I actually do stuff outside of whining though.

Also I think he was mafia in the Rogue Hype game with HF/ Scott, but the OP isn't updated so not 100% sure there.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 10 2016 23:31 GMT

#2962

Ok, I will read Palmar's filter in that game.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 10 2016 23:34 GMT

#2963

I just did. I was pleasantly surprised to see him actually play the game like a normal person.

He does some similar shit to this game (e.g., calling his town-reads bad)...but I see no excessive whining posts and that's the only thing that does it for me at the moment.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 10 2016 23:43 GMT

#2964

So if I just assume that Palmar is town then the three scum basically have to be among Damdred/ Scott/ JAT/ Oats by POE.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 10 2016 23:44 GMT

#2965

On October 11 2016 08:34 Calix wrote:
I just did. I was pleasantly surprised to see him actually play the game like a normal person.

He does some similar shit to this game (e.g., calling his town-reads bad)...but I see no excessive whining posts and that's the only thing that does it for me at the moment.

Mmk. Marv + Scott/jat + Damdred?

I don't see really see scott fitting in there, and jat I don't feel strongly about.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 10 2016 23:44 GMT

#2966

The mind melds are real this game.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 10 2016 23:46 GMT

#2967

So let's lynch Damdred. This makes way more sense since that clears up more.

I really don't think Marv is scum and I'm not in the business of lynching him based on his inactivity.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 10 2016 23:50 GMT

#2968

This is Completely Generic Mafia.

Palmar claims he rolled scum in his 7th post. He is way more hesitant than his "Calix is 100% mafia" self in this game. He also asks questions which I have not seen him do in this game.

Also, his 2 first pages of filter are only him calling others town. ie he's town-hunting vs. now his first posts were geared towards looking for scum.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 10 2016 23:50 GMT

#2969

On October 11 2016 08:46 Calix wrote:
So let's lynch Damdred. This makes way more sense since that clears up more.

I really don't think Marv is scum and I'm not in the business of lynching him based on his inactivity.

How is lynching Damdred different in that case?

Calix

3379 Posts

October 10 2016 23:52 GMT

#2970

On October 11 2016 08:50 NeverUnlucky wrote:

Show nested quote +

How is lynching Damdred different in that case?

I'm 100 times more confident that he will flip mafia than Marv, duh.

If both of them are somehow mafia then sure, it doesn't make a difference but I'm not sold there and I'd rather take the safe option now rather than later, you know?

Also means more popcorn if Palmar gets annoyed at me for not listening to him yet again

Calix

3379 Posts

October 10 2016 23:59 GMT

#2971

It's annoying when I have to differentiate between lurkers and even defend some of them.

But hey, not the first time I've defended the shitty. Wasn't I the only person defending Palmar on Day 1 as well? Just remembered that.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

October 11 2016 00:07 GMT

#2972

I would take palmar more seriously if he would actually carry this through a few hours and eventually produce something other than "lynch marv cause I say so".

Calix, why are you hesitant about lynching scott?

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

October 11 2016 00:07 GMT

#2973

I don't want to Lynch him today, but neither do I want to Lynch marv. Therein lies the problem Palmar.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 11 2016 00:09 GMT

#2974

Oh, I get it, Oats.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 11 2016 00:11 GMT

#2975

I'm not hesitant about lynching Scott. I've just been focused on other players.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 11 2016 00:20 GMT

#2976

I'm wondering if Scott/ Damdred/ JAT makes sense.

I'm only skimming JAT's filter at the moment since it's really late over here so if someone else wants to do it with me then knock yourself out.

You can check up on Marv and Oats too while you're at it.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

October 11 2016 00:27 GMT

#2977

I've kinda gone off the scum-team association stuff because we haven't even got one scum flip and honestly it's not necessary to convince ppl.

Calix

3379 Posts

October 11 2016 00:29 GMT

#2978

I'm doing it to see if my POE reads make sense.

Going to have to leave it for now. I am falling asleep at the keys here and I have important stuff to do tomorrow.

NeverUnlucky

Canada1622 Posts

October 11 2016 00:53 GMT

#2979

On October 10 2016 09:53 Oatsmaster wrote:
I really don't feel like I'm lynching Scott causr he hasn't played, I'm lynching Scott because he's been scummy as absolutely shit with his votes and posts.

What posts were scummy?

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

October 11 2016 03:55 GMT

#2980

On October 07 2016 12:23 scott31337 wrote:
Koshi - Carefree Koshi, leaning town for now.
Calix - He hates it when I put him in the tinfoil town pile, so I'll do it again.

marvellosity - town, pretty confident of - if he got mafia again he'd be all mopey and shit
Palmar - Null/Leaning Scum - Trying to coast, doesn't give much for info. (Lynch Calix)
justanothertownie - leaning scum, he's doing the not getting info/shitposting JAT - which is a mafia trait for him.
Damdred-slight townlean/almost null - very little to go on.
NeverUnlucky - town, probably #2 - lots of info, somewhat helpful.
Oatsmaster - townlean - points out some inconstistencies in posts that I've seen
Superbia - Uggg - kind of like last game - not very helpful - null
Grackaroni - like last game too but nothing of help/doing/etc.

That's where I'm at now - Lynch Palmar/JAT preferred, Poke Super and Grack some more.

After this post which is meh, scott then doesn't actually do shit about super and grack and asks Palmar some throwaway question that he never gets a reply to or cares about again.