EPTPower Rank 12/01/2009 - Page 26
| Forum Index > Polls & Liquibet |
|
johanes
Czech Republic2231 Posts
| ||
|
SuperArc
Austria7781 Posts
On December 27 2009 18:53 johanes wrote: Seeing the results this month, i believe Flash deserves nr. 1 AND nr. 2 spots. Everyone else is so behind... Look at JD's stats, look at his play. It's #1 worthy, but Flash is just even better. But saying JD is so behind Flash is just fanboyism. | ||
|
johanes
Czech Republic2231 Posts
On December 27 2009 19:00 SuperArc wrote: Look at JD's stats, look at his play. It's #1 worthy, but Flash is just even better. But saying JD is so behind Flash is just fanboyism. well he certainly didnt look even when they met + Show Spoiler + JK, although truth | ||
|
darktreb
United States3017 Posts
On December 27 2009 09:25 SuperArc wrote: Including PL, Movie played better than Shine..., especially since he had to play PvZ (imba matchup  )I don't know man, I love Movie (my favorite P by far) but Shine's run has been insane. He has only lost to elite players this month, and his OSL run is one of the sickest ever for someone coming out of nowhere. Something about beating Bisu in RO36 seems to bring out the best in an out of nowhere Zerg (hi by.hero). Also Shine had no embarrassing losses like Movie's game against Jaedong where he looked like he'd been up drinking all night celebrating his OSL win ... probably because he actually had been up drinking all night celebrating. I just don't think Shine gets enough credit because of all the hate he's attracted. I love Movie and consider him the favorite against Shine (I will be rooting for Movie hard) but all things considered I think Shine is 4a and Movie is 4b. | ||
|
johanes
Czech Republic2231 Posts
On December 27 2009 21:06 darktreb wrote: I don't know man, I love Movie (my favorite P by far) but Shine's run has been insane. He has only lost to elite players this month, and his OSL run is one of the sickest ever for someone coming out of nowhere. Something about beating Bisu in RO36 seems to bring out the best in an out of nowhere Zerg (hi by.hero). Also Shine had no embarrassing losses like Movie's game against Jaedong where he looked like he'd been up drinking all night celebrating his OSL win ... probably because he actually had been up drinking all night celebrating. I just don't think Shine gets enough credit because of all the hate he's attracted. I love Movie and consider him the favorite against Shine (I will be rooting for Movie hard) but all things considered I think Shine is 4a and Movie is 4b. I actually believe that big part of shine hate is caused by his looks; he is not likeable like bisu, cute like zero or fun like fbh. Combine with destroying peoples favourites, he is suddenly hated far to much. With time and with (possibly) continued good results hi reputation will probably begin to shine. | ||
|
Salteador Neo
Andorra5591 Posts
On December 27 2009 15:17 ndralcasid wrote: + Show Spoiler + Bisu losing to FROZEAN should seal the deal for people thinking about putting him on the list this month I don't agree. Watch what happened with Calm last month. | ||
|
Avidkeystamper
United States8556 Posts
| ||
|
SuperArc
Austria7781 Posts
| ||
|
FireGuyX
United States1712 Posts
On December 27 2009 21:06 darktreb wrote: I don't know man, I love Movie (my favorite P by far) but Shine's run has been insane. He has only lost to elite players this month, and his OSL run is one of the sickest ever for someone coming out of nowhere. Something about beating Bisu in RO36 seems to bring out the best in an out of nowhere Zerg (hi by.hero). Also Shine had no embarrassing losses like Movie's game against Jaedong where he looked like he'd been up drinking all night celebrating his OSL win ... probably because he actually had been up drinking all night celebrating. I just don't think Shine gets enough credit because of all the hate he's attracted. I love Movie and consider him the favorite against Shine (I will be rooting for Movie hard) but all things considered I think Shine is 4a and Movie is 4b. Shine has been playing more consistent, but I think Movie has more upside. You can say that Shine is 4a and Movie is 4b, but if you look at their records it's pretty similar. As for who wins in the OSL Ro4. I think its 50/50 mainly because El Nino and HBR favors Zerg. If the maps were more balanced, I would favor Movie. But Movie, he wins against Zergs in Zerg favored maps, especially on HBR. | ||
|
tedster
984 Posts
| ||
|
TwoToneTerran
United States8841 Posts
| ||
|
FireGuyX
United States1712 Posts
On December 26 2009 21:05 FireGuyX wrote: 1.Flash 2.Jaedong 3.Calm 4.Shine 5.Stork 6.Movie 7.Best 8.Kal 9.Light 10.Sea I stand by Sea at being #10. | ||
|
Hinanawi
United States2250 Posts
#3 Bisu Anti-fans are going to rage hard about this entry, but the truth is Bisu is clearly #3 on the scene at the moment. While certainly below Jaedong's standard in most matchups right now, he is still playing great Starcraft. Despite a loss to Luxury early on, Bisu delivered the results needed for SKT T1, and though now out of the OSL, is still by far one of the strongest contenders for a MSL title this season. Simply put, Bisu just didn't play enough this month to justify putting him lower. His games haven't been spectacular, sure, but remember, that's all relative. This guy is still one of progaming's most consistent performers, and it shows. Bisu was given his 'benefit of the doubt' month this month. He should be lucky to get a low #9/10 spot in Jan. Do you really want someone who got manner-CC'd by CuteAngel high on the PR? | ||
|
SkytoM
Austria1137 Posts
On December 29 2009 21:14 Hinanawi wrote: Bisu was given his 'benefit of the doubt' month this month. He should be lucky to get a low #9/10 spot in Jan. Do you really want someone who got manner-CC'd by CuteAngel high on the PR? yes. i mean, 2-0 vs Fox Zergs. Show me another P who can do this. //e: give him CBNC.. | ||
|
kickinhead
Switzerland2069 Posts
Also, Fantasy should be placed higher and Stork too, if you look at this month... Sea shouldn't even be in the Top-10, because in every other League than the Proleague, he is insignificant. There are tons of Players that deserve to be in this List more than Sea, like Light, Kal, JangBi, the aforementoined Leta etc. And yes; Bisu is clearly overrated atm. He lost games he should've never lost this month. | ||
|
johanes
Czech Republic2231 Posts
On December 30 2009 00:31 kickinhead wrote: I kinda miss Leta in this List.... There cannot be a Top-10 right now without him IMO. Also, Fantasy should be placed higher and Stork too, if you look at this month... Sea shouldn't even be in the Top-10, because in every other League than the Proleague, he is insignificant. There are tons of Players that deserve to be in this List more than Sea, like Light, Kal, JangBi, the aforementoined Leta etc. And yes; Bisu is clearly overrated atm. He lost games he should've never lost this month. Fantasy higher? i dont think so, fantasy has been just bad lately | ||
|
SuperArc
Austria7781 Posts
 Stork's and Movie's failure today there should be no discussion who the top3 are gonna be. Flash JaedongCalmStork/Movie/Kal/Shine all deserve #4 imo. The rest can be given to Effort, Hwasin, Kwanro... | ||
|
o[twist]
United States4903 Posts
On December 30 2009 02:27 SuperArc wrote: With Stork's and Movie's failure today there should be no discussion who the top3 are gonna be.FlashJaedongCalmStork/Movie/Kal/Shine all deserve #4 imo. The rest can be given to Effort, Hwasin, Kwanro... didn't calm just fail yesterday lol and i'm a huge leta fan but it's absurd to put him above sea, come on | ||
|
SkytoM
Austria1137 Posts
On December 30 2009 02:27 SuperArc wrote: With Stork's and Movie's failure today there should be no discussion who the top3 are gonna be.FlashJaedongCalmStork/Movie/Kal/Shine all deserve #4 imo. The rest can be given to Effort, Hwasin, Kwanro... calm = fail ? | ||
|
muramasa
Canada1299 Posts
I think the fact that Calm has won all his games in the OSL is significantly more important than a loss in PL. Even Flash lost to HyuN this month in PL and no one is disputing that he's the #1 player by miles.I'd say Calm's just slightly ahead of Kal because he's played better quality opponents the Last month while having basically the same win:loss ratio. | ||
| ||
