|
This thread is for discussing recent bans. Don't discuss other topics here. Take it to website feedback if you disagree with a ban or want to raise an issue. Keep it civil.NOTE: For those of you who want to find the actual ABL thread where the bans are posted. Please look in here: https://tl.net/forum/closed-threads/ |
Calgary26003 Posts
On February 07 2011 23:42 gods_basement wrote:
If idra gets permabanned, will you lock the idra fan club as well? If so, would it be to prevent the inevitable incessant whine in the thread, or would it be to sever your link with him entirely, or to serve as extra punishment?
I wouldn't see any reason to lock the fan club if he gets banned.
|
On February 08 2011 00:39 Liquid`Nazgul wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2011 00:22 Klive5ive wrote:
Grown men getting annoyed at nothing is pretty funny.
If someone posted an equally abrasive response as yours against the mods and for IdrA; they'd be banned instantly.
I still don't see why IdrA shouldn't be regarded as an equal to the mods. Every other article on this website is about him. He's given up more and creates more interest than everyone else put together. This just seems like a mod fueled ego-trip to me.
This ban serves no purpose other than to alienate IdrA fans and make TL more boring. You can run your site as you like. On mine I ask everyone including players to respect the staff that makes all of this possible. I will stand for that and have stood for that, and no matter whether it makes TL boring or nobody comes here anymore it will always stay that way. TL as it is today is the result of that vision.
I'm sure even Mani smirked at that post! Im calling out + Show Spoiler +Mani to honestly say whether he had a straight face when he read that!
Seriously, I think a sense of humor often lends credibility to bans; the lack of which makes a system totalitarian and frankly just begs for more jabs!
Maybe TL Admin is taking itself too seriously here...
|
what's ganna happen to idra next time nazgul goes to korea and meet him in real life?
|
SushilS was just temp banned for 2 days by Chill.
That account was created on 2010-11-16 14:16:31 and had 625 posts.
Reason: Misreading "Naz" as "Nazi" begets a 28 day ban reduction - But it's still ban-worthy. You have 4 warnings and a pretty poor post history. Please work on it.
Wait wait wait... Did he think "Liquid`Nazgul" was actually Liquid`Nazi?
|
On February 08 2011 03:56 DND_Enkil wrote:Show nested quote +SushilS was just temp banned for 2 days by Chill.
That account was created on 2010-11-16 14:16:31 and had 625 posts.
Reason: Misreading "Naz" as "Nazi" begets a 28 day ban reduction - But it's still ban-worthy. You have 4 warnings and a pretty poor post history. Please work on it. Wait wait wait... Did he think "Liquid`Nazgul" was actually Liquid`Nazi?
No, the end of the post said "Come on Naz..." and he thought it said "Come on Nazi"
|
Lol Idra doesn't know when to stop, first plexa, now mani..
|
What is the point in perma banning idra. Hes just gonna make another account and everyone is going to know who he is lol
I don't think you guys will ever perm him, like really? Hes done so much for this site lol but hes such a dick sometimes
oh hi there megalisk
|
On February 08 2011 04:06 Saturnize wrote:
What is the point in perma banning idra. Hes just gonna make another account and everyone is going to know who he is lol
I don't think you guys will ever perm him, like really? Hes done so much for this site lol but hes such a dick sometimes
oh hi there megalisk
People keep saying this, what has he done? He just plays SC2 and used to play SC1 and is very good at it. How did he help TL in this way?
|
Occasionally he brings good discussion when it comes to strategy, assuming he doesn't call someone else a fucking idiot before beginning his post.
|
On February 08 2011 04:08 Almin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2011 04:06 Saturnize wrote:
What is the point in perma banning idra. Hes just gonna make another account and everyone is going to know who he is lol
I don't think you guys will ever perm him, like really? Hes done so much for this site lol but hes such a dick sometimes
oh hi there megalisk People keep saying this, what has he done? He just plays SC2 and used to play SC1 and is very good at it. How did he help TL in this way?
Because he played BW in Korea, not that he was any good compared to the koreans but the fact of the matter is that he practiced with CJ Etnus which was/is pretty fucking huge for anyone outside of korea to do.
Honestly if he didn't do any of that stuff then he would probably be banned by now lol
|
So does this mean his stream is banned as well?
|
not the stream itself obviously as the stream is on an external streaming site, but streams of banned users are not displayed here.
|
On February 08 2011 04:27 Kleinmuuhg wrote:
So does this mean his stream is banned as well?
You'll just have to follow his stream or his twitter if you wanna watch.
|
United Kingdom16710 Posts
On February 08 2011 04:08 Almin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2011 04:06 Saturnize wrote:
What is the point in perma banning idra. Hes just gonna make another account and everyone is going to know who he is lol
I don't think you guys will ever perm him, like really? Hes done so much for this site lol but hes such a dick sometimes
oh hi there megalisk People keep saying this, what has he done? He just plays SC2 and used to play SC1 and is very good at it. How did he help TL in this way?
Apparently he contributed quite a bit to the BW strategy forums. For SC2, I'd wager his stream and just bits of progamer insight here and there.
|
On February 08 2011 01:26 SushilS wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2011 00:39 Liquid`Nazgul wrote:On February 08 2011 00:22 Klive5ive wrote:
Grown men getting annoyed at nothing is pretty funny.
If someone posted an equally abrasive response as yours against the mods and for IdrA; they'd be banned instantly.
I still don't see why IdrA shouldn't be regarded as an equal to the mods. Every other article on this website is about him. He's given up more and creates more interest than everyone else put together. This just seems like a mod fueled ego-trip to me.
This ban serves no purpose other than to alienate IdrA fans and make TL more boring. You can run your site as you like. On mine I ask everyone including players to respect the staff that makes all of this possible. I will stand for that and have stood for that, and no matter whether it makes TL boring or nobody comes here anymore it will always stay that way. TL as it is today is the result of that vision. I'm sure even Mani smirked at that post! Im calling out + Show Spoiler +Mani to honestly say whether he had a straight face when he read that! Seriously, I think a sense of humor often lends credibility to bans; the lack of which makes a system totalitarian and frankly just begs for more jabs! Maybe TL Admin is taking itself too seriously here...
No, communists never laugh.
|
Hyrule19253 Posts
On February 08 2011 04:06 Saturnize wrote:
What is the point in perma banning idra. Hes just gonna make another account and everyone is going to know who he is lol
I don't think you guys will ever perm him, like really? Hes done so much for this site lol but hes such a dick sometimes
oh hi there megalisk
A) No he won't
B) Including the mods
Even if he did make a new account, it would get banned. You may want to look at all the PBU bans in the ABL.
|
Even then he'd be allowed back, albeit on a very tight leash, remember gosi[terran]?
|
On February 08 2011 04:31 TBO wrote:
not the stream itself obviously as the stream is on an external streaming site, but streams of banned users are not displayed here.
Yeah that the stream itself wouldnt be disabled is obvious, but thanks for the info that it is not displayed here. Now the bm seems even less understandable as it harms him so much..
|
On February 08 2011 07:02 Kleinmuuhg wrote:Show nested quote +On February 08 2011 04:31 TBO wrote:
not the stream itself obviously as the stream is on an external streaming site, but streams of banned users are not displayed here. Yeah that the stream itself wouldnt be disabled is obvious, but thanks for the info that it is not displayed here. Now the bm seems even less understandable as it harms him so much..
He's been doing this shit for years and no one really knows why. I mean he seems like a likeable guy irl when he's on camera and I've never heard anyone that met him in person say anything bad about him.
|
I think where my issue comes is, after 11,000 posts and many years, a certain amount of familiarity grows between everybody. Seriously, think about that. He has been a member of this site for many years. He has contributed, been interviewed, and participated in events on a weekly or daily basis. Even if you're not a mod or above the law, that familiarity breeds a level of comfort.
While I can't say for certain what IdrA's frame of mind is when he posts, I think banning for what is, at best, a poke at a moderator seems ridiculous. It's not as though he entered the thread and called Manifesto a retard or a piece of shit. He did a light jab that in the context of recent events (which is key, since it's not as though it was out of the blue) that was obviously meant to be funny. In that regard, I can see if you want to draw a line and say "no insulting of moderators, ever", but at the same time I think making IdrA the whipping boy (even if he deserves it at times) over it seems semi ridic.
Obviously I'm not privy to all the information and Manifesto's Garfield comics tend to point that there is obviously a lot more conflict behind the scenes, so I could be ridiculous far off base. If those (behind the scenes issues) are the primary reason for the ban, then I can't really speak on the matter. If it's solely based upon that post and his previous bans/comments that I think it is overblown.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
