|
am i the only one whos actually posted anything even remotely close to a plan?
i have this feeling that everybody that's running is mafiaso except me... hahaha
and MTF, it seems the only reason you want to be mayor/pardoner is b/c you think you'll die if you're not in that position. What about me? What about any number of contributive townies? It's awfully selfish of you to be putting your survival ahead of everybody else's, especially when you don't have a plan or any thing but your great clue analysis.
Plexa posted a very simple statement which seems very un-Plexa like, so I'm suspicious of him.
Clazziquai's withdrawal confsued me.
I dunno what Ver is doing.
And nemy's reaction mayoral candidacy is very similar to that of last game where he was mafia.
Spiralarchitect's reason for not voting for me is b/c of a silly propaganda poster.
i dunno this just seems funny.
|
me me me, i want to join ;(
|
On November 17 2008 23:35 iNfuNdiBuLuM wrote:Having worked with clazz in the past, i do not doubt his sincerity.... i'm just not sure if he is the right person for the job (nothing personal)! I also have a much better feel for the way mtf, plexa, and caller (somewhat) tend to post. Having either of those 3 in the mayor/pardoner spot isn't necessarily a bad thing. There was a post several pages back, I think by Ver or Versatile (names too similar lol), where he argued that we should elect a mayor that we know is intelligent. this way, we can be more sure of his choices, and then if he is making choices that are bad for the town it is less likely he is makign those choices by accident or through careless thought. that said, i think i ## vote for caller. the whole thing i think brings up an interesting meta-game dilemma. having played with each other for several times now, we know who most of the high profile, dangerous players are. this means that these people are more likely to be checked, gather votes for mayor, given cement shoes, etc. i'm not sure exactly ofthe consequences of this, but it's rather interesting to think about anyway 
That was me and I'm a girl
Edit: Feel free to call me Verse (anyone) if that helps.
|
oh, and for my vote.....
Plexa doesn't seem to want to be Mayor, and MTF hasn't formulated a plan.
Caller, what changes would you make to the BG Plan? Same to you Ver? I kn ow you said earlier you only had some ideas, any progress yet?
|
On November 18 2008 02:20 Caller wrote:
am i the only one whos actually posted anything even remotely close to a plan?
i have this feeling that everybody that's running is mafiaso except me... hahaha
and MTF, it seems the only reason you want to be mayor/pardoner is b/c you think you'll die if you're not in that position. What about me? What about any number of contributive townies? It's awfully selfish of you to be putting your survival ahead of everybody else's, especially when you don't have a plan or any thing but your great clue analysis.
Plexa posted a very simple statement which seems very un-Plexa like, so I'm suspicious of him.
Clazziquai's withdrawal confsued me.
I dunno what Ver is doing.
And nemy's reaction mayoral candidacy is very similar to that of last game where he was mafia.
Spiralarchitect's reason for not voting for me is b/c of a silly propaganda poster.
i dunno this just seems funny.
You really think that my reaction for mayoral candidacy is similar to that of last game? Look at the first thing I posted once I got my role a few pages back. Do you think a mafia member would have outed the traitor role? Really?
|
I am very suspicious of anyone who wants to be the pardoner, not the mayor. Remember, AoC works just as well if they are the pardoner. Therefore, I urge the people who are voting for Plexa to reconsider because of the way he announced his candidacy.
Also, once the mayor and pardoner are elected, PLEASE role check the pardoner as well as the mayor (the town had the saboteur as the pardoner most of Mafia 2 because they didn't do this). The pardoner should be just as important as the mayor for providing direction to the town.
That being said, ## I vote for Caller because I think he seems the least suspicious and looks to be the most prepared mayor candidate
|
On November 18 2008 02:20 Caller wrote:
am i the only one whos actually posted anything even remotely close to a plan?
i have this feeling that everybody that's running is mafiaso except me... hahaha
and MTF, it seems the only reason you want to be mayor/pardoner is b/c you think you'll die if you're not in that position. What about me? What about any number of contributive townies? It's awfully selfish of you to be putting your survival ahead of everybody else's, especially when you don't have a plan or any thing but your great clue analysis.
Plexa posted a very simple statement which seems very un-Plexa like, so I'm suspicious of him.
I didn't see a problem with running just on Ace's bodyguard plan, as it worked brilliantly in the second game to set up a structure for town. I honestly don't see a better and more stable way to approach the beginning of the game than it. Bodyguards are all PMed, they all PM eachother to validate, DT checks Mayor and speaks up if he's red and stays quiet if he's green. This doesn't address the issue of the Godfather role, however, which is the only flaw I see in the plan, but I honestly can't think of any way but time to figure that one out. After the bodyguards are all confirmed and no DT speaks up then we PM roles to the mayor who keeps an eye out for inconsistencies, after which the roles would be subject to confirmation through time and observed actions.
If there's a better plan, I've yet to hear it. Ver is working on his at the moment, assumedly, and I'm waiting to see what that looks like, but the bodyguard plan is very solid. Your own revisions to the plan are actually exactly what the plan was from Ace the second game, with the exception of the blue roled mayor. I'd advocate it's use whether or not I get in.
Also, I didn't run just so I could have bodyguards. I am both organized and active, and with me living longer (however conceited it makes me look) I can do a lot for the town with clue analysis, vote list compilation, post analysis, and just general reasoning. I just want to try to get something done for the town before I'm wiped off the map, which I know applies to you and multiple other people as well.
|
On November 18 2008 02:41 nemY wrote:Show nested quote +On November 18 2008 02:20 Caller wrote:
am i the only one whos actually posted anything even remotely close to a plan?
i have this feeling that everybody that's running is mafiaso except me... hahaha
and MTF, it seems the only reason you want to be mayor/pardoner is b/c you think you'll die if you're not in that position. What about me? What about any number of contributive townies? It's awfully selfish of you to be putting your survival ahead of everybody else's, especially when you don't have a plan or any thing but your great clue analysis.
Plexa posted a very simple statement which seems very un-Plexa like, so I'm suspicious of him.
Clazziquai's withdrawal confsued me.
I dunno what Ver is doing.
And nemy's reaction mayoral candidacy is very similar to that of last game where he was mafia.
Spiralarchitect's reason for not voting for me is b/c of a silly propaganda poster.
i dunno this just seems funny. You really think that my reaction for mayoral candidacy is similar to that of last game? Look at the first thing I posted once I got my role a few pages back. Do you think a mafia member would have outed the traitor role? Really?
I don't think outing the traitor role really does anything for you either way. We know that ShadowDrgn sent that PM to at least several people that aren't mafia (I got it and I think I saw someone else also say they got that PM a few pages back). I think that a mafia member may try to use that PM to gain the trust of the town
|
On November 18 2008 00:09 clazziquai wrote:Show nested quote +On November 18 2008 00:02 clazziquai wrote:
REMOVE ME FROM THE MAYORAL ELECTIONS
thank you I want to tell all my voters: thanks for supporting me but I think that I am not the best candidate in the spot for mayor. Although I could probably do a decent job (hopefully  ) there are many more people suitable for mayor. I think that Caller is the best for the spot, following Plexa/MTF (Clue analyzers) with Pardoner. These people are the MOST qualified. At first I thought Caller running for mayor was a complete joke (due to his pics and whatnot) but what Showtime and Ver said has strongly convinced my opinion. I vote Caller for MayorALL MY VOTERS SHOULD CHANGE YOUR VOTES TO CALLER! I AM NO LONGER IN THE ELECTION.
Real talk, this looks VERY suspecious..... What logic are you using?
|
United States3824 Posts
|
Wow, there's a lot of words which I probably skimmed through in about ~20 or so minutes. But if I read things through correctly nemY, Caller, MTF, and Plexa are the ones running for Mayor and the most likely people to get voted?
nemY would vote for you b/c I love you, but I think Ace might have put you in Mafia to try to kill me really quickly to get revenge for the things I did to you last last game.
Caller I didn't like your pictures so I say nay to you.
MTF theres a lot of very, very, very long paragraphs which I didn't really read the last game, but you seem to be a good candidate for it seeing that people liked you.
Plexa you too wrote out very, very long paragraphs which I didn't really read, but seemed to be very helpful.
Would vote for Plexa, but you killed my lover nemY last game by mass PM'ing everyone to kill him while I retracted my vote after we made sweet love and I was sure he wasn't Mafia. That being said...
## I Vote MTF for Mayor.
Plus I like the mushy blogs he wrote out about him and his girlfriend.
|
Having read/skimmed over 20 pages, ## I vote Plexa for Mayor
I think Plexa has the intelligence and leadership ability to run the town
|
On November 18 2008 01:05 KlassyK wrote:
Having read/skimmed over ~17 pages, ## I vote Plexa for Mayor
I've read games that have been played on here, and I think Plexa has the intelligence and leadership ability to run the town well.
On November 18 2008 03:54 mischief6000 wrote:
Having read/skimmed over 20 pages, ## I vote Plexa for Mayor
I think Plexa has the intelligence and leadership ability to run the town
Uh...Does anyone else think that this proves me right in suspecting Showtime! and Plexa as Mafia?
Hint: If you don't see it, it's like they copy-pasted a PM from Plexa to say this.
|
with this many ppl the game will be so hard to keep up lwel. anyways i vote for plexa for mayor
|
## I abstain from voting
I would vote for someone who comes up with a decent game plan.
Otherwise I'm voting for Caller because he actually took the time to post those phony ads.
Or maybe Empyrean because I like him.
|
On November 18 2008 02:27 Versatile wrote:That was me and I'm a girl Edit: Feel free to call me Verse (anyone) if that helps.
how YOU doin?
i'm pretty much the king shit around here, so... i mean if you need any help navigating the site or being cool or anythin, i'm ya man
|
|
|
17052 Posts
On November 18 2008 04:05 KH1031 wrote:
## I abstain from voting
I would vote for someone who comes up with a decent game plan.
Otherwise I'm voting for Caller because he actually took the time to post those phony ads.
Or maybe Empyrean because I like him.
Awww
Anyway, I think the PM about being the traitor was probably done by someone not associated with town (probably either the real traitor or a mafia member), knowing that whenever some random townie broadcasts that he got a PM from the traitor, he'll immediately be singled out for suspicion.
|
On November 18 2008 04:00 MTF wrote:Show nested quote +On November 18 2008 01:05 KlassyK wrote:
Having read/skimmed over ~17 pages, ## I vote Plexa for Mayor
I've read games that have been played on here, and I think Plexa has the intelligence and leadership ability to run the town well. Show nested quote +On November 18 2008 03:54 mischief6000 wrote:
Having read/skimmed over 20 pages, ## I vote Plexa for Mayor
I think Plexa has the intelligence and leadership ability to run the town Uh...Does anyone else think that this proves me right in suspecting Showtime! and Plexa as Mafia? Hint: If you don't see it, it's like they copy-pasted a PM from Plexa to say this.
Uhhhhhh, did anyone else see this??? To me, those quotes look way too close to be a coincidence.
|
Agreed @ MTF and Kweezy.
Note to everyone: Kweezy, mischief6000, KlassyK, Double D and I allllll know Ace from another board. We have all played together MANY MANY times, and are all very familiar with each other's playing styles.
Those two posts looking so much like each other is very suspcious to say the least.
With that said, I thinkCaller or Ver or MTF is the best way to go.
For now, ##I vote Caller.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
