|
On May 31 2009 10:30 Shikyo wrote:
rolechecked a Mafia and also was against lynching almost all the people that actually were lynched. Although the town failed to listen to him, it doesn't make his play bad. Was against lynching me... here's a quote from a post he posted 3 days ago:
"From all the intel I have gathered, mostly working with teks here, it is reasonable to assume that these 5 people are mafia: ydg, wurm, pawsom, l10f, phelix."
So yeah, MVP in my eyes.
EDIT: Not to mention his fake accusing me and acting stupid at the beginning to drive attention away from him, letting him do his DT work in peace. I really don't get what more you can ask for a DT, finding 5 out of 7 mafia is pretty good.
@ the bolded:
You mean he figured out who was the mafia after ALL the townie deaths and reasonably there couldn't be that many other suspects?
you guys are so smart.
Finding 5 out of 7 mafia but getting only 1 lynched is good for what again?
:/
|
Shikyo wrote:
EDIT: Not to mention his fake accusing me and acting stupid at the beginning to drive attention away from him,
The problem I have with this is that afterward he's already shot his credibility with the town by acting like an idiot for 2 days (except for the handful of people he'd been PM'ing I guess?). Yes, it's good he gets under the radar from the mafia, yes he proved to be right, but had teks not told me Foolishness was a confirmed DT I never would have listened to him.
After he posted "it's not my role we should be focusing on" (or whatever he said) ... honestly he did a really good job of making me think my initial assessment of him as town-aligned was wrong.
I was looking for a town consensus on who to vote for on day 4 and I didn't get a straight answer till after I'd gone to bed either.
|
On May 31 2009 10:35 Ace wrote:Show nested quote +On May 31 2009 10:30 Shikyo wrote:
rolechecked a Mafia and also was against lynching almost all the people that actually were lynched. Although the town failed to listen to him, it doesn't make his play bad. Was against lynching me... here's a quote from a post he posted 3 days ago:
"From all the intel I have gathered, mostly working with teks here, it is reasonable to assume that these 5 people are mafia: ydg, wurm, pawsom, l10f, phelix."
So yeah, MVP in my eyes.
EDIT: Not to mention his fake accusing me and acting stupid at the beginning to drive attention away from him, letting him do his DT work in peace. I really don't get what more you can ask for a DT, finding 5 out of 7 mafia is pretty good. @ the bolded: You mean he figured out who was the mafia after ALL the townie deaths and reasonably there couldn't be that many other suspects? you guys are so smart. Finding 5 out of 7 mafia but getting only 1 lynched is good for what again? :/
Can blame the town for that. However, had those all been lynched, town would have likely won. It's not his fault if the town doesn't listen ^^
|
It's not his fault if the town doesn't listen ^^
Oh really?
It's not entirely his fault, sure, but really he wasn't going about his work in a way to make him very believable imo.
edit: nvm I just realized why this post is pretty pointless and I'll address it in my next one
|
On May 31 2009 10:40 Shikyo wrote:Show nested quote +On May 31 2009 10:35 Ace wrote:On May 31 2009 10:30 Shikyo wrote:
rolechecked a Mafia and also was against lynching almost all the people that actually were lynched. Although the town failed to listen to him, it doesn't make his play bad. Was against lynching me... here's a quote from a post he posted 3 days ago:
"From all the intel I have gathered, mostly working with teks here, it is reasonable to assume that these 5 people are mafia: ydg, wurm, pawsom, l10f, phelix."
So yeah, MVP in my eyes.
EDIT: Not to mention his fake accusing me and acting stupid at the beginning to drive attention away from him, letting him do his DT work in peace. I really don't get what more you can ask for a DT, finding 5 out of 7 mafia is pretty good. @ the bolded: You mean he figured out who was the mafia after ALL the townie deaths and reasonably there couldn't be that many other suspects? you guys are so smart. Finding 5 out of 7 mafia but getting only 1 lynched is good for what again? :/ Can blame the town for that. However, had those all been lynched, town would have likely won. It's not his fault if the town doesn't listen ^^
Yeah, town would have likely won when his PM about the 5 mafia was on Day 4 of the game? Over halfway through Day 4 on top of that? Maybe if you said Day 1 or 2, you might have an argument. But finding 5 mafia when the game is effectively over, is worthless.
|
On May 31 2009 10:43 Elemenope wrote:Show nested quote +On May 31 2009 10:40 Shikyo wrote:On May 31 2009 10:35 Ace wrote:On May 31 2009 10:30 Shikyo wrote:
rolechecked a Mafia and also was against lynching almost all the people that actually were lynched. Although the town failed to listen to him, it doesn't make his play bad. Was against lynching me... here's a quote from a post he posted 3 days ago:
"From all the intel I have gathered, mostly working with teks here, it is reasonable to assume that these 5 people are mafia: ydg, wurm, pawsom, l10f, phelix."
So yeah, MVP in my eyes.
EDIT: Not to mention his fake accusing me and acting stupid at the beginning to drive attention away from him, letting him do his DT work in peace. I really don't get what more you can ask for a DT, finding 5 out of 7 mafia is pretty good. @ the bolded: You mean he figured out who was the mafia after ALL the townie deaths and reasonably there couldn't be that many other suspects? you guys are so smart. Finding 5 out of 7 mafia but getting only 1 lynched is good for what again? :/ Can blame the town for that. However, had those all been lynched, town would have likely won. It's not his fault if the town doesn't listen ^^ Yeah, town would have likely won when his PM about the 5 mafia was on Day 4 of the game? Over halfway through Day 4 on top of that? Maybe if you said Day 1 or 2, you might have an argument. But finding 5 mafia when the game is effectively over, is worthless.
double lynch = 5 mafia left with 2 mafia KP. There'd have been enough townies left to get those 3 mafia in a row, we had both DTs and all medics left, too. The game wasn't as over as you say, really...
|
The problem I have with Foolishness at the end of the game is he just waited too long to tell us straight out who to vote for.
He's confirmed DT. We know all the blues, so when he roleclaims DT publicly the town trusts that. They have to when no one speaks up against him.
Then he dicks around until an hour before voting closes without just saying "these people are mafia and here's why:"
Too late. Yes he was right. I was ready to listen to him. He didn't tell me what to do till I was asleep though, he also didn't tell you Shikyo who to vote for till you were asleep..
|
lol. Game's over, you can end the drama if you want...
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
Well, I'm sorry for not telling you all what to do, and when I did it was too late.
|
lol.. GG
I had fun. When's the next mafia game?
|
On May 31 2009 12:53 wurm wrote:
lol.. GG
I had fun. When's the next mafia game?
check out caller's thread. I think semioldguy has one too now.
|
Heh, good game. I had fun while it lasted. Thanks for hosting, pyrr.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
