EPTI remember when Jaedong was awarded the win over Flash and trashed the finals of MSL a long time ago.
I believe a regame is almost always the right option unless there is no chance of coming back. To not do so is to discredit micro etc. etc.
What is your opinion on the Parting/MKP decision in the GS…
| Forum Index > Polls & Liquibet |
|
ghosthunter
United States414 Posts
I remember when Jaedong was awarded the win over Flash and trashed the finals of MSL a long time ago. I believe a regame is almost always the right option unless there is no chance of coming back. To not do so is to discredit micro etc. etc. | ||
epicdemic
Netherlands137 Posts
On April 11 2012 16:56 Blacktion wrote: Parting had hardly any money, he couldnt keep up the warp ins he needed to finish the game there. If it didnt DC, MKP pulls scvs when his next round of rax units is out and holds that attack. Was parting ahead? Yes. Was the game over? No. Regame. EDIT: The new korean starcraft organisation should get together with IPL, MLG and IEM and possibly kespa if this switching business is actually happening and get on blizzards case about LAN. So much money/prestige on the line and games are being fucked up by easily avoidable netwrok issues? Come on Blizzard. Seriously. Pulling SCV's against HT.. Yeah right. You sir are very smart. | ||
|
epicdemic
Netherlands137 Posts
On April 11 2012 17:00 berndniph wrote: the poll says it all. regame was the right decision. The majority of the people in the poll thinks regame was not the right decision. And also, since there are more MKP fanboys than Squirtle fanboys, probably it was not the right decision  | ||
|
ghosthunter
United States414 Posts
On April 11 2012 17:55 epicdemic wrote: The majority of the people in the poll thinks regame was not the right decision. And also, since there are more MKP fanboys than Squirtle fanboys, probably it was not the right decision 42% is not a majority, adding a smiley face does not make your point any more valid or less insulting | ||
|
epicdemic
Netherlands137 Posts
On April 11 2012 18:05 ghosthunter wrote: 42% is not a majority, adding a smiley face does not make your point any more valid or less insulting 1248 think that it was the wrong decision. 1070 think it was the right decision. >> majority. Sometimes math is very hard. This is not one of those times. | ||
|
ConRa
Sweden42 Posts
 | ||
|
InfusedTT.DaZe
Romania693 Posts
On April 11 2012 03:18 00Visor wrote: relevant: (I didnt do this) ![[image loading]](http://i40.tinypic.com/2128lzk.jpg) its so clear, also alot of people voted with heart(for mkp and prime) so... | ||
|
Mirrikh
Romania105 Posts
| ||
|
Terranicle
5 Posts
The entertaining parts of this thread are the random percentages people are pulling out of thin air: "Parting had it won 99.5%". Really? 99.5% won? How are you quantifying that? He was ahead, admittedly, but thrashing your hand on your numpad to produce an arbitrary percentage detracts from any impact a statement might have. Things I think should start to be discussed are how to avoid this situation in the future. How do people feel about certain conditions leading to an auto-win? What should those conditions be? X amount of army supply ahead? X amount of total supply ahead? Production structures being camped? Gametime elapsed? A combination of these or more, or less? Conversely what conditions should result in a re-game? Army supply within X amount of eachother? Total supply within X amount of eachother? Gametime elapsed? Who can set these standards? Should they be set? Or do you enjoy the drama caused afterwards too much? | ||
|
Gastronucci
Denmark11 Posts
EDIT - FML | ||
|
Lazzi
Switzerland1923 Posts
| ||
|
Skaminator
112 Posts
| ||
|
noddy
United Kingdom927 Posts
| ||
|
docvoc
United States5491 Posts
| ||
|
AethariA
Canada22 Posts
| ||
|
Crazyglue
United States17 Posts
That simple | ||
|
DidYuhim
Ukraine1905 Posts
| ||
|
SmuZ
Romania45 Posts
| ||
|
leperphilliac
United States399 Posts
| ||
|
JMDj
United States454 Posts
On April 11 2012 18:35 epicdemic wrote: 1248 think that it was the wrong decision. 1070 think it was the right decision. >> majority. Sometimes math is very hard. This is not one of those times. You're thinking of a plurality, not a majority. Majority is 50% or more. I think parting should have been given the win. Obviously Startale was banking heavily on Parting taking out MKP as he is definitely the most capable Terran sniper on the team. Anyone who knows Starcraft would understand that a player of Parting's caliber was not going to lose from that position. | ||
| ||
