Newbie Student Mafia XXVI - Page 118

On June 09 2017 23:30 Tumblewood wrote:
hold on one hot second actually. i know for a fact that no one but me has gotten the pm saying "you were roleblocked". so either we don't have or haven't been using our rb this whole game if i'm mafia.

On June 06 2017 07:53 Tubesock wrote:
Just in case:

PB - too sloppy from his last mafia game.
Conversion - he's trying for help and actually giving his thoughts. Too transparent for mafia.
HF* He's just too dangerous as mafia to not distrust at least a little bit. In any case I'm not going to lynch him till like D4/5.
Ritoky- I felt mindmelded + Show Spoiler +
Tumblewood - Uncc'd Doc but I don't think I'd out myself if I were the real doc just yet.
Onegu - started the successful shenany. It's certainly possible that he bussed for zero reason, but if he actually performs in the future, he's town.

LS- I used to think I could read LS. While his reasoning is "weird" his reads are / used to be actually good if you disregarded what he said and zero'd on just the names.

Mafias Most likely further down.

Grackaroni - mostly ignored because I still think BH is mafia. Take away BH though, and I don't see anything towny. I think his fight with Ritoky is pure OMGUS.

Blazinghand - at first I thought his jokes after the lynch made him town. His hyperawareness on how vote switching works (him telling Ritoky that if Ritoky jumped on the wagon after it was secured, it would have looked suspicious) tells me he is quite aware of his image. So, he's making sure everyone knows he's joking and trying to get us to like him. If he doesn't do anything next days we should kill him.

beentheredonethat- I think "emotional" outbursts is a terrible reason to town someone.
Vivax - I liked him until his weird shifts prior to the end of the day. His interaction with HF looked terrible.

On June 06 2017 08:32 Tubesock wrote:


You make jokes too!

On June 06 2017 16:08 Tubesock wrote:
basically, we lynch HF unless Vivax rescinds then lynch Vivax. HF flips mafia we celebrate or lynch Vivax after. If we decide to lynch Vivax first, and he is cop then we just gave mafia a free nightkill.

So, basically now we can just talk about who is the last mafia.

On June 10 2017 04:23 LightningStrike wrote:

From my PoV it's one of Covnersion, PB, and Tubesock by PoE alone. PB seems likely town by meta. So that leaves Conversion and Tubesock as my last scum there. Tubesock did vote 2nd on James but if TW was the roleblocker he probably would do that bus honestly. Conversion I liked some of his posts after I read his filter a bit but his weird reaction to the flip seems odd defending himself about being a team with PB. So ya One of Tubesock and Conversion is my last scum you?

On June 07 2017 04:00 Tubesock wrote:
Mechanically this is an easy day. Lynch the red check.

But they're right on Vivax having a reputation for not doing anything as scum and this is a great way to both not do anything and destroy the town by killing its leader. Hmm

On June 10 2017 06:50 Tubesock wrote:


I would bus both TW and Fidei on D1? No one was paying attention to Onegu until I jumped on Fidei. The PB wagon was already trying to gain momentum I think, why wouldn't I have jumped on that if PB is town?

On June 10 2017 06:34 Tubesock wrote:


To be fair, you could be lying and they RB'd the dead as they shot them.

On June 10 2017 06:50 Tubesock wrote:


I would bus both TW and Fidei on D1? No one was paying attention to Onegu until I jumped on Fidei. The PB wagon was already trying to gain momentum I think, why wouldn't I have jumped on that if PB is town?

On June 10 2017 06:52 Tumblewood wrote:

i realize now that this evidence has some holes in it

On June 08 2017 21:32 Tubesock wrote:


I'm starting to think more about BH. I realized I don't trust him. He's said pretty towny things and makes me laugh. He's really buddying up to you and I think that's shady. Reminds me too much of Darth P(something) and Geript. He gives the token "oh I distrust HF totally" blah blah but would follow any of your plays. I don't for a second think he's "keeping his eye on you".

Grackish. Sometimes I like what he says but most the time I don't like what he's doing. I've read his filter several times. I feel like I'm reading Batsnacks. His shit fight with Ritoky made me realize I need to reread them both. Grack reminds me of me sometimes. Some vet would scum me and I'd lose my shit because of some weird detail that no one gets and I shit the thread up. Grack says Ritoky is hypocritical for scumming him for not talking about Fidei. But to me it's pretty clear Ritoky is saying that Grack should have talked about him because he towned him enough to scum you for thinking F is scum. So I'm trying to reread and figure that out.

I just reread PB. Did you realize that about 90% of his posts are apology or excuses? Just count the ones that he's "I'm super busy" or some such thing. He's no dumby, if he has the terrible luck of rolling mafia twice in two games he knows he can't post like last time. His perfection was called out.

On June 10 2017 06:51 Prison Break wrote:


You had TW as 3rd scumread and only "bussed" him until his blue claim

And I'm not sure if you made comments on fidei or just voted him?

On June 10 2017 06:54 Holyflare wrote:


Let's be real, you were in no position to divert my wagon of justice off TW. Furthermore, if TW is rb like I said then moving to the gf makes perfect sense because it gives tw an excuse.

And like you said, if everyone is ignoring fidei then what's the harm jumping on his wagon?

Purely speculation at this point but I really hate your return to thread after liking you all game and I'm disappointed.

On June 10 2017 06:54 Holyflare wrote:


If you are doc then you should be calling out ritoky hardcore.