• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EDT 09:46
CEST 15:46
KST 22:46
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
TL Team Map Contest #5: Presented by Monster Energy4Code S RO8 Preview: herO, Zoun, Bunny, Classic7Code S RO8 Preview: Rogue, GuMiho, Solar, Maru3BGE Stara Zagora 2025: Info & Preview27Code S RO12 Preview: GuMiho, Bunny, SHIN, ByuN3
Community News
Code S RO8 Results + RO4 Bracket (2025 Season 2)9BGE Stara Zagora 2025 - Replay Pack2Weekly Cups (June 2-8): herO doubles down1[BSL20] ProLeague: Bracket Stage & Dates9GSL Ro4 and Finals moved to Sunday June 15th13
StarCraft 2
General
TL Team Map Contest #5: Presented by Monster Energy Code S RO8 Results + RO4 Bracket (2025 Season 2) The SCII GOAT: A statistical Evaluation How herO can make history in the Code S S2 finals Jim claims he and Firefly were involved in match-fixing
Tourneys
RSL: Revival, a new crowdfunded tournament series [GSL 2025] Code S: Season 2 - Ro8 - Group A [GSL 2025] Code S: Season 2 - Ro8 - Group B SOOPer7s Showmatches 2025 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament
Strategy
[G] Darkgrid Layout Simple Questions Simple Answers [G] PvT Cheese: 13 Gate Proxy Robo
Custom Maps
[UMS] Zillion Zerglings
External Content
Mutation # 477 Slow and Steady Mutation # 476 Charnel House Mutation # 475 Hard Target Mutation # 474 Futile Resistance
Brood War
General
BGH auto balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/ BW General Discussion Recent recommended BW games FlaSh Witnesses SCV Pull Off the Impossible vs Shu StarCraft & BroodWar Campaign Speedrun Quest
Tourneys
Small VOD Thread 2.0 [Megathread] Daily Proleagues [BSL20] ProLeague Bracket Stage - Day 4 [BSL20] ProLeague Bracket Stage - Day 3
Strategy
I am doing this better than progamers do. [G] How to get started on ladder as a new Z player
Other Games
General Games
Nintendo Switch Thread Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Path of Exile Beyond All Reason What do you want from future RTS games?
Dota 2
Official 'what is Dota anymore' discussion
League of Legends
Heroes of the Storm
Simple Questions, Simple Answers Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Heroes of StarCraft mini-set
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread Vanilla Mini Mafia
Community
General
Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine US Politics Mega-thread UK Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Vape Nation Thread
Fan Clubs
Maru Fan Club Serral Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Korean Music Discussion [Manga] One Piece
Sports
NHL Playoffs 2024 TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 2024 - 2025 Football Thread Formula 1 Discussion
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List
Blogs
A Better Routine For Progame…
TrAiDoS
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Heero Yuy & the Tax…
KrillinFromwales
I was completely wrong ab…
jameswatts
Need Your Help/Advice
Glider
Trip to the Zoo
micronesia
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 25535 users

Refute my logic.

Blogs > Track
Post a Reply
1 2 3 4 5 6 Next All
Track
Profile Blog Joined May 2006
United States217 Posts
August 31 2009 18:10 GMT
#1
A little introduction.. I'm currently in a relationship with a girl of distinctly Christian beliefs. Now, naturally, she wants me to feel the same way(if you go back through my blogs, you'll see that this is hardly the first time this has happened, I'm a sucker for punishment).

My problems with Christianity don't stem from the fact that I don't want to believe, just that there are things within Christianity that make it illogical to me. I'm going to post one of them, and I'm honestly hoping that my logic WILL be refuted. Yeah, I know, I'm not being objective at all in wanting my logic to be defeated, my thinking is clearly compromised by wanting to be with this girl. It's sad that I acknowledge this and yet can't quite force myself out of the relationship on these grounds.

I'm currently a mixture between a Deist and a Pantheist, and honestly I see no reason to believe Christianity is *the* true religion when there are countless out there with as much claim to truth. If you disagree, post and tell me why.

To save us all a lot of time, don't post and tell me that I should just dump the girl, it's plain that I *should* do that, but we both know that I'm not going to. In a rather infantile and immature fashion, I'm in love with her. And yes, it was foolish for me to allow feelings to develop when I knew there was this colossal hurdle to face, but. They have. I can only face what it is and move forward.

With no further rambling, here is my problem:

I'll give you a good example, and it deals with the central tenet to Christianity: free will. You can immediately see how free will is essential to Christianity in that if man is not responsible for his actions, then man cannot "sin". If man cannot sin, there is no need for Jesus to die for man's sins, thereby reducing Christianity to nothingness.

The contradiction is this. Think for a moment about your mind. What causes you to make decisions? Imagine if you will a few variables. X represents your desires, be they need for power, lust, you name it. Y represents your ability to overcome those desires, your willpower. You can add in any variables you like, as these can't be quantified, all I'm trying to do is establish what in your mind mixes in order for you to make a decision. For example, if X>Y in any given situation(oversimplification as it may be), then your desires will win out over your willpower, and you'll indulge. Add in any variables you like, the point is that we're considering it an equation for the sake of ease.

As a case study, let's consider a man and his son. The man warns his son not to eat the cookies, because they will make him sick. The son, being disobedient, decides to eat the cookies. This is an act of free will against the father, because the son had the free choice to either eat the cookies or not to do so.

It's very important to note at this point that "free will" is defined as: The power of making free choices that are unconstrained by external circumstances or by an agency such as fate or divine will. Ie, there are no external agents operating on you, "forcing" you to do anything.

Now, if the father had forced the son into either eating the cookie or not, it wouldn't have been free will, would it? Of course not.

One more point is essential to make before we continue: by the nature of God, nothing can exist independently of him. Ie, nothing can simply come into being without being caused by God. Which is pretty intuitive, given that we consider everything made by God, but it's an important premise to list before we go to our conclusion. I hope you're with me so far.

Finally, let's consider Eve and the fruit. Did Eve have free will in deciding to eat the fruit? Well, if we refer to our father-son example, she did. But, there's one crucial difference: the father did not design the son. The father did not set into place the X and Y variables in the son's mind, so, naturally, the father wasn't at all forcing his son to make a decision.

God, however, DID set the variables. He had to, because nothing can exist independent of him. If they simply sprung into existence without God, our entire concept of God is wrecked. God, therefore, put into place within Eve's mind her X and Y variables. She exhibited a weakness for temptation, a willingness to be deceived, corrupted. Is she responsible for this weakness, or is God? By our definition, nothing can exist independent of God, so, by causation, he is responsible for this. This is the crucial point of the case study: her variables couldn't have sprung into existence, they had to come from somewhere, and the only logical place they could have possibly come is from God. So. If the father had FORCED his son into either eating the cookie or not, we would not say that the son was operating of his own free will. How then, given that God is, by having set our variables, forcing us into action, can you say that we operate under free will when we sin? If your car breaks down, who do you blame, the car, or the car maker?

If you consider:
1. God is omniscient and omnipotent.
2. Nothing can existent independent of God.
3. Given premise 1, God does not make mistakes, and he fully understands the consequences of everything he does, since he knows the future.
4. There is a thought process that guides our decision making.
5. Given premise 2, our thought process comes inevitably from God.
6. Given premises 3 and 5, God knows exactly what will happen when he sets the variables.
7. Given premise 1 and 6, God knows what combination will cause us to sin, and, given 2, there are no other factors independent of God.

Quod Erat Demonstrandum: Given your premises, free will is thereby logically defeated.


I appreciate any and all input on the subject.

***
Strength does not come from physical capacity. It comes from an indomitable will.
Saracen
Profile Blog Joined December 2007
United States5139 Posts
August 31 2009 18:20 GMT
#2
With this revelation, my mind has officially been blown.
Husky
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
United States3362 Posts
Last Edited: 2009-08-31 18:24:53
August 31 2009 18:23 GMT
#3
While I'm sure most anyone who's read any of my posts already knows my beliefs, I will just say, you are a brave brave soul for dating someone who is extremely Christian while you are not yourself.

Now, I dont have anything against them (except the ones that try to convert me), but I cant imagine falling in love with someone who has such extreme different views. Thats just me though, and its good to hear you two are able to make it happen.

That aside, as someone posted recently (forget if it was here or another forum), being an atheist is just denying one more god than all the gods Christians deny. Thus your logic rox!

Edit: I'm not really atheist btw... I just know Christians think they're all going to hell etc etc.
Commentaries: youtube.com/HuskyStarcraft
StorrZerg
Profile Blog Joined February 2008
United States13919 Posts
August 31 2009 18:23 GMT
#4
I find it easier to be ignorant
Hwaseung Oz fan for life. Swing out, always swing out.
Mah Buckit!
Profile Joined April 2009
Finland474 Posts
Last Edited: 2009-08-31 18:33:31
August 31 2009 18:23 GMT
#5
Dude are you trying to find some logic in religion?
C´mon just think for second now....

I don´t watch TV but wasn´t it House who said: " If you could reason with religious people, there would be no religious people."

E. And I´m going to be totally honest here: I would never date a non atheist girl, because I could never appreciate one. She would always be inferior to me. And you extreme fundamentalists better not ban me for this.
Starcraft? Epic Grimness.
Athos
Profile Blog Joined February 2008
United States2484 Posts
August 31 2009 18:25 GMT
#6
Just because free will doesn't exist (it doesn't, your environment and genetics decide everything you are going to do) doesn't mean that God exists. So really God = genes + environment.


Oh, and I once had a crush on a conservative Christian girl. Nothing happened, but I also was willing to compromise my beliefs to get a girl. It's totally normally dude.
illu
Profile Blog Joined December 2008
Canada2531 Posts
Last Edited: 2009-08-31 18:27:29
August 31 2009 18:26 GMT
#7
Since you are a deist, I will offer my argument since I consider myself to be one as well. To note, however, seeing your sophiscated argument I think mine may not be good enough, but I will try.

First we will establish the faith for an all-loving being, call it God. Since you are a deist as you claimed, I trust that you have no problem with God, but may get sore noses on the "all-loving" part. In my personal opinion, if you cannot have the faith that any possible supreme beings are all-loving and all-good, there is little point left in deism (and you might as well go athiesm). If you can do that, the rest is quite trivial (we don't need omnipotency or any other bullcraps).

The Christianity God is all-loving and all-good, which is compatible what I have described earlier. Therefore, there is no reason why you should not believe it, as you should be compatible with its moralities, etc..

If, however, it turned out that the Christian God is not the real God, that should be OK since the all-loving, all-good real God will forgive you for making such mistakes - you were simply fooled for a clever con-artist.
:]
udgnim
Profile Blog Joined April 2009
United States8024 Posts
Last Edited: 2009-08-31 18:28:56
August 31 2009 18:27 GMT
#8
here's how you get your logic refuted

talk to your girlfriend about the same exact subject matter you've posted

see who wins the argument. faith > logic
E-Sports is competitive video gaming with a spectator fan base. Do not take the word "Sports" literally.
Husky
Profile Blog Joined May 2009
United States3362 Posts
August 31 2009 18:27 GMT
#9
This picture I've found also angers a lot of Christians I've talked to. Though honestly I dont really get into religious debates anymore. People will believe what they've always believed and almost never change (at least from a single conversation).

+ Show Spoiler +
[image loading]
Commentaries: youtube.com/HuskyStarcraft
Saracen
Profile Blog Joined December 2007
United States5139 Posts
August 31 2009 18:28 GMT
#10
On September 01 2009 03:25 Athos wrote:
Just because free will doesn't exist (it doesn't, your environment and genetics decide everything you are going to do) doesn't mean that God exists. So really God = genes + environment.


Oh, and I once had a crush on a conservative Christian girl. Nothing happened, but I also was willing to compromise my beliefs to get a girl. It's totally normally dude.

Good thing your ID's not pAthos! Eh heh heh... heh...

...fuck.
Misrah
Profile Blog Joined February 2008
United States1695 Posts
August 31 2009 18:29 GMT
#11
Is god willing to prevent evil, but not able? Then he is not omnipotent. Is he able, but not willing? Then he is malevolent. Is he both able, and willing? Then whence cometh evil? Is he neither able nor willing? Then why call him God. ~ Epicurus

Just thought that i should begin with Epicurus.

Ok so let me try and explain in more laymen terms what i believe could be the one flaw in your argument.

As a preface- i am not christian, nor am i catholic. The only reason i would like to try and show that i am not extremely biased is simply to try and form some sense of credibility within this thread. In fact it doesn't matter if i am religious or religious at all, this is simply my opinion. From a novice theologian like myself it is simply at your discretion to take my advice or ignore it.

To begin:

The one flaw in your argument that i cannot come to terms with is your idea of free will. From what i gather- and from what my experiences in religious classes, debates and from partitions of the faith themselves- free will is seen in a completely different light than the one that you describe. From what i understand, free will while having been created by god, is not controlled by him. IE- your soul is yours, and will always be yours to keep. Even though god creates your soul, and understands everything within it, he simply decides to not control it. Basically you can do what you like. God will not stop you either way, but at the same time god knows exactly what you will do. So why eve and the fall from grace? According to a priest- it's "all part of his plan."

However this statement in itself some how defies the logic that God is an omnipotent and omnipotent diety- so really once again this is weak. (i fully admit this) Because why would god create man if god knew that man would fall, would suffer, and sin? The simple answer- That is extremely illogical, is this:

God wants to see- that even in the face of pain, tragedy, and the endless suffering that is life- will you still praise him?

Applying logic to god is impossible. Because if you could reason with religious people- there would be no religious people left. Faith is called faith for a reason, and it is up to you to decide if you really believe in God. No amount of logic can make that decision for you. Because logically- i disproved the entire idea of god with my first paragraph lol.

A thread vaguely bashing SC2? SWARM ON, LOW POST COUNT BRETHREN! DEFEND THE GLORIOUS GAME THAT IS OUR LIVELIHOOD
Railxp
Profile Blog Joined February 2008
Hong Kong1313 Posts
August 31 2009 18:30 GMT
#12
the Christian religion is illogical to begin with. Since your core issue is with the girl rather than your logic, i would advice to just avoid this flamefest with her to begin with. Get to know her, have fun enjoying her company, and settle to agree to disagree regarding religion. If you prove that your logic is flawless, then by implication she is wrong. If we DO manage to dismantle your logical conclusion, then you will just find something else about Christianity to disagree with, since it is so full of logic holes. Either way it will form an unnecessary wedge in your relationship with her in the long run.

Unless you are looking to marry her, there is no need to dismantle another person's laboriously constructed cornerstone of belief, that would be unnecessarily cruel. Pretend ignorance or claim to be vaguely agnostic, ask her to respect your religious beliefs as you do hers, and drop the topic. She is much more than her belief in god, so there is not much point dwelling on it.
~\(。◕‿‿◕。)/~,,,,,,,,>
micronesia
Profile Blog Joined July 2006
United States24650 Posts
August 31 2009 18:31 GMT
#13
Your first problem in your proof is with step 1 since nothing can be omnipotent.

According to biblical times didn't God have to flood the entire Earth to kill pretty much everyone? I stopped taking Abrahamic religions seriously after that.
ModeratorThere are animal crackers for people and there are people crackers for animals.
Kwidowmaker
Profile Blog Joined October 2007
Canada978 Posts
August 31 2009 18:33 GMT
#14
No girl is worth compromising your metaphysical principles
Kk.
Railxp
Profile Blog Joined February 2008
Hong Kong1313 Posts
August 31 2009 18:33 GMT
#15
On September 01 2009 03:27 HuskyTheHusky wrote:
This picture I've found also angers a lot of Christians I've talked to. Though honestly I dont really get into religious debates anymore. People will believe what they've always believed and almost never change (at least from a single conversation).

+ Show Spoiler +
[image loading]


That picture is one of the most awesome things i've seen in a while. Fukkin saved.
~\(。◕‿‿◕。)/~,,,,,,,,>
Strayline
Profile Blog Joined January 2009
United States330 Posts
August 31 2009 18:35 GMT
#16
Yeah people will believe what they will believe.
KwarK
Profile Blog Joined July 2006
United States42443 Posts
August 31 2009 18:40 GMT
#17
Just pay lip service.
ModeratorThe angels have the phone box
Thratur
Profile Blog Joined June 2008
Canada917 Posts
August 31 2009 18:47 GMT
#18
This is interesting. I agree with you that free will doesn't exist. However, I'm an atheist. I can say, though, that in your reasoning, we can almost replace god by "physics" (with some tweaks of course) and it works the same! Some chemical interaction created us, so we're dependent to them, etc.
Mah Buckit!
Profile Joined April 2009
Finland474 Posts
August 31 2009 18:51 GMT
#19
"God is dead" - Nietsche

Saying free will doesn´t exist is madness.
I think I saw a research which said that our brains make decisions before we "make" them, so in a way I think free will exist but it might not be our conciousness that makes the decisions.
Starcraft? Epic Grimness.
Diggity
Profile Blog Joined September 2007
United States806 Posts
Last Edited: 2009-08-31 19:04:14
August 31 2009 18:59 GMT
#20
[image loading]



the link for slow load times: http://www.smbc-comics.com/index.php?db=comics&id=1394#comic
1 2 3 4 5 6 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
OSC
13:00
King of the Hill Weekly #213
CranKy Ducklings64
Liquipedia
WardiTV Invitational
11:00
WardiTV June Group D & 1/2C
MaxPax vs Spirit
Krystianer vs SpiritLIVE!
YoungYakov vs MaxPax
WardiTV1022
IndyStarCraft 239
LiquipediaDiscussion
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
IndyStarCraft 239
ProTech88
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 34865
Calm 11219
firebathero 6215
Hyuk 919
EffOrt 825
Stork 421
Mini 363
Larva 331
Zeus 313
ZerO 279
[ Show more ]
actioN 276
Shuttle 261
Light 195
Rush 114
Dewaltoss 111
PianO 101
ToSsGirL 68
hero 59
Sea.KH 52
Barracks 39
sorry 38
[sc1f]eonzerg 34
sas.Sziky 23
HiyA 18
sSak 18
scan(afreeca) 13
IntoTheRainbow 12
Nal_rA 12
SilentControl 10
Noble 10
ajuk12(nOOB) 5
ivOry 4
Dota 2
Gorgc4207
qojqva2397
XcaliburYe309
syndereN253
boxi9852
Counter-Strike
olofmeister2444
byalli233
Super Smash Bros
C9.Mang0496
Westballz37
Other Games
singsing2485
B2W.Neo561
Fuzer 354
DeMusliM315
crisheroes296
hiko257
elazer191
ArmadaUGS130
XaKoH 123
Liquid`VortiX93
djWHEAT66
KnowMe47
QueenE46
ZerO(Twitch)24
Organizations
Dota 2
PGL Dota 2 - Main Stream6767
StarCraft: Brood War
lovetv 15
StarCraft 2
Blizzard YouTube
StarCraft: Brood War
BSLTrovo
sctven
[ Show 13 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• LaughNgamezSOOP
• Migwel
• sooper7s
StarCraft: Brood War
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
Dota 2
• WagamamaTV440
League of Legends
• Nemesis8081
• Jankos2429
Upcoming Events
BSL 2v2 ProLeague S3
5h 14m
Korean StarCraft League
13h 14m
SOOP
19h 14m
sOs vs Percival
CranKy Ducklings
20h 14m
WardiTV Invitational
21h 14m
Cheesadelphia
1d 1h
CSO Cup
1d 3h
BSL: ProLeague
1d 4h
Hawk vs UltrA
Sziky vs spx
TerrOr vs JDConan
GSL Code S
1d 18h
Rogue vs herO
Classic vs GuMiho
Sparkling Tuna Cup
1d 20h
[ Show More ]
BSL: ProLeague
2 days
Bonyth vs Dewalt
Cross vs Doodle
MadiNho vs Dragon
Replay Cast
2 days
Wardi Open
2 days
Replay Cast
3 days
Replay Cast
3 days
RSL Revival
3 days
Cure vs Percival
ByuN vs Spirit
RSL Revival
4 days
herO vs sOs
Zoun vs Clem
Replay Cast
5 days
The PondCast
5 days
RSL Revival
5 days
Serral vs SHIN
Solar vs Cham
Replay Cast
6 days
RSL Revival
6 days
Reynor vs Scarlett
ShoWTimE vs Classic
Liquipedia Results

Completed

CSL Season 17: Qualifier 2
BGE Stara Zagora 2025
Heroes 10 EU

Ongoing

JPL Season 2
BSL 2v2 Season 3
BSL Season 20
KCM Race Survival 2025 Season 2
NPSL S3
Rose Open S1
CSL 17: 2025 SUMMER
2025 GSL S2
BLAST.tv Austin Major 2025
ESL Impact League Season 7
IEM Dallas 2025
PGL Astana 2025
Asian Champions League '25
BLAST Rivals Spring 2025
MESA Nomadic Masters
CCT Season 2 Global Finals
IEM Melbourne 2025
YaLLa Compass Qatar 2025
PGL Bucharest 2025

Upcoming

Copa Latinoamericana 4
CSLPRO Last Chance 2025
CSLPRO Chat StarLAN 3
K-Championship
SEL Season 2 Championship
Esports World Cup 2025
HSC XXVII
Championship of Russia 2025
Murky Cup #2
Esports World Cup 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall 2025
BLAST Bounty Fall Qual
IEM Cologne 2025
FISSURE Playground #1
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2025 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.