EPTOGN sure does have a nicer studio though, but as it is I'd say GOM wins.
SC2 production? - Page 5
| Forum Index > Polls & Liquibet |
|
DelRax
Australia54 Posts
OGN sure does have a nicer studio though, but as it is I'd say GOM wins. | ||
|
Djagulingu
Germany3605 Posts
On September 25 2011 08:25 Matkap wrote: do you say all that to you yourself when you go to sleep at nights? jeez relax..and well, why would I care if its on cable if im watching through the internet? you dont need a player for gom vods, and well, I would rather have casters that I understand you know, I guess that when tasteless was casting BW you didnt hate on him as much... I did like as well OGN of course and they`re a lot of really cool things there that are miles ahed of GOM, but its not like they do everything wrong Korean GomTV commentators are ex-ogn commentators. OGN replaced them with better ones. And Tasteless was much worse than korean OGN commentators during GomTV classic anyway, nothing changed since then. And not having to pay for the VODs is just so good. Not to mention OGN's studio and observers. And the fact that 4:3 resolution is the biggest complaint of the people means ogn is doing everything else right. | ||
|
T0fuuu
Australia2275 Posts
| ||
|
Fus
Sweden1112 Posts
| ||
|
Phayt
Canada346 Posts
This is the only correct answer. GomTV has the absolute best english casting in the entire scene. WCG Korea had NO english casting. So if you ask a primarily english website which production was better, well... Realistically? GomTV is the better SC2 broadcaster, no doubt. But OGN brought much of their e-sports expertise to the broadcast, and all the things they did right demonstrated all the things Gom could do better. Hell, for the Korean viewer, it may even have been better, I don't know. OGN definitely did a great job, lack of english aside. And the best thing? OGN IS BROADCASTING SC2! FUCK YEAH! | ||
|
MetalLobster
Canada532 Posts
| ||
|
mordk
Chile8385 Posts
I dunno, I wasn't even that big on BW. So it's not like I'm struck by nostalgia. I just think it's better overall, their experience shows in every aspect. As a gamer, it's simpler for me to put it this way: -GomTV right now, looks like HoN did on release. It had much better graphics than DotA, it had the engine right for the game. You didn't need things like WarKeys to set up hotkeys. -OGN broadcast, is the original DotA, no matter its flaws, it's an irreplaceable classic. | ||
|
Sina92
Sweden1303 Posts
| ||
|
Tomken
Norway1144 Posts
95% of comments support OGN, but GSL got double votes rofl. | ||
|
artynko
Slovakia86 Posts
| ||
|
Robinsa
Japan1333 Posts
| ||
|
Trizz
Netherlands1318 Posts
So there for, GOMTV leads the poll. But in reality, OGN are the better casters. | ||
|
Kogan
Germany84 Posts
On September 25 2011 07:56 Node wrote: I'm completely lost as to how people can discern that casters using a language they don't understand are better than casters using one they do. i agree, its kinda stupid to say korean casters are better cause they seem to be more pumped^^ | ||
|
sluggaslamoo
Australia4494 Posts
OGN: - Better Observers - Better Camera Usage (doom zooms) - Enthusiasm - Professionalism - Post-Game Recaps GOM: - English commentary (racist and unfair criteria), - Graphics (even though free stream is as good as goms, HD available on ogn.net for free if you can read korean, no lag!!!!!) Remember GOM was the worst broadcaster back in BW, if OGN got a full hold of SC2 there would be no contest. On September 25 2011 23:23 Kogan wrote: i agree, its kinda stupid to say korean casters are better cause they seem to be more pumped^^ Because people do translations on live-stream or actually understand korean, I have a korean friend who often tells me what the commentators are saying and its much more in-depth/funny/interesting/relevant than what you normally hear from the English casters. Often when Tastosis says something funny, it doesn't have much to do with the game, but Korean commentators will often say something funny that is also relevant to the game. (Exception is Tasteless on BW, he was at that level then, he seems to have lost a lot of his commentating flair in SC2) The commentator was like, "The tanks became the protoss's friends!" Lol on commentators on 21:35, "This is the time where the opponents say I wish he take a break and go to the bathroom, but at this stage of the game even if Stork goes to the bathroom this is game" LOLL Also if a commentator gets you much more engaged in a game, then that's tantamount to his ability as a commentator. | ||
GTR
51540 Posts
On September 25 2011 17:56 Djagulingu wrote: Korean GomTV commentators are ex-ogn commentators. OGN replaced them with better ones. And Tasteless was much worse than korean OGN commentators during GomTV classic anyway, nothing changed since then. And not having to pay for the VODs is just so good. Not to mention OGN's studio and observers. And the fact that 4:3 resolution is the biggest complaint of the people means ogn is doing everything else right. uh, they aren't ex-ogn commentators. lee hyun-joo was a former mbc caster, that's about it. the current commentators didn't have any previous casting background before being hired by gom for their classic league. | ||
|
mrRoflpwn
United States2618 Posts
| ||
|
sluggaslamoo
Australia4494 Posts
On September 26 2011 00:32 mrRoflpwn wrote: I personally thought the OGN observer was terrible- he never went back to the players main bases and let us see the production facilities. They almost never had the production tab open, and he would also many times cut to a battle late which was frustrating. Production tab is terrible for spectating IMO. | ||
|
windsupernova
Mexico5280 Posts
On September 25 2011 23:32 sluggaslamoo wrote: Lol what a biased poll, after looking at the responses. OGN: - Better Observers - Better Camera Usage (doom zooms) - Enthusiasm - Professionalism - Post-Game Recaps GOM: - English commentary (racist and unfair criteria), - Graphics (even though free stream is as good as goms, HD available on ogn.net for free if you can read korean, no lag!!!!!) Remember GOM was the worst broadcaster back in BW, if OGN got a full hold of SC2 there would be no contest. Because people do translations on live-stream or actually understand korean, I have a korean friend who often tells me what the commentators are saying and its much more in-depth/funny/interesting/relevant than what you normally hear from the English casters. Often when Tastosis says something funny, it doesn't have much to do with the game, but Korean commentators will often say something funny that is also relevant to the game. (Exception is Tasteless on BW, he was at that level then, he seems to have lost a lot of his commentating flair in SC2) http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L83ju7jfJ1I http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0IK6rECL3Qc#t=19m15s Also if a commentator gets you much more engaged in a game, then that's tantamount to his ability as a commentator. Wat?! How does liking a commentary in a language that you understand is ¨racist¨? I voted for OGN but that is a ridiculous argument. And I think you are selling GOM short there,but its your opinion. I just don´t like the racism argument lol | ||
|
branflakes14
2082 Posts
| ||
|
MildSeven
Canada311 Posts
 | ||
| ||
