|
On September 01 2010 13:14 Vz0 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2010 12:33 ltortoise wrote:On September 01 2010 12:15 dacthehork wrote: How can you sound this intelligent and be stuck in bronze?. Mechanics. I spent my first 100 games in the beta in copper, back when copper still existed. I was so excited to play SC2 when I heard about the beta that I tried getting into brood war during my wait. I massed games of brood war. Played hundreds. Never made it past D- on iccup. Of course, it also occurred to me that many of the D and above level brood war players had been playing brood war for...Quite some time! My mechanics in SC2 were also my limiting factor. It's easy to be limited by mechanics. Intelligence and mechanics have nothing to do with each other, but BOTH are requisite for high level play. errrr you played 100 games and you were still in copper? -__________-" ! I don't think your the same "gamer" as the rest of us. User was warned for this post
God the stench of elitism is rank in here!
|
Sadly I have a feeling given enough time it will all become so standard that it will get boring, a lot of diamond players also fall into this same trend just with better mechanics/macro/micro. But still this is a good read into your division of play 
ps love all these warnings keep up the good work, and good luck with your gaming OP
|
A lot of the campaign missions consist of you defending until you have a large enough army to push out and complete the objectives, this may contribute to the fact that newer players like to play safe.
|
On September 01 2010 21:32 Inkarnate wrote: A lot of the campaign missions consist of you defending until you have a large enough army to push out and complete the objectives, this may contribute to the fact that newer players like to play safe. I agree, the campaign is highly biased by design, towards one type of play. Naturally, this will be what people get used to.
Ultimately, in order to rise in League, it's all about getting the knowledge, understanding and practice outside of the campaign - although the campaign is in no way unusable for this.
|
Lol what's with the bashing.
I find it interesting to hear about the game's development, it happening in bronze isn't any less worth than diamond to me.
If these standard strategies develop, then you should have a pretty nice learning path ahead of you. Practicing against the same build order a lot is always good, when you find a good counter to it you'll sky rocket out of bronze !
GL Hf!
|
Well, I'm playing Protoss in the Bronze League too. And have even fewer games than the OP does under my belt. I guess I'm one of the types of player's he's kinda complaining about. I wall off very quickly and build off my main base until I'm ready to move out.
The reason is simple. If I tried to execute the simple "core" build orders for Protoss, 5 out of 6 games I'd lose to a Zerg player with a 6 pool or a Terran with a proxy Rax right outside my base. By walling off my ramp with a gateway and a couple pylons (and a zealot or two in front of the wall), I actually have a chance to play a full game.
And what I've found is that if I can negate the early all-in rush to win, then my opponent often doesn't know enough about the macro game to beat me. My win percentage has gone up quite a bit once I started this opening strategy.
To be clear: I'm not asking for suggestions either. I read TL forums and watch casts most of the day at work (the joys of working on a computer service desk ... lots of dead time between trouble tickets). And my mechanics are getting better. I figure my biggest issue in not moving up more quickly is that I can only play 1-3 games a night; so it takes a while to learn how to put what I know into practice.
I just wanted to give some perspective to the OP on why some of us have learned to wall off right away and why his early rushes aren't being as successful as they used to be. It's how we've learned to survive.
|
To whichever mod is busting out the warnings and banhammers in this thread, good call.
I'm glad that the skill floor in multiplayer is rising. It means that by the time the next ladder reset happens (or if it happens), the higher leagues will be a greater goal to work towards. Many of the people in the higher leagues now entered those leagues when most players were probably still playing single player, so it was much easier back then. It might be a different story next time.
|
well Im kind stuck too, but i receive one bnet drop in each 3 games .... literally .... my actual win/loss ratio would be 75% if it was not for drops, but i dont care either way, just have fun if u dont get d/c very often i believe u will go from silver in no time straight from gold ...
|
I think a lot of the warnings were not just for bad manners, but being off topic and not reading the OP, he was not asking advice on how to be better in his gameplay.
User was temp banned for this post.
|
Canada9720 Posts
I didn't do any of the warnings, but stop derailing the thread about them. Stay on topic, please. Any moderation feedback should go in the website feedback forum.
No more posts about the warnings please.
|
OP - I'm in a similar situation (In silver, but always playing against diamond for some reason...) and I notice the same things.
As far as improving... get a practice partner from these forums (PM me if you want.. I'd be more than happy to assist) that will help you. Two people working more towards bettering themselves is always going to be more productive than two people trying to win vs each other. (Till you have the basics mastered).
|
It's ever interesting to learn how the players community is evolving, don't care about ranks. Also is interesting to see the difference between SC1 and SC2 because ofc the SC2 lowest ranks are/was really new players (also new to RTS some time) instead of SC1 ICCup where most of the time also D- players are experienced players. I suggest to you to watch a lot of pro replays/vods and copy their style. I think that rushes and cheese will ever work especially at low ranks so try to learn all the already developed cheesy builds and improve your micro than try to make your own pimp builds which will work because the game is very new.
Thx op make more ^^ GL
|
On September 01 2010 21:02 lololol wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2010 20:42 pikkumyy wrote: I have read some posts on TL but this one was the one that made me register in order to reply.
I am stuck on bronze as well. All these comments about "check day9 and watch a couple of replays" are just bull. I have watched dozens of dailies from day9 (and have gotten several good points that certainly have improved my vision of the game) as well as checked a lot of replays.
I have over 15 years of background in competetive online gaming (fps games only) with some playing around of rts such as c&c, supcom and so.
I too was expecting the lower level play to be "DURR what does this button do" but no, in the rare exception that I'm not cheesed with one or another strategy that totally screws up any attempt to maintain a specific plan or build order (that I've tried to mimic from those replays and videos) then it's an attack that I would have to really have microing skills and the sorts to handle.
The entry level for SC2 seems really a steep ladder to climb. I mean, checking the documentation in terms of replays and various commentators, doing training with builds (with yabot and the likes) and really learning to optimise to shave a few seconds off from this and that doesn't seem to be enough.
Please, have some respect towards your fellow gamers that are trying to have fun and improve instead of bashing them with those lame "lol bronze" comments. Thank you. You're going completely in the wrong direction. You should most definitely NOT be trying to optimize builds and you should most definitely NOT try to maintain a specific build regardless of circumstances. The first one is not worth it at your level, and the second one is plain bad, because you should be reacting to your opponent. If you're in bronze your errors are much more basic. You're not constatnly producing workers, you're not constantly spending your resources and you're not scouting/don't know how to respond to the enemy.
Good advices. OP should follow them. Dont try to micro your units. Dont even do this in bronze. This isnt a game about micro especially in bronze league. Create workers, production buildings and units. When your base is saturated and you have 15+ units, expand. When your 2 base are saturated and you have below 500 minerals, push and win. As simple as that. Especially as a terran : you can push against towers with your siege tanks, you can defend easily with a wall-in and you can scout easily with scans.
Not to brag or anything but before playing SC2 I didnt played any RTS games. I was in platinum during beta and now diamond by playing 150 games overall. I think my competitive background (I played CS) helped me a lot. Ive a lot of friends who are in top french CS teams aswell and just picked up RTS with SC2. They are already in diamond in 2-3 weeks. Starcraft 2 is a game with certain mechanics. I think playing on a high level video game teams helped us understand the basic mechanics and exploit them. Workers, buildings, units, keep your money low, energy low on CC and be as fast as possible at everything you do. Its easy to say but having these kind of background helped us reach these goals faster than you.
Everytime you see a replay or do a mistake, you should not to it again, ever. Its hard to do but you should concentrate on it. Make workers, buildings, workers, units, workers, expand, workers, buildings, units, workers, units, push -> win. Dont try to micro, attack move into his base and win. If he turtles, expand more and more and more. Eventually you'll win.
Dont try to cheese and work on your mechanics. Its not about the win its about improving your macro.
|
On September 01 2010 21:19 Zoroth wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2010 20:13 wollhandkrabbe wrote: I agree with all the warnings. It seriously damages my view of TL if casual Bronze players are treated without respect. If you think the OPs thoughts are worthless, just don't answer ffs. How exactly are those posts disrespectful? They simply state that certain things are true for Bronze League that aren't found at higher leagues. It has nothing to do with the OP, personally. Show nested quote +On September 01 2010 12:16 Kolvacs wrote: Not to be a douche or anything, but it's bronze league. I'm not sure what your expecting.
User was warned for this post Is it offensive to state the obvious, that Bronze League isn't a level where you'd expect a lot of skill? This is a statistical fact of life. Instead, maybe people should instead stop being so embarassed about having poor skill. I'm a crappy player myself, macro-wise. Should people be warned every time they point out that I'm a poor macro-player? It's a fact, not an attempt at insult - unless they use a language that is clearly offensive. Show nested quote +On September 01 2010 12:15 dacthehork wrote: How can you sound this intelligent and be stuck in bronze? I understand being in bronze if you are new, but if you spend some time watching replays (and copying) you should be out in no time. Even without any apm/mechanics.
Honestly just find a good build order for each match up and refine it in practice games against comp until you can decently execute it. Then do it over and over in bronze and you will be out in no time.
User was warned for this post He's giving the OP both a compliment and a useful tip, and he's being warned for it? Show nested quote +On September 01 2010 12:26 Vz0 wrote:On September 01 2010 12:16 Kolvacs wrote: Not to be a douche or anything, but it's bronze league. I'm not sure what your expecting. agree. dont want to be the "diamond pro" laughing at the "bronze noobs" but most people at bronze are not very efficient and unelss we are given a replay we seriously can't judge anything. There could be heavy macro mistakes in both parties that lead to an obscured gameplay. User was warned for this post Again, this guy is stating a neutral fact about Bronze. Most Bronze players are not very efficient, or else they wouldn't be in Bronze. It's not an insult, it's an explanation to what Bronze League actually is. I'm sorry, I just wanna know how people think. Is there some channel to use to give moderators feedback on how they handle things in this forum? I respect the rules of this forum and the moderators' words are final, but I also feel it's important to point out how ridiculous this seems. I would like to ask the owner of this website how much he moderates his own moderators, whenever they cross the line. Again, not meant as insurrection, but if individual moderators go unchecked by their peers, then that can and will have some negative effects on this website's infrastructure. Suddenly people are afraid of discussing things, I mean. The fact of the matter is that Starcraft 2 strategy is often about getting a personal reality check. Why are we not getting any better? Do people really want an answer or are we just pretending to care about it? Just think it's strange, especially since a couple of disgusting, gay-bashing posts in "Gay Starcraft Players" have gone completely unwarned. Suggestion:Maybe the webmaster could add a more democratic system with a +/- function for each post, similar to what they have at Youtube.com. A general warning might not always "hit home", because people might not always see the logic of that warn. But if forumers themselves can, plurally, give a "score" to the posts, then maybe that reflect a little more accurately how offensive the posts really are. After all, what is offensive and not can actually be highly subjective. Thanks!
I agree with your post, specifically several of the people complimenting the OP and offering sound suggestions, yet they still get warned. I pointed this out and got warned for pointing out and I can only assume you will too, I don't know what's going on with the overzealous moderation in this particular thread but someone has gone warn happy it seems.
(One or two were slightly rough on the front page but most quite good responses)
Weird.
User was temp banned for this post.
|
It's pretty damn interesting to hear what it's like in the Bronze league. Most of us TLers either Diamond or Platinum, so hats off to the OP for being the proud Bronze leaguer. IMO the OP has more worth as a person than most of these people Diamond players in these forums.
I believe the meta-game in the Bronze league is as innocent as it can be compared to the other leagues that have players who have done their share of research of BOs, tactics, etc. When the game started out, I'm guessing that most Bronze league players would just rush and cheese without even knowing that they were cheesing or going all-in. Eventually players would learn that if they defend 1 or 2 pushes they would win with ease. Eventually the loyal cheesey and rushing players will alter their build so that they wouldn't fall behind so much. It must be really cute to watch Bronze players go at it lol.
|
On September 01 2010 22:12 abrasion wrote:Show nested quote +On September 01 2010 21:19 Zoroth wrote:On September 01 2010 20:13 wollhandkrabbe wrote: I agree with all the warnings. It seriously damages my view of TL if casual Bronze players are treated without respect. If you think the OPs thoughts are worthless, just don't answer ffs. How exactly are those posts disrespectful? They simply state that certain things are true for Bronze League that aren't found at higher leagues. It has nothing to do with the OP, personally. On September 01 2010 12:16 Kolvacs wrote: Not to be a douche or anything, but it's bronze league. I'm not sure what your expecting.
User was warned for this post Is it offensive to state the obvious, that Bronze League isn't a level where you'd expect a lot of skill? This is a statistical fact of life. Instead, maybe people should instead stop being so embarassed about having poor skill. I'm a crappy player myself, macro-wise. Should people be warned every time they point out that I'm a poor macro-player? It's a fact, not an attempt at insult - unless they use a language that is clearly offensive. On September 01 2010 12:15 dacthehork wrote: How can you sound this intelligent and be stuck in bronze? I understand being in bronze if you are new, but if you spend some time watching replays (and copying) you should be out in no time. Even without any apm/mechanics.
Honestly just find a good build order for each match up and refine it in practice games against comp until you can decently execute it. Then do it over and over in bronze and you will be out in no time.
User was warned for this post He's giving the OP both a compliment and a useful tip, and he's being warned for it? On September 01 2010 12:26 Vz0 wrote:On September 01 2010 12:16 Kolvacs wrote: Not to be a douche or anything, but it's bronze league. I'm not sure what your expecting. agree. dont want to be the "diamond pro" laughing at the "bronze noobs" but most people at bronze are not very efficient and unelss we are given a replay we seriously can't judge anything. There could be heavy macro mistakes in both parties that lead to an obscured gameplay. User was warned for this post Again, this guy is stating a neutral fact about Bronze. Most Bronze players are not very efficient, or else they wouldn't be in Bronze. It's not an insult, it's an explanation to what Bronze League actually is. I'm sorry, I just wanna know how people think. Is there some channel to use to give moderators feedback on how they handle things in this forum? I respect the rules of this forum and the moderators' words are final, but I also feel it's important to point out how ridiculous this seems. I would like to ask the owner of this website how much he moderates his own moderators, whenever they cross the line. Again, not meant as insurrection, but if individual moderators go unchecked by their peers, then that can and will have some negative effects on this website's infrastructure. Suddenly people are afraid of discussing things, I mean. The fact of the matter is that Starcraft 2 strategy is often about getting a personal reality check. Why are we not getting any better? Do people really want an answer or are we just pretending to care about it? Just think it's strange, especially since a couple of disgusting, gay-bashing posts in "Gay Starcraft Players" have gone completely unwarned. Suggestion:Maybe the webmaster could add a more democratic system with a +/- function for each post, similar to what they have at Youtube.com. A general warning might not always "hit home", because people might not always see the logic of that warn. But if forumers themselves can, plurally, give a "score" to the posts, then maybe that reflect a little more accurately how offensive the posts really are. After all, what is offensive and not can actually be highly subjective. Thanks! I agree with your post, specifically several of the people complimenting the OP and offering sound suggestions, yet they still get warned. I pointed this out and got warned for pointing out and I can only assume you will too, I don't know what's going on with the overzealous moderation in this particular thread but someone has gone warn happy it seems. (One or two were slightly rough on the front page but most quite good responses) Weird. A rating system for comments is a brilliant idea! i seen it done in some websites. Some with better success then others but i wouldn't mind seeing tl beta test it 
edit-my bad i rly deserved that 
User was warned for this post
|
My only experience with the Bronze league were my first 2 placement matches 2 days ago, and I disagree. All they did was sit in their base the whole game. Both games ended as soon as I got mutas. I'm not sure if you mean 6pool or whatever, but that doesn't really work anyway. Most people are overly scared at the low levels actually and play extremely defensively. Back in early beta when I intentionally lost all 5 of my placement matches and went to copper, I think that the level back then was either higher or at least the same. Back then at least the beta people were most likely pretty big gamers, now there's gazillions of complete newbies in the bronze league.
So judging by those 2 games nah, you can still win with early aggression if you do it properly. About the "lack of mechanics" thing, everyone below Platinum has awful mechanics. 30 APM are all you need until at least platinum. Just concentrate on early harrassment and builds that force your opponents to multitask and they all will crumble.
Mechanics are also extremely easy to get better at until a certain level, much easier than you'd think. If you for 3 hours a day practice a build order where you try to go as fast as possible, after a few days you will most likely 1. have clearly above 100 apm 2. be able to do a build perfectly, letting you easily cruise into at least platinum. Most people just don't bother, because they think that they won't learn, or mechanics are things some people have or some don't or whatever.
My friend was an awful SCBW player who didn't manage to stay even at D- and lost 95% of all his games and was just really bad. In SC2 he was placed in silver and is now in the Gold league and does things correctly now. He's been improving really fast. I'm not sure why that is, but at least he's been listening to my advice... He had about 20-30 APM in SCBW but now that he's tried to improve it in SC2 his APM is around 80 in every game and that's getting him along just fine.
You can improve your mechanics really easily if you put effort into it. During the course of about 2 months I improved my SCBW APM from 80-100 to 220 by just playing without playing to win, but rather playing to do everything as fast as possible.
EDIT: Huh, if you're in the Bronze league and not even aiming/trying to get better, is this seriously the correct forum
|
That's interesting to hear that in 1v1s people are massing BCs/voids/ultras in bronze. I'm waiting until i get diamond in 4v4 and 2v2 still before i even try 1v1s (cause i'm a scaredy cat). Usually that "mass up tier 3 units" used to be limited to FFA in beta.
|
I don't think the level of play is that bad in the lower levels, seems to me (based on my mate who is in silver) that a lot of the play is one dimensional.
Embarrassingly, I got rolled by a silver terran last night who pulled off a particularly nasty 3 rax timing push which I didn't quite read until too late. (I saw 2 raxes but the third was really late).
I have to say my experience in diamond that the level of play has increased a lot in the month since release. It's not quite what it was in the beta, but it's getting there.
|
Osaka27179 Posts
On September 01 2010 18:04 Manifesto7 wrote: If you have a problem or question about the way I mod, PM me or make a thread in website feedback. Do not derail the thread.
Not reading the thread is harmful to your posting health.
I'm going to lock the thread now to save stupid people from themselves. Unfortunately, I suspect it is like using duct tape on a leaky dam, you are all going to get washed away at some point.
|
|
|
|
|
|