| Forum Index > Brood War Tournaments |
|
tfeign
United States2980 Posts
On November 10 2005 09:33 mnm wrote: we don't live in the real world buddy. It doesn't mean that we have to make it more fake. Lurker hold is not a bug. Why should you not be able to tell your lurker not to attack until you want it to? PGT allows lurker hold, WGT allows lurker hold. Every Korean league allows lurker hold. It's not that big of a deal though so whatever | ||
Insane
United States4991 Posts
 | ||
|
SolaR-
United States2685 Posts
| ||
|
mnm
United States4493 Posts
Now regardless of whether or not you are going, I'd like feedback on this matter. Why is the hold lurker bug accepted but others arent? I think the big reason why these bugs are not allowed is because even if some people think its ok, there are also some people who don't think it is. Thus, to even things out, it isn't allowed just so nobody would complain of unfairness. One example is that bug where reaver scarab upgrades were able to be upgraded more times than intended and a lot of people thought it was unfair that reach did this at the blizzcon match and wondered why blizzard didn't do anything about it. This is a bug that occurs in this particular map and any protoss player could do it. Why is this case unfair and not others? Along those lines, why is it fair that Nada was allowed to push his mnms through the mineral line with his barracks in his game vs yellow. This is also a bug but it is accepted by people and even thought of as pimpest play. Why is this case fair and not others? | ||
|
collegeBored
United States1524 Posts
sc engine allows 200upgrades (i think, whatever the number is) so it depends on how u intend the map to work. in blizzcon's particular case it was a MAP bug, not a game bug. flying templar wasnt meant to be in the game. period allied mines arent always possible (1v1 mode) thus its an illegal manipulation of the game stacked peons are only supposed to happen when in process of gathering resources. thus peon defense vs ling/zlot or whatever is fine, however when they run off stacked and kill your shit its an obvious bug. turret bug is the only thing im unsure about. because logicaly its possible that in that particular spot turret cannot target the obs, however the fact that it cant target any other shit shows that its prolly a bug. hold lurkers are always possible, make perfect sense, and can be a game winning move, why would anyone argue against it? | ||
Liquid`Jinro
Sweden33719 Posts
| ||
|
cava
United States1035 Posts
| ||
|
mnm
United States4493 Posts
Do you think allied mines should be allowed? Why or why not? Do you think stacked peons should be allowed? Why or why not? Do you think the OL/lurk stop position should be allowed? Why or why not? Do you think turret stalling should be allowed? Why or why not? Do you think flying templar should be allowed? Why or why not? Please answer all and not just one. kthx. | ||
|
dronebabo
10866 Posts
| ||
|
mnm
United States4493 Posts
| ||
|
HappyManRun
1111 Posts
| ||
|
mnm
United States4493 Posts
| ||
|
nvnplatypus
Netherlands1300 Posts
| ||
|
St3MoR
Spain3256 Posts
| ||
|
hasuprotoss
United States4612 Posts
On November 10 2005 15:55 mnm wrote: Do you think allied mines should be allowed? Why or why not? No, you have to open a menu to get to how you do it. On November 10 2005 15:55 mnm wrote:Do you think stacked peons should be allowed? Why or why not? If it is where you defend with them and they just get in the way, sure why not? You don't really have to do anything out of the way to do it, and it might be the only possible way to stop a rush you weren't expecting. On November 10 2005 15:55 mnm wrote:Do you think the OL/lurk stop position should be allowed? Why or why not? Yes, you can do it to a peon, you can do it to a lurker. Also, you don't have to really go out of your way to get your lurkers to hold position. On November 10 2005 15:55 mnm wrote:Do you think turret stalling should be allowed? Why or why not? No only one unit can do this. On November 10 2005 15:55 mnm wrote:Do you think flying templar should be allowed? Why or why not? No, this is obviously an exploit. You have to go out of your way to do it. Holding a turret is something only an obs can do. Holding position with something that doesn't have it on the menu is something that everybody can do. | ||
|
collegeBored
United States1524 Posts
On November 10 2005 15:25 cava wrote: hold lurkers is not a bug its the same thing as choking you ramp with say a zealot and a probe and hitting hold position. normally a probe cannot do this but with a zealot he can. Not a bug but simply the way the game works. quoted for truth. its EXACTLY the same thing | ||
|
mnm
United States4493 Posts
Disallowed bugs: Hydralisk Stack Allied Mines (using optical flare on them is fine) Observer on turret SCV/Drone/Probe stack Allowed bugs: Hold Lurker hmmm... (pgtour is down i cant check =/) btw, I added a poll on the front page. kthx. | ||
|
PanoRaMa
United States5069 Posts
I'll be in berkeley during thanksgiving weekend so i'll be there, despite the fact that I play war3  . Hope to have lots of fun, thanks to mnm for hosting this event, it takes a lot of effort. | ||
|
Blind
United States2529 Posts
The 1v1 tournament games should be played in "one on one" mode. The only reason they are made in UMS is so the judge can ob the game. It's still supposed to be played the same as the one on one mode. In this mode, you can not ally/vision/ally victory your opponent. In this mode, allied mines would not be possible, while hold (or stop) lurkers would still be possible. This is what I'd like to add on: Anyway, lurkers have the stop command, while mines do not. The game never intended for you to control when the mine detonates, but it does let you stop the lurker from attacking manually. | ||
|
mnm
United States4493 Posts
On November 10 2005 19:52 PanoRaMa wrote: aside from the lurker hold position debate, who from TL is going? I'll be in berkeley during thanksgiving weekend so i'll be there, despite the fact that I play war3 . Hope to have lots of fun, thanks to mnm for hosting this event, it takes a lot of effort.i have 7 ppl who are currently almost sure to go not including me but including you (counting from ppl who told me or ppl im gonna kill if they dont go.. i hope they dont change their minds later). 3 others that have a high likelihood of going. 9 people who are extremely flaky sounding maybes. 3 ppl who flat out rejected me. 9 people I havent heard from. and.. a few ppl here and there who said they might go in the diff forums but they didnt gimme their emails. My goal is 16 people. | ||
| ||
|
|
OSC
SKillous vs ArT
ArT vs Babymarine
NightMare vs TriGGeR
YoungYakov vs TBD
All-Star Invitational
INnoVation vs soO
Serral vs herO
Cure vs Solar
sOs vs Scarlett
Classic vs Clem
Reynor vs Maru
uThermal 2v2 Circuit
AI Arena Tournament
All-Star Invitational
MMA vs DongRaeGu
Rogue vs Oliveira
Sparkling Tuna Cup
OSC
Replay Cast
Wardi Open
Monday Night Weeklies
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
