Rockband Mini Mafia - Page 24

On September 20 2012 00:15 Palmar wrote:
Get off my Hapa bro's case.

Wtf is this shit, prplhz is not scum look at his big post after he started caring.

On September 19 2012 23:48 Palmar wrote:
What about marv austinmcc? Why do you not want to lynch him?

On September 19 2012 18:13 Palmar wrote:
This is important: When I joined the game marv had made exactly one post worth reading. It was a long-winded post but it had very little substance to it, at least for someone I would consider a good player. He basically rehashed the reasons why a case against hapahauli was bad (duh) and then proceeded to vote for a lurker.

The point is marv was really, really not doing jack shit in the game until I actually came in and called him out on it. He seems to have really changed things up. He even changed his entire attitude to be more badass. If you don't believe me, read his filter before, and after this post:

On September 18 2012 22:19 marvellosity wrote:
Shame goodkarma is replacing out. His first post was scummy as hell. Not the general wishywashyness/not voting, but the fact that he was willing to talk about policy/trolling. I'm going to be keeping a close eye on his replacement. Look at this:



The thread has already generated a scumread for GK, but for some reason he's derailing into policy discussion. Look at what he says - policy discussion is far more productive than the direction this game has gone. But look at how this game has gone. This might be the most productive Day 1 I've ever seen. Why is he complaining about it?

On September 20 2012 00:02 austinmcc wrote:

Look at all the reactions to this post I made. Palmar thinks I'm scum just from the too obvious comment. Marv found it scummy. Hapa found it scummy. I think another one or two people did as well. But Mementoss's reaction to my comment felt different.

On September 20 2012 00:02 austinmcc wrote:

He mentions me later, after Bluelightz questions him a little:
I guess...I didn't feel pressured by his post. He doesn't call me scum. He doesn't call my scummy. He doesn't REALLY say anything about me above. This isn't a super-strong point, as indecisiveness usually ~ scumminess, but my problem with his initial reaction was that it wasn't strong, didn't call me out, didn't end in a vote, nothing. So I find his characterization of that post as being the only pressure he's put on a person other than prplhz this game to be off. It's not outright, flashing lights, scummy. But when it's a response to pressure and you're sort of...almost misrepresenting an earlier post, misrepresenting your play, it comes off scummy. It comes off like you don't have a good handle on the actions you've taken and are slightly scrambling to explain yourself to pressure.

On September 20 2012 00:36 marvellosity wrote:
austin:



I don't read much into this. It's the kinda post I can see being made as either alignment.



The thing is, I think you're actually misrepresenting Mementoss somewhat here. He said "the only other person I remotely pressured" - the way this is phrased clearly indicates to me that he wasn't calling it significant pressure. "I remotely pressured" - as in, I kinda pressured a bit. But you're saying that he's misrepresenting it as proper pressure, when I don't think that's actually the case.

---

Some of the other parts of your case are stronger, though. The bits with the questioning on me/fuba without coming to an explanation. I think you also have a valid point that he voted prplhz early, but never updated his read on him despite all prplhz's other posting.

Why has it taken you so long to come into the thread and contribute something, austin?

On September 20 2012 00:38 Blazinghand wrote:
Cause he doesn't care about the game. Tbh I was hoping he'd be mod killed so we wouldn't have to deal with him.

On September 20 2012 00:49 austinmcc wrote:

So cruel. But so true for most of my D1 performance.

On September 20 2012 01:08 marvellosity wrote:
Hapa, could you give me your current read on austin, please?

On September 20 2012 00:02 Zephirdd wrote:


##unvote
##vote prplhz

bluelightz sheeps any player who he feels to be town
blazinghand had his view changed but decided prplhz to be better after all
Mementoss has stated that his top scum read is the one guy he is voting, and most of his posts are somehow connected to prplhz's case or people who aren't on his case
austin looks bad, I don't disagree with it
I've posted my reasons earlier and IMP is clearly not happening
Ange is legit as well like you said

and finally, there is way too much resistance on prplhz. resistance in form of a marvellosity lynch that I find to be unjustified, in form of a mementoss lynch that is coming out of fucking nowhere, in form of terrible posts from iamperfection, in form of terrible posts from hiropro.

On September 20 2012 00:02 austinmcc wrote:
*snip*
So here's the thing. I don't get the feeling like mementoss is scumhunting. Not in the way that people should be getting that feeling about me, or others that have lurked. I get the feeling like he's been trying to show that he's scumhunting, but that his reactions are entirely wrong for someone who is doing so.

• His reaction to my TOO obvious post was to tell me not to be wishy-washy. When everyone else's reaction was "austinmcc scum." He then later notes that he applied pressure with his comments.
• He pokes at mkfuba, but when mkfuba responds with a nothingpost, mementoss doesn't care at all.
• He engages marv in discussion, after something weird, but seems to draw no conclusion from the discussion, ending at his starting point
• He voted prplhz based partially on BH's case (fine) and partially on prplhz asking who mkfuba was (not a scummy contradiction, NOT fine)

I know that it's shitty to be gone, throw out someone new, vote them, try to switch votes, blah blah. But mementoss is the most scummy person to me. I'd rather vote someone scummy than sheep, although prplhz isn't a pure sheep, he doesn't look great and I was really worried about something Zephirdd mentioned, that mini where he got pinned on D1, claimed cop, and then just sat back all game.

Still...mementoss scummier.

##Unvote
##Vote: Mementoss

---

---

Hapa, you had previous concerns over mementoss. They seem to still be around. How do you feel about his reactions to my TOO obvious post and mkfuba's weird post?

marv and palmar, you guys both found me SCUMMY based on that TOO obvious post. How do you feel about mementoss's reaction? Was he just calmer about it, or does it actually feel like he responded in an entirely different way than a town mindset player would?

Other folks. Has mementoss done a thing you're happy with? Contributed something you're happy with?

On September 19 2012 22:41 austinmcc wrote:
I have been absent. I am getting this vote into thread because the deadline is coming. I like it better than the other options that MIGHT be legitimate at this point, which seem to be ... just marv?

##Vote: prplhz


I think I'd much rather lynch bluelightz, unless there's been any action on that front, but I don't believe that's going to happen.

On September 20 2012 01:06 Hapahauli wrote:
##Vote mementoss

I'll re-iterate what I said before. Mementoss voted for prplhz early in the game. He never once questioned prplhz, and hasn't mentioned him for well over 24 hours while having his vote on him. This makes no sense from a townie perspective.

As for prplhz, I have a townie read on him. Too many people are sheeping his case. Things are coming together too easily. Finally, I don't agree with Ange's case. Ange reads his posts as "useless fluff", and therefore he's scum. I read his posts completely differently, and see a townie who's being open with his suspicions.

For example, look how he voted marv, and explicitly stated he had reservations about it. That's not scum behavior. Voting for someone you don't believe is scum = scum behavior. Voting someone while expressing reservations is a cautious townie. What's the point of including that reservations line as scum? It's just as easy to sheep and tunnel marv without any reservations.

To me, his "reservations" say that he's open about his reads and mentality. I believe prplhz is town.

Please take a look at mementoss's filter. There's nothing townie about it. He seemingly forgot about his suspicions prplhz and has been trying to point fingers since. Like read his filter, he never has a definite scumread and has been fanning the flames of several cases made through the day; astinmcc, mkfuba, and most recently marv.

On September 20 2012 01:20 Mementoss wrote:
While I got your attention, why don't you answer this... How do you go from voting Prplhz, to saying I would like BL to be lynched to making a case on me within an hour.




Its not just that you'd rather lynch bluelightz youd MUCH rather. Yet you don't even explain why you think he's scummy or attempt to convince anyone he is scum. Then you spend time making a case on me. What happened to BL, if you'd much rather lynch him why was there no case on him? This time-line makes no sense to me, it makes it seem like your just making up targets as you go, and you don't really care who gets lynched. On that note, where the fuck is bluelightz anyways, or perfection, or HiroPro.

Also, why do people keep saying they think prphlz is town without explaining it? All they say is, look big post, big post = cares, cares=town. It makes no sense. And the fact that several people have been doing it, is very strange. The way this prphlz lynch has been going down all day, makes me think he is scum for sure.

On September 20 2012 01:22 Mementoss wrote:
EBWOP: @ Hapa if you read my last post before my defence post, I mention that I still maintain that I think prphlz is scum and the way the lynch is going makes me think he is scum even more.