| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
poorcloud
Singapore2748 Posts
On December 23 2011 22:15 Switchy wrote: 'You guys are terrible casters, but its not a personal attack.'.... Whatever lol Well to add on, people can express their opinions on the poll without fear of being attacked by other people. Apparently, majority likes khaldor so whats your beef? | ||
|
Biggun69
187 Posts
On December 23 2011 22:05 Twisted wrote: Edited out. First you personally attack the casters than you say it's not a personal attack? wtf? This is meant to be a thread where people can give contructive criticism to help Khaldor improve his casting not some dumb rant on who GomTV hire and saying that all the code A casters are bad. | ||
Twisted
Netherlands13554 Posts
| ||
|
Dob
3 Posts
| ||
|
Twisted
Netherlands13554 Posts
Meh never mind what I said, I guess this isn't the topic for it. Only constructive criticism I can give you is this: work on the accent. You really need to work on sounding like a native English speaker. Maybe this will improve if you only talk to English-speaking people and while in Korea, I guess it should improve. | ||
|
Mantraz
Norway119 Posts
I feel you're synegery with Wolf is great, but I dislike how harsh you can be to the players at times if they slip a little. I dont enjoy the "he's really horrible" wording and so on as an intro if a player is a bit off in a matchup (they're still s class...). That being said, you've improved a tonn since i first saw your casts (atleast the english ones, your germans didnt cater too much to me..  ) | ||
|
Silentenigma
Turkey2037 Posts
On December 23 2011 22:29 Twisted wrote: Maybe I shouldn't have posted it because I kind of figured out I'd get responses like that though. Had to rant somewhere other than the mailbox over at gomtv. Meh never mind what I said, I guess this isn't the topic for it. Only constructive criticism I can give you is this: work on the accent. You really need to work on sounding like a native English speaker. Maybe this will improve if you only talk to English-speaking people and while in Korea, I guess it should improve. Stop being an elitist jerk their accent is fine Most people understand them fine.You dont have to sound native english speaker to cast a starcraft game. | ||
|
Ghrimnar
Germany260 Posts
| ||
|
Absentia
United Kingdom973 Posts
Any problems in your casting, (small errors in English, occasional bumps in flow with other casters) will be ironed out with experience. One thing I do really like about your casting is that you're not afraid to contest what your co commentator is saying. I imagine some people don't like this, but I think it makes the cast sound more like a discussion. Furthermore, if your co commentator is wrong, the error should be pointed out in some way. Overall, I'm looking forward to more of your casting next year. | ||
|
aebriol
Norway2066 Posts
Keep up the good work. ps: Unlike some previous casters with an accent, I have no trouble understanding you at all. But that may be because I am also European, so I might be used to hearing a similar accent. | ||
|
Nickemwit
United States253 Posts
| ||
|
nepeta
1872 Posts
You may say whatever you want, even if it's not in tune with the TL hive mind. At my first job I was told a complaint is actually a compliment, for it gives one the chance to improve. If customers (e.g. watchers/listeners) bother to comment, at least they care, if they don't, they'll just walk away and you find yourself wondering why. | ||
|
nepeta
1872 Posts
Manner yo! Apparently you disagree, but you might want to express it in a somewhat more mannered way. | ||
|
Pirat6662001
Russian Federation949 Posts
| ||
|
Awesomeness
Germany1361 Posts
| ||
|
Zalithian
520 Posts
| ||
|
Twisted
Netherlands13554 Posts
On December 23 2011 23:25 nepeta wrote: Twisted :o You may say whatever you want, even if it's not in tune with the TL hive mind. At my first job I was told a complaint is actually a compliment, for it gives one the chance to improve. If customers (e.g. watchers/listeners) bother to comment, at least they care, if they don't, they'll just walk away and you find yourself wondering why. I know but I was overly harsh to good-willed people and that doesn't really work in a community where average and sub-par performances are easily forgiven because 'they support esports' even though they are paid for their work by (to some extent) the season passes costumers buy. Ok, /sarcasm. It just doesn't do any good. Even if I actually give constructive crisicism, i.e. try to tone down the accent, I get called elitist prick for no reason by probably a very young person so what's the use. 'Accent is no issue because it's a game of Starcraft' lol what kind of argument is that. I shouldn't even waste time on that actually haha. If you're gonna be an English-speaking caster you should try to work on ironing out the accent because it distracts a lot and it's downright annoying. At least it is to me and I consider myself pretty normal when it comes to pretty much all subjects, so there must be more people that think the same. Obviously everyone understands Khaldor just fine because his English is fine. It's the German accent he needs to drop to improve his casting-voice. | ||
|
Bulugulu
Israel250 Posts
Personally I wasn't very fond of your casting due to your slightly off english, however recently i'm enjoying it more. I think you've improved by being more relaxed and easy going during the casts, and your casting has become more fluent. I hope you continue to improve, your game understanding definitely gives you the potential to be excellent. | ||
|
Figgy
Canada1788 Posts
Decent play by play and voice imo, nowhere near the level of the other popular casters but it's alright. | ||
|
Schwopzi
Netherlands954 Posts
On December 23 2011 23:38 Twisted wrote: I know but I was overly harsh to good-willed people and that doesn't really work in a community where average and sub-par performances are easily forgiven because 'they support esports' even though they are paid for their work by (to some extent) the season passes costumers buy. Ok, /sarcasm. It just doesn't do any good. Even if I actually give constructive crisicism, i.e. try to tone down the accent, I get called elitist prick for no reason by probably a very young person so what's the use. 'Accent is no issue because it's a game of Starcraft' lol what kind of argument is that. I shouldn't even waste time on that actually haha. If you're gonna be an English-speaking caster you should try to work on ironing out the accent because it distracts a lot and it's downright annoying. At least it is to me and I consider myself pretty normal when it comes to pretty much all subjects, so there must be more people that think the same. Obviously everyone understands Khaldor just fine because his English is fine. It's the German accent he needs to drop to improve his casting-voice. Having a accent is not something that -needs- to be dropped in order to cast in english for a big audience. There are plenty of people that enjoy "accent english" (I have no idea how to properly phrase that ><) more then native english, which by the way also comes in lots of accents. Just because you consider yourself "normal" and think your opinion is the same as the majority doesn't actually make it so and makes for a pretty flawed arguement. There are always things a caster can work on and Khaldor still has a long road ahead of him sharpening his craft. "Having a german accent" however is open for debate on being a good thing for shaping his identity & setting him apart from other casters (we don't want a completely homogenous caster squad doing everything right? :<). | ||
| ||
StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Sea Dota 2 2581Pusan  520BeSt 290Jaedong  172sSak 53Mong 41zelot 25Sharp 23Rush 22Noble 22[ Show more ] Counter-Strike Heroes of the Storm Other Games Organizations Counter-Strike Other Games StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War Other Games StarCraft 2 StarCraft: Brood War |
|
GSL Code S
ByuN vs Rogue
herO vs Cure
Replay Cast
GSL Code S
Classic vs Reynor
GuMiho vs Maru
The PondCast
RSL Revival
GSL Code S
OSC
Korean StarCraft League
RSL Revival
SOOP
HeRoMaRinE vs Astrea
[ Show More ] |
|
|
EPT
