|
Summary for everyone:
Overall 10 people left, listing below... 3 Scum, 7 Town... Scum has 2 KP, we have one Vigi left... Riddlers shots will go into effect this night based on his game, the three people who fail at his game (one of whom seems to be me =_=)
Evantrees - Scummy
-_-quails - realized why people keep calling him qualis, BC misspelled his name on the filter list >_<
forumite - Penguin
rgtheschworz - Mr. Freeze
Katina - No clue
Adam4167 - Very pro-town
Hiro Protagonist - Very scummy, but VE was pushing for his lynch :S
Jayjay54 - His defensiveness reminds me of VE, lol...
jaybrundage - VE was pushing to lynch him
RayzorFlash - Vanilla town
This is confusing because a lot of the people left alive have been super lurky, theres very few people with more than 2 pages in their filter... It might end up just being a crapshoot...
|
EBWOP: (one of whom seems likely to be me =_=)
|
|
|
Okay, we can win this if we lynch correctly, I shoot the right one tonight, then you clean it up after.
rg, explain yourself!
|
What are your thoughts, Forumite?
|
On February 18 2012 17:30 Adam4167 wrote:
What are your thoughts, Forumite?
Anger mostly. The two most vocal players yesterday were Scum VE, and Palmar who wasn´t helping. I should have shot VE the night before last, we´d have been in a much better position now.
Right now rg looks bad, because nothing about risks role-PM says anything about Mr Freeze, this together with yesterdays rant about Kurumi makes me want to take him out. He´s not the only scummy player though.
Not sure what to do about Hiro, all the dead scum have wanted him lynched, but could be WIFOM-crap.
Tomorrow 2 players will be dead by Town hands, and 2 will be dead by scum. If the lynch or nightshot doesn´t kill scum then the game is lost tonight. I will probably not survive the night, so this is it.
|
-_-quails - risk rolechecked
forumite - guaranteed in game, not Counterclaimed
Evantrees
rgtheschworz - Claimed Mr. Freeze, not guaranteed in game
Katina
Adam4167
Hiro Protagonist
Jayjay54
jaybrundage
RayzorFlash
|
The reasons we left rg alive is because Kurumi confirmed him, and because noone has claimed Mr Freeze yet. The reason he should be lynched is because he failed to correctly describe his role when risk claimed, because of his play, and because Kurumi left a poison pill in the game somewhere, and he´s most likely the one.
Checking the votes, he hasn´t been on a single pro-Town lynch apart from the Sheth-lynch, where scum all bandwagoned. He voted Quails D1, Forumite D3, and risk.nuke D4, making sure to avoid the popular lynches. He´s fakeclaimed Two-Face and fakeclaimed a Red check on DocH, which got the Three-Face thing going, and revealed DocH and Toades as blues. His play has been full of wild accusations, mostly of nowadays confirmed Town, and is disrupting when possible
He has been breadcrumbing, by making it laughably clear what he´s trying to appear as, with things like this: On February 10 2012 01:01 rgTheSchworz wrote:
I seriously don't get it.
I posted in a hurry because it's f...ing FREEZIN in my country atm and i had to go to school.
20 pg+ since I went afk.
Please explain Toad why i'm not Two-Face. Optimal Veteran-play is not to make sure scum knows you are a veteran and stays away from shooting you.
This is what I have so far, but I´m fairly confident he´s the one.
##vote rgTheSchworz
|
Do you think BM was trolling when he announced he took a hit on N1? Did we ever solve that?
|
What do you mean "Kurumi left a poison pill in the game somewhere"?
|
On February 18 2012 18:18 Adam4167 wrote:
Do you think BM was trolling when he announced he took a hit on N1? Did we ever solve that?
Didn´t he and Palmar claim late in the day?
Not sure, the old list could use updating, but with 3rd party lying about their moves, who knows?
On February 18 2012 18:22 Adam4167 wrote:
What do you mean "Kurumi left a poison pill in the game somewhere"? While we were lynching him, Kurumi dropped hints that it would end badly for us and that there was a surprise in store. It was in spite, but makes total sense from a CW perspective, to confirm scum as blues to make the game harder for Town.
|
Darn was close to getting to bed then started reading this again. Going to go over the day 1 and 3 vote lists and the riddler nonsense again.
So should be here for a bit.
Interesting idea concerning rgTheSchworz.
|
Forumite, can you read everything by jackal in the phonebooth QT and try and figure out where his N1 shot went... I have a theory, but if he was more upfront about it in there, all the better.
|
woah, I was convinvced that VE is scum and I didn't count the possibility of him being a PR, but yet I am pleasently surprised that he actually was the GF. Nice. Just sucks that Palmar is gone now 
KThis should absolutely be winnable. P is down to 2. Riddler is still coming up (I reread he kills night 5, because he starts at day 2 and not day 1). Evantrees and Rayzor are in this. Then again, we don't know, if they are still in it. Hmm. tough choice. I'd go for evantrees, but am afraid to lynch a KP.
Also, to make it clear for once and for all, I did not claim anything. Claiming is fucking stupid and the NKs show why. Forumite obviously wasn't shot and Solomon double stacked, if you all just had shut your mouthes, tunkeg would be still alive, and we still had a dt. That was just not good. Whatever.
rayzor, you really don't like me, do you? it's not my fault that his defense sounded like mine and what I say is actually true. Maybe I inspired him. Why don't I get any credit for pushing 100% the right play with Kurumi first and then killing VE? My "votes" are now 3/5, that's pretty good IMO.
I don't know what to make out of RG. The kurumi save doesn't really make sense to me. If he is really scum the coaches treat him like shit and use him as the all purpose gambling chip which keeps him alive surprisingly long :D I am leaning town, he just did too much stuff.
Nearly all of his play were anti-town. nukes move to save himself was actually pretty good and rg just stepping up and destroying it was stupid as shit. The CC could be based on the unfitting lore of two face / freeze.
This is atually getting hard. Tyran was a safe bet IMO...[WIFOM] VE was pushing for hiro and JB. Certainly not both are scum both scum. JB was pushing for VE really hard and his case was OK, so maybe hiro is scum afterall? Maybe not. [/WIFOM] Evantrees reaction of being called scum a billion times was just to sit it out. While he was "rereading" he hasn't provide any analysis whatsoever in the last few days. I try to deduct the scum identities by ruling out town people, too, which brings me to:
Evantrees
Hiro Protagonist
RayzorFlash
So if put under a gun my scum would look like this now...I hope I am not terribly wrong about rg...
I want to see a little more discussion (about candidates and wether we should lynch people in the riddler game) before I vote...
|
DAY 1 Lynch Vote list
+ Show Spoiler +Liquid`sheth - 7
hiroprotagonist
katina
Forumite
Palmar
radfield
Visceraeyes
tunkeg
Cyber_cheese - 12
Toadesstern
drH
slardar
ico/rayzorflash
tyrran
wbg
chaoser
liquid`sheth
jackal
opz
evantrees
billmurray
Kurumi – 1
Layabout
-_-quails – 2
rgtheschworz
kurumi
ico – 2
kitaman
adam4167
toadesstern – 2
Kenpachi
Risk.nuke
DrH – 2
Jayjay54
cyber_cheese
Chaoser – 1
Tobberoth
didn't vote
jaybrundage and someone else.
Day 3 Lynch Vote list
+ Show Spoiler +
Radfield - 9
Forumite
tunkeg
Toadesstern
-_-quails
palmar
adam4167
katina
kurumi
jaybrundage
Palmar - 1
hiro protagonist
Forumite - 1
rgtheschworz
chaoser - 6
Risk.nuke
radfield
ico/rayzorflash
kitaman
evantrees
Visceraeyes
hiro protagonist - 1
jayjay54
ico/rayzorflash - 3
Layabout
Chaoser
tyrran - 1
billmurray
|
On February 18 2012 19:25 evantrees wrote:DAY 1 Lynch Vote list + Show Spoiler +Liquid`sheth - 7
hiroprotagonist
katina
Forumite
Palmar
radfield
Visceraeyes
tunkeg
Cyber_cheese - 12
Toadesstern
drH
slardar
ico/rayzorflash
tyrran
wbg
chaoser
liquid`sheth
jackal
opz
evantrees
billmurray
Kurumi – 1
Layabout
-_-quails – 2
rgtheschworz
kurumi
ico – 2
kitaman
adam4167
toadesstern – 2
Kenpachi
Risk.nuke
DrH – 2
Jayjay54
cyber_cheese
Chaoser – 1
Tobberoth
didn't vote
jaybrundage and someone else. Day 3 Lynch Vote list + Show Spoiler +
Radfield - 9
Forumite
tunkeg
Toadesstern
-_-quails
palmar
adam4167
katina
kurumi
jaybrundage
Palmar - 1
hiro protagonist
Forumite - 1
rgtheschworz
chaoser - 6
Risk.nuke
radfield
ico/rayzorflash
kitaman
evantrees
Visceraeyes
hiro protagonist - 1
jayjay54
ico/rayzorflash - 3
Layabout
Chaoser
tyrran - 1
billmurray
posting list evantrees? now? really?
|
|
|
I'm an idiot................. unsure what I should do about that as of yet.(posted in votethread by mistake)
Have to start somewhere(also look a few posts up), to an extent solidifies my opinion on rayzorflash being scum, kind of doubting only two scum voted for cheese but it is possible I suppose.
We have to lynch/shoot 3 scum there is no great need to start with those who just might die to riddler from beyond the grave. That said I kind of doubt rayzorflash will end up dieing to riddler tonight.
more on the riddlers game.
kitaman27 choose the second option, it is ending tonight.
Second option. Choose 8 people. Over the course of 4 game days these players are given riddles (you provide each). On the first three nights the first person to correctly answer the riddle is safe and removed from the riddle game. On the last night the first two people to correctly submit the answer are safe and the remaining three are killed.
people still in the game(apprently) prior to kitaman27 's death. (another list sorry jayjay)
jaybrundage
rayzorflash
evantrees I escaped day 4
Palmar gone
chaoser dead
So today jaybrundage and rayzorflash both have a chance to get out of it.
so both, one or none of them will die to it tonight.
|
Votes Day 3, including chagned votes
+ Show Spoiler +- rgTheSchworz - 0
Jayjay54
Bill Murray
Forumite
Radfield
- Bill Murray - 0
Kurumi
-_-Quails
- Evantrees - 0
Radfield
Tunkeg
Kurumi
Toadesstern
Palmar
Chaoser
Adam4167
layabout
- Risk.nuke - 0
Jayjay54
- Tyrran - 1
layabout
Bill Murray
- Tunkeg - 0
Katina
- hiro protagonist - 1
jaybrundage
Jayjay54
- Radfield - 9
Forumite
Tunkeg
Palmar
Toadesstern
Kurumi
jaybrundage
-_-Quails
RayzorFlash
Katina
Adam4167
Adam4167
jaybrundage
- Palmar - 1
layabout
Radfield
Toadesstern
Jayjay54
VisceraEyes
RayzorFlash
hiro protagonist
- Forumite - 1
risk.nuke
rgTheSchworz
- rayzorflash - 2
kitaman27
risk.nuke
layabout
chaoser
VisceraEyes
Adam4167
- Chaoser - 6
Kitaman27
risk.nuke
Radfield
RayzorFlash
VisceraEyes
Evantrees
Rayzorflash and Evantrees looks Scum
Katina looks Town.
I´ll back off from rg for now, but from this I think the lynch should be between either RayzorFlash or Evantrees for their last desperate defence of Radfield.
|
The Riddler is dead, doesn´t that mean that those in the game are safe? There´s no riddle for them to answer, and even if there was, they can both get out of it by guessing right.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
