Stranger
Kazakhstan762 Posts
On February 16 2013 15:08 Cpt.beefy wrote: wtf.... ? | ||
|
Sinedd
Poland7052 Posts
 NW Power - 1. OpalonaLufa - P (Cpt) 2. BLATERO - P 3. NeBu - T 4. kura90 - Z 5. Siskin - P (v Cpt) 6. Freedom - P 7. MoreAndMore - Z 8. Sprite - P 9. Star-10 - P 10. Maciej - P 11. Cuber - Z 12. Zbignieff2 - P 13. Szafa92 - T 14. TakiJeden - T yo ! + Show Spoiler + the lineup may change a little in near future | ||
|
Zergneedsfood
United States10671 Posts
| ||
Nagisama
Canada4481 Posts
I feel that drafting hasn't really worked in a long time, since maybe DRTL2. The teams needing players just simply ask the free agents before the actual drafting starts and then the pool simply disappears before draft. This is a bit early to say considering we still have 3 weeks til start of the season, but perhaps have AtomicArchon join one of the two teams ACE/Phoenix and have the remaining free agents divided between them would make 6 strong teams. Instead of waiting on almost 2 more teams worth of free agents to join in. We could wait on it for another week or so before deciding that, but just throwing out that possibility. | ||
|
SynC[gm]
United States3127 Posts
On February 17 2013 00:35 Nagisama wrote: I feel that drafting hasn't really worked in a long time, since maybe DRTL2. The teams needing players just simply ask the free agents before the actual drafting starts and then the pool simply disappears before draft. This is a bit early to say considering we still have 3 weeks til start of the season, but perhaps have AtomicArchon join one of the two teams ACE/Phoenix and have the remaining free agents divided between them would make 6 strong teams. Instead of waiting on almost 2 more teams worth of free agents to join in. We could wait on it for another week or so before deciding that, but just throwing out that possibility. Unfortunately, there's also SunKan with pebble, thezansuric, and probably BaBo, and a couple others I can't remember... Hopefully they'll be willing to merge as well. AtomicArchon + Phoenix and SunKan + Airforce? But at the same time, I'm sure some of these guys want to have their own teams and just stick with their own guys... Right now, we have TAKK, Stealth Bunnies, Courage, Airforce Ace of Spades, DeSPA, SunKan, Phoenix, and NW Power... Players at the moment: DeSPA - 1 Airforce Ace of Spades - 6 Phoenix - 5 Courage - 10 Stealth Bunnies - 10 TAKK - 13 NW Power - 14 SunKan - ? (but they did they say they were signing up...) | ||
|
pebble444
Italy2503 Posts
About these discussions here is my opinion: I don' t think puppykiller shoud be allowed to play (nothing personal just your rank). Offracing has been discussed and everybody i saw agrees on that. I would like very much to have Ace matches, why remove them? they are exciting and cool Another suggestion consider adding one or two BWMN maps to the map pool. About the teams, more than the number of teams, i have an opinion about the players: TAKK is full of well known regular players that play often. I think it would hurt the league that so many regular players are in one team. If you want to go the 6 way team with bigger roosters, i would consider the possibility of merging ( but want to keep the team name Sun Kan) last thing: i think you should replace the how to sign up/who can sign up with the how to watch in the OP (i mean switch them in position). and maybe add the allready signed up roosters to the OP. | ||
|
SynC[gm]
United States3127 Posts
On February 17 2013 01:47 pebble444 wrote: Can' t commit yet there is still a couple weeks, probaby yes but don' t set it in stone. To me the most important part is having the games all played. If we do sign up its Mellial (aka thezarnursic) and me for sure, maybe Babo and Gorg, and XKCD if he wants to re-sign up with us (given he was on our team before if he wants he should be allowed before the draft) . About these discussions here is my opinion: I don' t think puppykiller shoud be allowed to play (nothing personal just your rank). Offracing has been discussed and everybody i saw agrees on that. I would like very much to have Ace matches, why remove them? they are exciting and cool Another suggestion consider adding one or two BWMN maps to the map pool. About the teams, more than the number of teams, i have an opinion about the players: TAKK is full of well known regular players that play often. I think it would hurt the league that so many regular players are in one team. If you want to go the 6 way team with bigger roosters, i would consider the possibility of merging ( but want to keep the team name Sun Kan) last thing: i think you should replace the how to sign up/who can sign up with the how to watch in the OP (i mean switch them in position). and maybe add the allready signed up roosters to the OP. I'm sure puppykiller won't be allowed to play, but if he's serious about wanting to act as a coach, that'd be a great idea. I think L3gendary recommended adding a BWMN map or two to L_Master, so we'll see. I think one of the recommendations was Gemlong and a 3-player map, I'm not sure. Edit: Also, the teams that are already signed up are listed in Liquipedia here. | ||
|
Sinedd
Poland7052 Posts
1. OpalonaLufa - P (Cpt) 2. BLATERO - P 3. NeBu - T 4. kura90 - Z 5. Siskin - P (v Cpt) 6. Freedom - P 7. MoreAndMore - Z 8. Sprite - P 9. Star-10 - P 10. Maciej - P 11. Cuber - Z 12. Zbignieff2 - P 13. Szafa92 - T 14. TakiJeden - T 15. Ali.G - P 16. From0ToHero - Z we are ready to go !!! YYYIIIIHAA ! | ||
|
chrisolo
Germany2610 Posts
On February 17 2013 00:35 Nagisama wrote: I feel that drafting hasn't really worked in a long time, since maybe DRTL2. The teams needing players just simply ask the free agents before the actual drafting starts and then the pool simply disappears before draft. This is a bit early to say considering we still have 3 weeks til start of the season, but perhaps have AtomicArchon join one of the two teams ACE/Phoenix and have the remaining free agents divided between them would make 6 strong teams. Instead of waiting on almost 2 more teams worth of free agents to join in. We could wait on it for another week or so before deciding that, but just throwing out that possibility. Did you think the drafting in DRATL was bad too? I thought I done the best I could. If you think it was bad, could you give feedback for a possible draft in a possible future DRATL 2 (tho DRTL 4 and 5 will have priority and maybe even DRTL 6)? It is hard to improve these things without any kind of feedback. Maybe LMaster will be able to improve his drafting for this DRTL too with your feedback ^_^? | ||
|
From0ToHero
Poland1 Post
Rank: D ICCUP account: From0ToHero Race: Z | ||
|
SynC[gm]
United States3127 Posts
| ||
|
Nagisama
Canada4481 Posts
On February 17 2013 19:14 chrisolo wrote: Did you think the drafting in DRATL was bad too? I thought I done the best I could. If you think it was bad, could you give feedback for a possible draft in a possible future DRATL 2 (tho DRTL 4 and 5 will have priority and maybe even DRTL 6)? It is hard to improve these things without any kind of feedback. Maybe LMaster will be able to improve his drafting for this DRTL too with your feedback ^_^? I don't think it was terrible, but it had it's pros/cons for being a draft in the thread. Similarly, a Skype call with the captains also has pros/cons. Drafting in the thread is visible to everyone who sees it and also doesn't force team captains to a specific time to draft, but may be slow since people don't check the thread regularly. Skype drafting is faster, can probably be done in a few mins, but you need to find some agreed upon time that fits a bunch of people's schedules, it's a bit more private and results get posted afterwards, so it's not that bad. The main problem I found with the draft is that free agents are just being picked up pre-draft, and after a week or 2 when it's actually draft time, you have basically have no free agents left to draft. There isn't any rule saying they're not allowed to be picked up pre-draft as well. This leads to some more active captains actively going out and asking free agents if they want to join their team, and then they'll post later saying roster updated etc. This isn't necessarily a bad thing because I know teams need players, and it's best if the players are actually in a team they want to be in as opposed to being randomly stuff into a team. However, some captains will think, they should just wait for the draft, and will then feel shafted when they see free agents disappearing, and they may start picking up free agents themselves too. This just leads to a not-really draft-like end, and more of a, "ok we have like 0-3 players left as free agents for a draft, lets just put them on whoever needs them more". The other option is to have new players that sign up, specifically say they want to be free agents, and implementing some rule that they're off limits til the actual draft. Any new players to the league with a specific team they want to join, could probably state that when they first post their intentions to join, or have the team captain post on their behalf when they bring out their roster. This would have a bigger draft pool, and likely reduce the likeliness of new players being picked up pre-draft and perhaps a more balanced drafting. Either way, both types of draft end up with players on the teams that need them, which is good. The bad is that captains get shafted in not being able to pick players they had an eye on because they actually waited for the draft time, while other captains just ignored draft time and picked them up. Both are fine and can be implemented, just let the captains know specifically whether or not they're allowed to just randomly pick up free agents. Note: The captains I'm referring to are those on the teams that need the players. It's already obvious the bigger teams that are already fine on their own, don't need to draft, and they probably won't anyways because they know that. | ||
|
Cpt.beefy
Ireland799 Posts
On February 18 2013 00:37 Nagisama wrote: The bad is that captains get shafted in not being able to pick players they had an eye on because they actually waited for the draft time, while other captains just ignored draft time and picked them up. ..... exactly. | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War GuemChi Dota 2 4655Rain 3989Tasteless 136Leta  136ZergMaN  29Bale 28IntoTheRainbow 26Noble 26Icarus 7League of Legends Counter-Strike Super Smash Bros Other Games |
|
WardiTV Weekly
PiGosaur Cup
The PondCast
Replay Cast
CrankTV Team League
OSC
Replay Cast
Replay Cast
CrankTV Team League
OSC
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
