On March 16 2016 02:18 Hexe wrote:
Playing zerg on any dark map is nightmare. Hard to see creep hard to see burrowed mines lurks statis wards. LotV has been a step down on the map visual aspect

That's one of the reason I've been avoiding a lot of the LotV textures, many of them are busy and make mines and such too hard to see.

opisska

Poland8852 Posts

March 15 2016 23:40 GMT

#42

So do I understand it correctly that this issue discussed here should be invisible to me, as I play on Low everything? I always considered SC2 quite dark, but I have just cranked up the gamma and it's generally fine.

The only exception for me is Central Protocol, which I have banned after one game. There is weird blending of creep which makes every place where I have creep really confusing with random bright and dark places, where I can't even see my units properly.

Avexyli

United States689 Posts

March 16 2016 01:07 GMT

#43

You shouldn't see any lighting issues on Lowest settings, no.

The creep thing is because LotV uses a different normal.dds for creep than HotS does. You can see this when looking between maps like Orbital Shipyard and possibly Lerilak Crest, with any other Legacy map.

I talked about this here.

Hexe

United States332 Posts

March 16 2016 03:13 GMT

#44

On March 16 2016 10:07 Avexyli wrote:
You shouldn't see any lighting issues on Lowest settings, no.

The creep thing is because LotV uses a different normal.dds for creep than HotS does. You can see this when looking between maps like Orbital Shipyard and possibly Lerilak Crest, with any other Legacy map.

I talked about this here.

I have problems seeing mines/burrowed on low. Lurker spines by themselves on white paint would be hard to spot where its coming from, let alone Fields of fucking Death.

Cyro

United Kingdom20274 Posts

March 16 2016 07:34 GMT

#45

Yeah, i tried playing on low after this discussion and went back after 2 games because i was throwing half of my stuff away into widow mines that were suddenly way harder to see

Existor

Russian Federation4295 Posts

March 16 2016 11:00 GMT

#46

I'd like to suggest Hybrid Settings to solve your problems with dark graphic in ZvZ on dark maps.

Low settings applying dark filter/shadow over every object. here is the comparison:

[image loading]

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/starcraft-2/498454-hybrid-settings-30-lotv-edition

Cyro

United Kingdom20274 Posts

March 16 2016 11:30 GMT

#47

That's something that would help but it's a bit of a band-aid fix to the problem - it creates some other issues (not being able to see some other things as well, have to use certain graphics settings) and will not be used by casters. I'd like to call for this to be adressed on a higher level.

One of my friends also said that he uses those settings because of map lighting issues and variability

FoxShine

United States156 Posts

March 28 2016 23:47 GMT

#48

On March 15 2016 07:50 Cyro wrote:

Show nested quote +

There is a lighting issue that affects a lot of maps - some of the ladder maps, most of the campaign stuff. Instead of having colors go from 0-255, they actually go from like 20-230 so the darkest color available is a light grey, usually tinted one color.

seems to be a map editor setting, because some maps run normally and others have that problem. If you know the setting, could you post comparison screenshots (with fog of war, of possible) between the live ladder map version and a "fixed" 0-255 version?

Neither of your screenshots seem to really show the issue. I'l take a screenshot ingame of what the map actually looks like.

The colors of everything dark on the map is squished. The blackest black is 14, 15, 23 - a blue tinted grey - and this also extends to the UI for some reason. On other maps, this is 0,0,0 as it's supposed to be.

-----

[image loading]

I made another picture, cut out a bit of the solid color and replaced it with black like it is on a bunch of maps and all of the pre-LOTV maps, to show the amount that the color has changed.

it seems obvious now that this might have been done with some artistic intent - but the end result is completely awful IMO. AT THE VERY LEAST it should be toggleable back to normal.

I noticed this color issue on release day when I started playing the campaign. I profile my display and use a colorimeter to calibrate led TVs ect, so this black level issue stood out immediately for me.

I'm bumping because I'm wondering if you found anymore info on a fix? Settings edit or something like that.

Ve5pa

United Kingdom252 Posts

March 29 2016 19:05 GMT

#49

Well the new map pool seems to be a bit brighter. Other than that, I doubt much will change. Even broadcasters can't really do much I assume. I don't play zerg myself but when watching a ZvZ of pro players sometimes it's still a bit of a nightmare on some maps and it certainly detracts from the actual gameplay at times, in my opinion anyways.

Cyro

United Kingdom20274 Posts

March 31 2016 00:01 GMT

#50

On March 29 2016 08:47 FoxShine wrote:

Show nested quote +

The fix is to yell at blizzard and post stuff on twitter/reddit until they edit the official maps

Not much more we can do, i think. Really just bring the issue into the public eye. This is something that i think a lot more people should have noticed (because it's extremely obvious to me and bothers me every time that i play) but it seems like a lot of people won't really notice it unless you show them an A vs B with an improved version.

It's the same for some other issues, like the microstutter that the game has. Everyone is just used to that and they don't know what a better version would feel like.

Fortunately this colour thing looks super fixable with a few slider drags, so it should be easy. I have not played for a little while so i can't say how the new season maps are yet

Isarios

United States153 Posts

March 31 2016 10:09 GMT

#51

Blizzard needs to make the ladder maps also just not super dark. The old maps that were dark such as Shakuras Plat were just really darn hard to see. They're not fun for anyone when you can't see a thing.
Its like playing Gameboy in your mom's car at night.

Cyro

United Kingdom20274 Posts

March 31 2016 16:45 GMT

#52

The darkness is a much smaller problem than the lighting settings IMO. I didn't have memorable issues seeing on Shakuras but it's physically uncomfortable to play on Dusk Towers

feanaro

United States123 Posts

March 31 2016 22:58 GMT

#53

Not a zerg, but I would like to throw in my two cents and say that a lot of maps are frustratingly dark to play on. I wish they wouldn't make it so you have to play on high graphics settings just to be able to see the map.

Avexyli

United States689 Posts

May 19 2016 22:25 GMT

#54

Not to necro, but I was messing with some map reskins and I think these images show how much the new lighting styles mess with dark colors:

Ladder Bridgehead:
[image loading]

New Bridgehead:
[image loading]

Basically means we can use the new lighting style (Filmic) but would have to get rid of Colorize - which kinda ruins the point of using Filmic.

Cyro

United Kingdom20274 Posts

June 03 2016 20:34 GMT

#55

On May 20 2016 07:25 Avexyli wrote:
Not to necro, but I was messing with some map reskins and I think these images show how much the new lighting styles mess with dark colors:

Basically means we can use the new lighting style (Filmic) but would have to get rid of Colorize - which kinda ruins the point of using Filmic.

Both links there are to the same image