EPTShould Idra B allowed to play in TSL? - Page 2
| Blogs > Rekrul |
Rekrul
Korea (South)17174 Posts
| ||
|
RLTY
United States965 Posts
and I don't have beyond A+ practice partners. | ||
|
Glaucus
479 Posts
On January 30 2010 13:24 Rekrul wrote: Where did Idra prove me wrong? I've never been proven wrong in my life!!!! Idra succeeding. And what about losing to Artosis and that boji car thread? | ||
|
Rekrul
Korea (South)17174 Posts
On January 30 2010 13:30 icemac wrote: and I don't have beyond A+ practice partners. You have jaedong vods man, just copy him. No way you'll lose. | ||
|
RLTY
United States965 Posts
On January 30 2010 13:31 Rekrul wrote: You have jaedong vods man, just copy him. No way you'll lose. Yea, that's why we're all A+ gosu. | ||
|
Rekrul
Korea (South)17174 Posts
On January 30 2010 13:31 Glaucus wrote: Idra succeeding. And what about losing to Artosis and that boji car thread? Idra succeeded the moment he stepped onto Korean soil. And "succeeding" is not only a very ambiguous word, but also one I never use in serious context or think about ever. | ||
|
Licmyobelisk
Philippines3682 Posts
| ||
|
Nick_54
United States2230 Posts
| ||
|
St3MoR
Spain3256 Posts
keep being yourself and contributing to our community, I apprecciate it and i'm sure many people does. | ||
|
ghrur
United States3786 Posts
I always knew I should eat more kimchi... | ||
|
hyst.eric.al
United States2332 Posts
| ||
|
Rekrul
Korea (South)17174 Posts
Little E-gangs ensuring ongoing domination for the people already at the top of the ladder. THATS NOT FAIR WAHH WAHH WAHHH YELLOW U DESERVE NONE OF UR TITLES o wait u have none | ||
micronesia
United States24660 Posts
"We simply did not want to stop someone from moving to Korea to pursue his dream of becoming a professional StarCraft player." This is the main justification behind letting Idra and a few others participate.... and even rewriting the eligibility rules to ensure it is permissible. This, coupled with offering to reward foreigners for long-term service to the foreigner community is the only reason given by TSL staff from what I've seen for why they are eligible. Supposing SC2 doesn't come out for a long time (not so far fetched lol) and the bw community continues to evolve, what we might find is more and more foreigners going to Korea and training like Idra and one or two others have done recently (granted it probably won't get better but bear with me). Eventually the level of 'foreigner' play eligible according to the current rules will be too high for anyone who doesn't go to train in Korea to compete with (imagine a tsl ladder with 100 Idras). Thus, this seems like an unsustainable system at its core for accomplishing the ultimate goals of the TSL. However, I don't anticipate this actually happening or there being many TSLs prior to sc2 so it isn't a big deal. Still, it is not a ridiculous argument to make that certain people shouldn't be allowed to participate (even if I want them to for personal reasons). edit: ninja quote: "fundamental point that pokerstrategy is sponsoring TSL for it to be a popular and fun event" I disagree. | ||
|
Rekrul
Korea (South)17174 Posts
And to those making the point that 'its racist to not let koreans play because ur letting idra play and he's in their same situation!' you are idiots too. Koreans polluting this tournament will not make it fun for the foreign audience. We already have the Korean leagues obviously. And the whole Ret ordeal has shown us Koreans are atleast a little bit racist, so fuck them anyways  | ||
|
RoieTRS
United States2569 Posts
| ||
|
Purind
Canada3562 Posts
On January 30 2010 13:28 valaki wrote: Imagine Idra winning OSL + being 70% in every matchup, should they still allow him to play? Nah just kidding, i've got nothing against Idra, let him play. He would still suck and be Artosis level, so yes he would still be allowed to play | ||
|
Saturnize
United States2473 Posts
| ||
|
Rekrul
Korea (South)17174 Posts
On January 30 2010 13:51 micronesia wrote: Funny rek, but to get somewhat serious... "We simply did not want to stop someone from moving to Korea to pursue his dream of becoming a professional StarCraft player." This is the main justification behind letting Idra and a few others participate.... and even rewriting the eligibility rules to ensure it is permissible. This, coupled with offering to reward foreigners for long-term service to the foreigner community is the only reason given by TSL staff from what I've seen for why they are eligible. Supposing SC2 doesn't come out for a long time (not so far fetched lol) and the bw community continues to evolve, what we might find is more and more foreigners going to Korea and training like Idra and one or two others have done recently (granted it probably won't get better but bear with me). Eventually the level of 'foreigner' play eligible according to the current rules will be too high for anyone who doesn't go to train in Korea to compete with (imagine a tsl ladder with 100 Idras). Thus, this seems like an unsustainable system at its core for accomplishing the ultimate goals of the TSL. However, I don't anticipate this actually happening or there being many TSLs prior to sc2 so it isn't a big deal. Still, it is not a ridiculous argument to make that certain people shouldn't be allowed to participate (even if I want them to for personal reasons). edit: ninja quote: "fundamental point that pokerstrategy is sponsoring TSL for it to be a popular and fun event" I disagree. I totally agree with you and as I know you know...thats just not the case right now. But yeah it's not far fetched at all to take certain things into consideration in the future if certain players could ruin the suspense and fun of a tournament. (But then again, if prizes are so big and events are so big we should look to the other foreign players to rise to the occasion and get better rather than focus on removing people who are too good...and well if the foreign players can't then thats just sad and don't know why ppl would throw so much money into events.) But right now? With Idra? Please ppl. He's still B-team, he hasn't qualified in any korean leagues yet. Maybe he is the favorite, but he is totally beatable by foreigners. And actually I truly believe the reason why IdrA has gone higher than the curve of foreigners in the past 2 years is not because he's living and playing with koreans, but merely a byproduct of that fact. It's the playing all day every day non stop that played the real role in him improving, rather than him playing those games against the koreans (of course that helps too but not the main factor imo). It's not Idra's fault all the top foreign players these days barely play compared to him. To punish him for slaving away for his 'dream' would be idiotic. | ||
|
Athos
United States2484 Posts
On January 30 2010 13:29 Rekrul wrote: I just find it hilarious how when big prizes start being given out everyone who is totally not effected by them start claiming idiotic justifications for why someone should not be allowed to play without realizing anything about anything. qft | ||
|
foxbearcheetah
United States50 Posts
On January 30 2010 13:53 Rekrul wrote: Instead of being little jealous idiots not wanting to see Harry Potter build his Hogwarts bankroll you should just support the tournament. hahahahha. honestly though, imagine a tournament without idra. he's one of the most exciting foreigners and the one i keep an eye on the most. aside from whether or not it is fair, banning a player should only be considered if it helps the overall foreigner scene and right now, i don't see how it even comes close. excluding idra would definitely hurt the legitimacy of any foreign tournament in my eyes. you see artosis posting these showmatches with korean b teamers to show that the skillgap between korea and the rest of the world is closing. saying idra is too good, or an autowin in any tournament would definitely be a step backwards. | ||
| ||
