| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
MockHamill
Sweden1798 Posts
Even though it is theoretically possible to play late game vs Protoss the mechanical requirements are so extremely high it is not feasible in practice. I am not sure what the solution is. Maybe decrease Disruptor range and making HT 3 supply would help somewhat in the late game. Making Tempest less of hard counter to BCs would also help. | ||
|
Ben...
Canada3485 Posts
On March 09 2019 21:31 Tyrhanius wrote: You're missing the point and your knowledge is out of date. Parting faced a nydus rush on stream that hit at 3:50 that featured 3-4 queens and mass zerglings off essentially one base (there was a second hatchery for production only). This rush has also appeared on several other prominent protoss streams. That timing is before warpgate is done, and on the map he was on, Year Zero, the rush distance was big enough that adepts would be unable to make it to the main to scout in time or would scout as the worm was already put down in the protoss base. Parting actually managed to kill the first nydus head after the queens and some of the zerglings had got out, but the problem is that the zerg started a second at his natural the instant the first one finished and it was more or less unstoppable since all Parting's units were tied up in the main trying to kill the all the units there. So he then proceeded to lose his entire natural mineral line with little in ways to defend.Fastest nyndus build i know is hatch first, lair ASAP no speedling, 1 more gas, roach warren, nyndus and it comes at 4:30. This build have existed since ever (here is a vod from 2015 that explains how to do it : www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUjLd0LPqfQ)... The change on nyndus doesn't make it much stronger, actually before it was invincible and you couldn't prevent it to pop. The scouting is easy, you send the shade of your adept on B1 to check and see the fast lair, aslo no B3 (or maybe a fake one), no speedling . And then like vs every two bases all-in you cut worker production and build emergency army. The number of units you need to kill a nyndus have been posted on battle.net : 0.1 time reaction : https://docdro.id/wz6J3zH 5s time reaction (= 9s left to kill nyndus): https://docdro.id/qGPxs9N 10s time reaction : https://docdro.id/96SVCKx No way this all-in works vs someone decent if scouted. The problem is you don't scout... Also you start whining here for that one time you need to learn to deal with a cheese from zerg, while zerg has to learn each season to defend the new P/T cheese : Beginning of LOTV : proxy reapers everygame, adepts cheese each time, MSC core harass, then 2/1/1, oracles harass, PICA, archons drops etc... Now recently we had the proxy canon immortal/shield batteries, we face archons drops every games, learn to face the BC with teleport, cyclons/hellions new style, and we still need to know how to counter the old shool cheeses. Recently, i've die on a proxy reaper as i was doing the fast three hatch before the first reaper arrive so i have late speedling. You complain that each nyndus you kill only cost 50/50 ? I would love to make that trade, currently if i don't see the DT i'm dead, but if i perfectly react to it, Protoss just make archons, kill free stuff, and with pick up range he can't lose them. And sorry, if zerg is doing the nyndus all-in, he is all-in, it fails end of the game = victory for you. The BC/archons drops etc... are not all-in, we don't counter =defeat for us, we counter and the game just continue and we can still lose. Here you seem like the the child too spoiled that start to complain at the first frustration while his other siblings were taught the hard way and suffered ten times more than that without complaining. So pick the data we provide to you, learn to counter that BO, and stop acting it's imbalance when it's just a learn to play issue like us zerg need to face every seasons. The problem isn't the rush itself, it's that this rush is in the same category as the 1/1/1 was. If you prepare for it and it happens, you're fine, but if you prepare and it doesn't happen you are automatically behind and will likely lose. Not preparing for it amounts to a build order loss. It's the same reasoning they got rid of hatch tech drops last year. Those forced the opponent to play a certain way to defend them or else risk losing the game outright. The new nydus is exactly the same. This rush is in some ways more powerful than the old invincible nydus rush in that the unload speed is so fast that the zerg is all but guaranteed to get multiple queens out and get a transfuse done while the zerglings exit fast enough to overwhelm the protoss, and since the exits are so cheap, zerg can throw down a second one far from the first and protoss basically can't defend both at once. The only way to hold it comfortably is to rush higher damage units like zealots, immortals, void rays, etc. and have perfect vision of your base at all times. This puts protoss behind if zerg does literally anything else than a nydus rush. If they scout protoss is preparing to defend nydus, they can just drone and then be massively ahead because protoss is spending all their gas to defend something that isn't going to happen. The balance team's idea for using nydus in the mid and late game is cool, and quite like BW, but the changes they made to nydus made it slightly better for that intent, but were a big buff to rushes, which is exactly what they said they wanted to get away from. To fix this issue all they literally need to do is either make the heads take longer to pop so there is a better chance of the defender killing them, or make the nydus building itself take a bit longer to build. Defending this rush even 30 seconds later would be much more reasonable for the protoss player since they could have the units in time and not scouting it would be on them. But as it is right now, this rush hits when protoss has at most 2-3 gateway units and maybe an oracle and mass zerglings and a few queens can kill that small of an army with little trouble. | ||
|
Cyro
United Kingdom20319 Posts
You're missing the point and your knowledge is out of date. Parting faced a nydus rush on stream that hit at 3:50 that featured 3-4 queens and mass zerglings off essentially one base (there was a second hatchery for production only). This rush has also appeared on several other prominent protoss streams. That timing is before warpgate is done, and on the map he was on, Year Zero, the rush distance was big enough that adepts would be unable to make it to the main to scout in time or would scout as the worm was already put down in the protoss base. Parting actually managed to kill the first nydus head after the queens and some of the zerglings had got out, but the problem is that the zerg started a second at his natural the instant the first one finished and it was more or less unstoppable since all Parting's units were tied up in the main trying to kill the all the units there. So he then proceeded to lose his entire natural mineral line with little in ways to defend. The problem isn't the rush itself, it's that this rush is in the same category as the 1/1/1 was. If you prepare for it and it happens, you're fine, but if you prepare and it doesn't happen you are automatically behind and will likely lose. Not preparing for it amounts to a build order loss. It's the same reasoning they got rid of hatch tech drops last year. Those forced the opponent to play a certain way to defend them or else risk losing the game outright. The new nydus is exactly the same. My ZvP MMR is higher than PvZ despite playing protoss 10x more because of this opening - so many ways that P can play amount to a straight up build order loss but a tailored counter only gives each side a chance to win while putting P behind against some other plays. It's so early in the game that a lot of scouting can't yet come into play, a common theme in ridiculous coinflip/all-in openings over the years. The nydus buffs were also specifically focused on making it a nearly unstoppable force in the extremely early game which seems bizarre to me; changes like giving it a lot of armor before it comes out of the ground. That's far more relevant for building a nydus in somebodies face at 3:50 - so that they can't stop it despite having most of their units and a worker surround hitting the underground worm - than it is for any kind of midgame nydus play. Load/unload speed is good. | ||
| ||
Replay Cast
Crank Gathers S2: Playoffs D1
BASILISK vs Shopify Rebellion
Team Liquid vs Team Falcon
[ Submit Event ] |
|
StarCraft: Brood War Dota 2 League of Legends Counter-Strike Other Games |
|
Replay Cast
WardiTV Invitational
ByuN vs Spirit
herO vs Solar
MaNa vs Gerald
Rogue vs GuMiho
Epic.LAN
CrankTV Team League
BASILISK vs Team Liquid
Epic.LAN
BSL Team A[vengers]
Dewalt vs Shine
UltrA vs ZeLoT
BSL 21
BSL Team A[vengers]
Cross vs Motive
Sziky vs HiyA
BSL 21
Replay Cast
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
