|
France1887 Posts
On January 16 2012 20:00 ajabberwok wrote:
On the mobile version of the site please increase the font size of the control links (page numbers, next links, etc), because they are just way too small to reliably hit with a finger or thumb. This would improve forum navigation greatly.
Are you talking about Liquipedia, or teamliquid.net Forum? Because there are no page numbers or "next" links in Liquipedia.
If your remark does concern TL Forum, you may want to create a post in this thread: TL mobile version.
|
France1887 Posts
On January 16 2012 19:11 mikkmagro wrote:PS: I saw that a page was needed for LANTREK, and I added it with the relevant information. As it is my first page, it is very possible that I made mistakes, so I would appreciate if anyone knowledgeable, who has some spare time, could have a look at it. http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/LANTREK'12
Just about your LANTREK'12 page, it was overall pretty good for a first page!
I made a few corrections. I removed the 4th place in the Prize Pool section, since there was no prize for 4th place.
|
|
|
Just want to point out that the link to the english translation of "Crazy as Me" is broken on BoxeR's sc2 page.
|
France266 Posts
Actually this region distribution template is quite recent, and is discussed right now in order to find out the best way of using it.
On January 21 2012 17:16 Gono wrote:
Just want to point out that the link to the english translation of "Crazy as Me" is broken on BoxeR's sc2 page.
Thanks for the heads-up  (when you find such issues don't hesitate to log on the wiki (with your TL.net log and password) in order to fix it)
|
On January 25 2012 05:47 Koorb wrote:Actually this region distribution template is quite recent, and is discussed right now in order to find out the best way of using it. Show nested quote +On January 21 2012 17:16 Gono wrote:
Just want to point out that the link to the english translation of "Crazy as Me" is broken on BoxeR's sc2 page. Thanks for the heads-up (when you find such issues don't hesitate to log on the wiki (with your TL.net log and password) in order to fix it)
I just saw that it was fixed on Kiev page to reflect just USA players. IMHO I'd put "America" as a whole continent (without the flag, of course), Europe (actually, without the flag also, because it isn't all European countries that are from EU) and Asia (to reflect Korea + Sen)
Very thankful about the quick response and the fix.
|
Team Vile page lists Echoic as a former player, yet Echoic's page states that he's still a member.
|
Netherlands6142 Posts
On January 27 2012 14:25 wendillian wrote:
Team Vile page lists Echoic as a former player, yet Echoic's page states that he's still a member.
You should find out and edit it :o
|
Not sure if this is the appropriate place to say this, but this page http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/Robin reads like a CV/resume ("After much hard work, dedication, and practice..." and "Having an ever-growing passion for StarCraft II, and loads of practice with both playing and casting under his belt...") to me and is full of useless information , not like a wiki page. Without being rude, it sounds like he wrote it himself and I think it should be rewritten / rephrased.
|
France1887 Posts
On January 31 2012 10:02 Ostaf wrote:Not sure if this is the appropriate place to say this, but this page http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/Robin reads like a CV/resume ("After much hard work, dedication, and practice..." and "Having an ever-growing passion for StarCraft II, and loads of practice with both playing and casting under his belt...") to me and is full of useless information , not like a wiki page. Without being rude, it sounds like he wrote it himself and I think it should be rewritten / rephrased.
The  Robin page was actually written by the Liquipedia user BrightSideSC2 who interviewed him (Interview with Robin - the "Passion Man" himself.).
Personally, I don't think the page is useless. The tone is not as strict as an average wiki page, but it's not that bad. You can still log in to Liquipedia and make some edits to correct the tone if you want.
|
Hey guys. I decided it might be good for my brain to try and learn a new system. Liqupedia seems complicated and daunting, so I thought attempt to learn about it.
As I'm a masters protoss who occasionally plays lower level NA GMs, I'd thought I'd start updating all the Protoss strategy articles, moving some of the better guides, and creating some new articles as well. However, since I know nothing about how Liquipedia works now, I need some place to start and practice.
http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/Naniwa's_no_scouting_Build_(vs._Protoss)
This is the stub build I will start on. I actually play Blink Observer PvP, and have easily put in more than 50 blink observer PvP games since season 5 started.
Essentially, what I'm trying to say is you're going to see a lot of changes to that stub article while I try to figure out how Liquipedia works.
|
Hyrule19193 Posts
Cool.
Use Preview instead of Post -> Read or I'll kill you.
Have fun.
|
Sweden5554 Posts
On February 03 2012 01:10 tofucake wrote:
Cool.
Use Preview instead of Post -> Read or I'll kill you.
Have fun.
Hmm, how come I'm still alive then? *smiles innocently*
|
On February 03 2012 01:10 tofucake wrote:
Cool.
Use Preview instead of Post -> Read or I'll kill you.
Have fun.
Okay, I'll preview when I'm trying to see whether something like a pic appears in.
e: actually irc looks good for asking qs!
|
On January 16 2012 19:11 mikkmagro wrote:It is probably not my place to make this observation, but the guidelines set as regards to creating player pages are being overlooked in many cases. A lot of unremarkable players are being added, and in my opinion, this will be unsustainable, as keeping everything up to date is almost impossible with the number of players being added. Personally, I don't see anything wrong with team managers adding a page for their particular team, even if they haven't done anything in the competitive scene, but going on to create a page for every person in their management staff, let alone their actual players, is going too far in my opinion. A notable example is Team aiR: http://wiki.teamliquid.net/starcraft2/Team_aiRNote also, that the achievements listed also go against the Liquipedia guidelines. I think that the guidelines should be enforced, so that Liquipedia can remain cleaner and more up to date.
LP is a constant balancing act between page quality and quantity. The best, most up-to-date pages are the most popular ones. Not only do they get lots of input, but the incessant "bumping" makes sure that lots of editor time goes into them as well.
Less popular pages, like Team aiR's new complement, are sort of the opposite. However, at least in my eyes, it's better to have a page for somebody than not to, so we must simply strive to teach and edit consistent, neutral content. If leaving and fixing pages encourages even a tiny fraction of these kind of contributors to keep editing, I believe it's worthwhile effort.
NOTE: as always, I speak only for myself.
|
Hyrule19193 Posts
On February 03 2012 01:13 salle wrote:Show nested quote +On February 03 2012 01:10 tofucake wrote:
Cool.
Use Preview instead of Post -> Read or I'll kill you.
Have fun. Hmm, how come I'm still alive then? *smiles innocently*
Keeping you alive to fix templates is worth the headaches.
|
What qualifies a crowning achievement? I noticed Whitera doesn't have one even though he won both IPL2 and homestorycup 2 (the data box specifically states that "IGN29"(sic) is not Whitera's crowning achievment. While I would agree that Whitera didn't have the most difficult journey in IPL2, Homestorycup 2 was a top class tournament. HSC2 was certainly atleast if not more difficult than Jinro's MLG dallas victory which is listed as a crowning achievement.
It seems as if the prestige of the tournament is a bigger factor than the effort invested to win. This is confounded whoever by the fact that Dongraegu's IEM Newyork victory and dreamhack valencia victory are not considered to be"crowning achievements" .
|
Hyrule19193 Posts
Edit the pages then? Nobody is stopping you. Lots of pages have out of date info and it's hard to keep track of every single one.
|
I think you missed the part where I said that it specifically says in the data boxes what isn't acceptable as a crowning achievement.
|
I think the Category:Articles with unsourced statements page isn't working correctly. I spent hours getting it down to 33 or something yesterday and today all the one's it removed as I referenced things have appeared back, but with still no "citation needed" template on them at all, and it's not a case of needing to be verified. viOLet for instance being the first one I did which the page auto removed yesterday is now showing on it again as needing references while none are needed on the page.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
