might as well elaborate on palmar a little, pros and cons:

flicking through his filter just now, there are quite a few posts that look decently like flippant town palmar

but he criticised the lynch while doing absolutely nothing about it. it's an awfully long time ago now but it reminds me very much of rockband where he shat all over the prplhz lynch d1 while doing absolutely nothing about it.

he voted for hf instead (on nothing) having previously kinda townread him, and then subsequently townread him (????). like he says hf looks fine, votes him for a total non-reason at deadline while doing nothing to dissuade the bats wagon, and then calls him town after. it's all just nonsense and palmar doesn't generally do nonsense of that variety as town.

plus there were one or two other things i picked out on day 1 that i don't remember now

but hey if he's town he can so easily turn things around, because i'll always listen to him (which he knows)

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

October 06 2016 21:32 GMT

#1750

anyway i spent too long here, catch y'all tomorrow

Calix

3379 Posts

October 06 2016 21:33 GMT

#1751

If Palmar is town then that would make pretty much all of the leading EOD wagons town, right?

Calix

3379 Posts

October 06 2016 21:35 GMT

#1752

Question. May we have links to Night 1/ Day 2 in the OP?

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 06 2016 21:36 GMT

#1753

On October 07 2016 06:28 Calix wrote:
NU, did you ever explain why you voted for someone you didn't scum-read yesterday?

Maybe. Can't recall.

My vote on HF was useless as I was the only one to vote him at the time. I was considering voting either Bats or Plamar (I sr neither).

Batsnacks' defense was utter shit, and I thought he scumclaimed when he voted HF and said something like, "Might as well have fun while I can." I would expect this to be something scum would say when they're on the verge of being lynched (like me in superstitious), not a town. Town should give out the final reads they have which he did not do.

That was what made me vote him. Obv. with hindisght bias I now think voting Plamar was the better option there as he is playing exactly like in hm3.

On October 07 2016 06:20 Calix wrote:
But yeah, my play this game is reminding me of other games I've had where I was totally wrong and was basically honorary mafia by pushing mislynches all game long so I'm just going to take a step back now BEFORE I reach that point.

##vote Palmar

Don't say I did not try to prevent that.

Also, when you type my initials, how do you read my name? ie "[NeverUnlucky], did you..." or "[En-you], did you..."

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 06 2016 21:38 GMT

#1754

You have this annoying habit of not listening to others who say that the lynch you are leading is a ML. Please try listening to your trs in the future.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 06 2016 21:39 GMT

#1755

Your explanation sucks.

You said you didn't scum-read him. Now you're claiming that you did scum-read him for that post.

You also said he was scummy because he didn't say "I'm town" in his defense - that is literally what you posted in the thread.

Someone saying "might as well have fun" has never been scum-indicative. What are you smoking?

I don't give a shit if you tried to prevent that, my dude.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 06 2016 21:40 GMT

#1756

To add to marv's points on Plam - Plamar said that I should have been modkilled day 1 for trying to abuse the game mechanics. This would only favor mafia.

That's his one post that made me think he is mafia.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 06 2016 21:41 GMT

#1757

It also makes no sense for you to lecture me for not listening to you when you voted for him for doing something scummy, lmao.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 06 2016 21:42 GMT

#1758

On October 07 2016 06:39 Calix wrote:
Your explanation sucks.

You said you didn't scum-read him. Now you're claiming that you did scum-read him for that post.

You also said he was scummy because he didn't say "I'm town" in his defense - that is literally what you posted in the thread.

Someone saying "might as well have fun" has never been scum-indicative. What are you smoking?

I don't give a shit if you tried to prevent that, my dude.

I did not scum-read him. I said that as I voted. Go check. (Grack asked me if I scum-read Bats and I said no.)

Yes, I said that. Your point?

I explained my thought process. I still think it's scum AI.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 06 2016 21:44 GMT

#1759

On October 07 2016 06:41 Calix wrote:
It also makes no sense for you to lecture me for not listening to you when you voted for him for doing something scummy, lmao.

Listening to your TRs is what I said. I was not the only one to tell you bats was unlikely to flip mafia.

It makes perfect sense.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 06 2016 21:45 GMT

#1760

That's my point.

You said at the time that you didn't scum-read him.

When I asked now why you voted for someone you didn't scum-read, your answer was that you thought, among other things, that he had scum-claimed and that he was acting like mafia.

Plz explain.