EPTWhich commentator has the highest play skill level - Page 5
| Forum Index > SC2 General |
|
iRRelevance
Romania725 Posts
| ||
|
Treemonkeys
United States2082 Posts
On March 25 2011 00:51 Kvothe wrote: Artosis is often regarded as the best commentator in terms of understanding the game....not sure where you came up with that. You might be thinking sololy tasteless, who often makes the wrong call. You only need to watch all GSLs to come up with that. Artosis does it all the time - he consistently underestimates what players are able to hold off and do, though he is much better now compared to season one. I think it was season 2 where he was saying "14 hatch doesn't work anymore" and then the zerg proceeds to hold 14 hatch perfectly fine every game rofl. He's really good but he also just bases too much on his own skill and experience and acts like he knows all. | ||
|
HavoK.
United States172 Posts
On March 25 2011 00:42 faulty wrote: I'd say Artosis, but just because I've seen him play recently (relatively speaking) EDIT: I have a feeling that once Day9 graduates he'll be showing his true colors :D agreed it would seem to be artosis at the moment but if day starts playing competitively again that would just be awesome. | ||
|
Drock
United States305 Posts
| ||
|
s031720
Sweden383 Posts
| ||
|
Spikeworld
Germany61 Posts
| ||
|
bokchoi
Korea (South)9498 Posts
| ||
|
Greek820
Canada210 Posts
| ||
|
Silmakuoppaanikinko
799 Posts
On March 25 2011 01:30 Treemonkeys wrote: Pretty much, he makes bad call after bad call. Now this wouldn't be so bad if he said 'MC is gonna have a hard time with this!', but he says 'There is 0% chance MC can hold this, now, some of you noobs may think 'what if he does ...', but no, trust me, there is 0% chance.', and then he holds it with minimal losses. =/ Never gotten why Kelly gets all the burn when Nick and Dan really make bad calls with supreme confidence all day.You only need to watch all GSLs to come up with that. Artosis does it all the time - he consistently underestimates what players are able to hold off and do, though he is much better now compared to season one. And also, like I said, he tends to have 'hipster reasoning', he seems to fall for 'this is original / not done before, thus it is good.' a lot, the only reason he thinks 2base colossus is bad is because it's trite, and then he tries to come up with justifications like costs and transitions which are really ill-argued to justify his hipsterosity. Note that I also don't 2base colossus or colossus that much at all really for the exact same reason, it's trite, I like to be different, but I'm not going to pretend that this build used by high class players like Tester who play with huge amounts of money on the line is actually 'bad', and I'd probably use it more if there were money on the line for me too. | ||
|
Hairy
United Kingdom1169 Posts
On March 25 2011 01:16 Sein wrote: I'm not sure why so many people are mentioning Day9 when they probably haven't seen a single game of him playing SC2 for almost a year. His understanding of the game is undeniably good and he'd probably make an excellent coach for just about anyone, but that doesn't mean that his level of play is at the very top level. Well we at least know that he's in masters, and we know that he is still buddies / practice partners with some great players. Is he at the "very top level"? Perhaps with practice he could be. From my understanding, Day[9] doesn't want to reveal any information about his playing because he feels it would change how people judge him as a caster. The rumours that he might start playing again when he's finished at university are intriguing though, as that means if/when we DO see Day9 playing again he's going to be hotsauce :D I'd LOVE to see a shoutcaster tournament (though who would cast it....?) - I'd pay good money to see Husky get hulksmashed  | ||
|
deejY
Germany44 Posts
| ||
|
Geo.Rion
7377 Posts
| ||
|
Zedex
United Kingdom310 Posts
| ||
|
PeaNuT_T
Sweden326 Posts
| ||
|
Silmakuoppaanikinko
799 Posts
On March 25 2011 01:36 Hairy wrote: Husky's understanding of the game is pathetic. He's really a person I think I can hang out with though, the way he likes trolls, how he never gets angry, the way he responded in the thread about TSL2 abusers, I like people who don't have a large sense of 'justice' and are hard to get angry and just brush it off.I'd LOVE to see a shoutcaster tournament (though who would cast it....?) - I'd pay good money to see Husky get hulksmashed But really, his balance insinuations which are often due to his own terrible misunderstanding of the game tend to be some-what annoying. ('phoenices don't counter vikings, you need void rays, as they do bonus damage to armoured', WOT?) | ||
|
Existential
Australia2107 Posts
| ||
|
Treemonkeys
United States2082 Posts
On March 25 2011 01:35 Silmakuoppaanikinko wrote: Pretty much, he makes bad call after bad call. Now this wouldn't be so bad if he said 'MC is gonna have a hard time with this!', but he says 'There is 0% chance MC can hold this, now, some of you noobs may think 'what if he does ...', but no, trust me, there is 0% chance.', and then he holds it with minimal losses. =/ Never gotten why Kelly gets all the burn when Nick and Dan really make bad calls with supreme confidence all day. And also, like I said, he tends to have 'hipster reasoning', he seems to fall for 'this is original / not done before, thus it is good.' a lot, the only reason he thinks 2base colossus is bad is because it's trite, and then he tries to come up with justifications like costs and transitions which are really ill-argued to justify his hipsterosity. Note that I also don't 2base colossus or colossus that much at all really for the exact same reason, it's trite, I like to be different, but I'm not going to pretend that this build used by high class players like Tester who play with huge amounts of money on the line is actually 'bad', and I'd probably use it more if there were money on the line for me too. Yeah exactly. He also comes across as a person who just enjoys acting and being perceived smart which bites him in the ass when he acts way too sure and then is proven wrong. Personally I think it makes the cast more entertaining, so it's all good and maybe intentional, but he does in fact make bad calls all the time. | ||
|
ELA
Denmark4608 Posts
Ofc both Tasteless, Artosis, Day9, InControL are on another level, but they're all former pro's that switched or partially switched to commentating | ||
|
rakura
United States183 Posts
| ||
|
jimminy_kriket
Canada5520 Posts
Edit: and day[9] and any other top players that do commentary some times. | ||
| ||
