Mario Mini Mafia - Page 103

On November 16 2012 16:12 debears wrote:
I agree with BH Djo.

Why the fuck would the mafia lynch the godfather and their best player on day 1 with a last minute voteswing when they could easily stay on z-bo?

On November 16 2012 16:15 Djodref wrote:


The thing is it was really safe for a csum BH to switch to Hapa with 8 votes against Z-bo at 5 minutes before lynch.

On November 16 2012 16:15 debears wrote:
Based on above thought, who does that leave?

Thrawn (Djo)
Z-Bo (Can't vote himself as scum or gives away hapa)
Clarity
SnB

Who has been least helpful while active?

I'd say thrawn or Snb. Since thrawn got replaced, I'm willing to give you time to show you are town.
Clarity I found town for d1. I still have to look at him again.
SnB has done absolutely nothing for town

On November 16 2012 16:17 Blazinghand wrote:


Another reason to cut Djo some slack is that thrawn might have been unhelpful while active, but he DID end up getting replaced-- so we shouldn't hold that against Djo. Generally replacements should get a day of breathing room.

On November 16 2012 16:18 debears wrote:
And Djo

What has SnB done for town? Nothing
What has BH done? Helped lynch the godfather

It'd be a stupid gambit for scum. Town cred is worthless d1 for a scum bus. THINK ABOUT IT

On November 16 2012 16:20 Blazinghand wrote:


Another note, it'd probably be an infinitely better strat to do in reverse: Hapa, the godfather, who checks as town, should lynch me and bathe in glory (and he looked better than me at the time) and if anyone checks him, he comes back town.

I'm just not buying it. I'm me, of course, but like it sounds utterly implausible that I'm scum and me and Hapa talked and he was like "yeah man i think it's a good idea for you to lynch me"

On November 16 2012 18:09 Djodref wrote:
I don't think it is as unlikely as it seems. I have good arguments to support this but I'm phone posting from my car so I'm not in the best position to explain them in details but here are a few hints.
First things first, BH play is not town-like. Could we at least agree on this one ?
Secondly, when you look at C9++, from which the setup of our game is derived from, the roles of the mafia team are given after that the roles for the town are decided. So the mafia team have more info than us about the roles. My point is that for a goon, goon, GF scumteam, it is not so risky for a troll goon to claim JK, as it is less likely to have a real JK.
Thirdly, voting against Hapa could have been a soft bus vote rather than a real bus vote because a Hapa lynch was unlikely to happen. Nobody could have foresaw it, especially with the Kickstart switch coming from nowhere.

On November 16 2012 18:17 Djodref wrote:
It pisses me off that you don't want to consider a BH lynch given his prestation for all D1/N1. I understand that it is not likely for him to be scum given the circumstances but I think that he has taken advantge of it to auto proclaim himself ”confirmed town” when his play shows the opposite.
I don't like this at all and I'm not dropping this case until people start to realize that he is likely to be a goon after all.

It's still early D2 so I'll get some time to consider other players so please don't try to shush by stating that a BH lynch is not going to happen.

On November 16 2012 18:17 Djodref wrote:
It pisses me off that you don't want to consider a BH lynch given his prestation for all D1/N1. I understand that it is not likely for him to be scum given the circumstances but I think that he has taken advantge of it to auto proclaim himself ”confirmed town” when his play shows the opposite.
I don't like this at all and I'm not dropping this case until people start to realize that he is likely to be a goon after all.

It's still early D2 so I'll get some time to consider other players so please don't try to shush by stating that a BH lynch is not going to happen.