Newbie Student Mafia XXII - Page 40

Post a Reply

Prev 1 38 39 40 41 42 64 Next

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

August 04 2016 19:18 GMT

#781

On August 05 2016 03:25 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

Well who are you your two most liekly scums ? Cause it seemed like it was Lunatic + Celestial

Lunatic. Celestial in my paranoid world.

beentheredonethat

2934 Posts

August 04 2016 19:19 GMT

#782

On August 05 2016 03:25 MoosyDoosy wrote:
But I'm super darn sure btdt flips scum.

Where does that come from Oo

Skynx

Turkey7150 Posts

August 04 2016 19:20 GMT

#783

Rels can be confirmed for now I guess, I would still go back and read his interactions with Grack pre night flip tho.

Skynx

Turkey7150 Posts

August 04 2016 19:21 GMT

#784

On August 03 2016 19:05 J Roc wrote:
Fucking auto login...

LOL

Skynx

Turkey7150 Posts

August 04 2016 19:25 GMT

#785

On August 03 2016 20:07 silentwarrior wrote:

Show nested quote +

No, only lynch for me is lunatic. Also, claiming vig is the best thing for town right now. We get a confirmed town and we also might have a doctor, who will most likely protect Rels now. This is a very good position for town right now.

I wasn't even talking to you lol why so paranoid?

Skynx

Turkey7150 Posts

August 04 2016 19:29 GMT

#786

On August 03 2016 20:08 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

I didn't claim right before deadline because I was sleeping.
I don't understand what you are saying in that second part of your post. What I'm saying is that you should be happy that I claim cause now you know that I'm town and you can push whoever you want, silent or scsott being the most logical that is true given your list. Nothing you've written addresses this.

I think you do understand second part of my post.

Rels: The lynch today was basically me or silent, according to his list during the night. So me claiming is a fucking GOOD thing for him, as it makes him re evaluate and should push him in the right path instead of wasting time scumreading me.

Skynx: What is pushing the "right" part in your opinion here? Grack flipped green so it clears Silent? You are confirmed town so only lynch now is Scott?

I was pretty clear, you say my lynch options are you/silent. You being confirmed town should 'push me into right path'. I dunno if you're defending silent by saying I should consider other options or just saying silent is the right path. I asked you to clarify but this is more suspicious now I think about it.

Skynx

Turkey7150 Posts

August 04 2016 19:32 GMT

#787

On August 04 2016 17:45 Rels wrote:
Yeah Lunatic dude couldn't help but post every 30 seconds in the previous game, but can't be assed to post for days here. Mafia, or he has some IRL urgencies. Let's hope it's not the latter.

Or he took lessons from last game.

J Roc

96 Posts

August 04 2016 19:37 GMT

#788

Im kinda around kinda not. I will read up I promise.

Skynx

Turkey7150 Posts

August 04 2016 19:41 GMT

#789

On August 03 2016 07:28 silentwarrior wrote:
Ok, so I wanted to post my reads in case i get killed tonight. This will be mostly the people I left out from my previous big post.

Rels: At the start I got a town feeling from him. His push on mderg was imo credible and I don't think he should be faulted that it resulted in mislynch. Mderg looked scum there. But then he says he likes a list where he is listed as mafia. Not sure if he just missed it or simply liked the list without even reading it, but it is kind of strange. Especially since he is listed as the first mafia. For now he is null to me, and I think I need more to make a better assesment.

Townreading for mderg case (which is fair) and Rels is not at fault for mderg lynch.
Downgrades the townread cuz Rels liked my scumread on him (this is before vigclaim)
Overall null

I mean mderg lynch makes everyone voting for him suspicious straight away. Rels started the bandwagon, no matter how solid his case is, it is suspicious. Grack jumped on it without question, instantly scumread by all if he wasn't already.
If you have been following the game, you should find out that there is mafia in that train almost 100% of times. If you are town, Rels is town, grack also flipped, why are you not voting Scott instead of a nonfactor in this game?

Skynx

Turkey7150 Posts

August 04 2016 19:42 GMT

#790

Guys Lunatic is not the lynch here...

##Vote: Silentwarrior

Rels

France13467 Posts

August 04 2016 19:43 GMT

#791

On August 05 2016 04:20 Skynx wrote:
Rels can be confirmed for now I guess, I would still go back and read his interactions with Grack pre night flip tho.

Thanks for confirming yourself town

Rels

France13467 Posts

August 04 2016 19:44 GMT

#792

On August 05 2016 04:18 beentheredonethat wrote:

Show nested quote +

Lunatic. Celestial in my paranoid world.

Then I don't understand why you even consider scott in your town circle, since in your world he's the most likely partners of your two most likely scumteam.

Rels

France13467 Posts

August 04 2016 19:46 GMT

#793

On August 05 2016 04:32 Skynx wrote:

Show nested quote +

Or he took lessons from last game.

What lessons ? That he should do the exact opposite as last game ?
Last game he tried an awful lot. He was super wrong, but so was everybody, and he was saying a lot of nonsense; but he tryharded as fuck. There is NOTHING that shows that this game. He is scum

Rels

France13467 Posts

August 04 2016 19:46 GMT

#794

On August 05 2016 04:42 Skynx wrote:
Guys Lunatic is not the lynch here...

##Vote: Silentwarrior

No, Lunatic is the lynch

Skynx

Turkey7150 Posts

August 04 2016 19:49 GMT

#795

D1 pattern:

silent pushes stutters > stutters is getting townread > people jump off scott train to silent train > Rels starts mderg train > their only interaction in game happens:

On August 02 2016 07:18 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

These posts are townie:

Show nested quote +

On August 02 2016 06:44 Stutters695 wrote:

On August 02 2016 01:51 mderg wrote:

On August 02 2016 00:29 MoosyDoosy wrote:

On August 01 2016 22:56 Skynx wrote:
Also Moosy how is KSC town is that a tone read?

Yes.

On August 01 2016 22:54 mderg wrote:

On August 01 2016 22:42 MoosyDoosy wrote:

On August 01 2016 22:05 mderg wrote:

On August 01 2016 21:39 MoosyDoosy wrote:

On August 01 2016 17:40 mderg wrote:

On August 01 2016 12:57 Grackaroni wrote:
[quote]
I think that mafia tends to play more subdued is a pretty standard idea that most players would accept. I'm not saying Race Bannon could never be mafia but lynching the guy who goes out of his way to spam the thread and pisses everybody off in the process is definitely not a good place to start if you want to hit mafia.

Silent made the first serious accusatory post of the game and put himself in the spotlight. I liked the post just because I think that Kelsier's non-contribution would look scummy to a newcomer, but the start of the game is the easiest time to "contribute". All I've gathered so far is that Kelsier seems annoyed from the state of the game and can't be assed to start playing. I don't really read Kelsier either way. Also I can disagree with a post's conclusions and still townread somebody for their post. Case in point, I don't really agree with your reads or any of the reasoning attached to them, but I'm still very thankful for something to comment on and will give a town read for it. It's magic!

As for my choice not to post my thoughts before getting other people's. Are you saying that I'm afraid of putting forth my own thoughts before seeing other people's or something else? I don't think that will be too much of an issue. Actually I think the reason I've come up here in the first place is that I've actually put out some of the more distinctive things.

My point here for Mderg is that he's pushed three slots that I feel are town slots. What kind of deception do you think I'm trying to slip under the radar here? Anyone can read his filter in 30 seconds and see whether he has posted about Race bannon or Scott.

I didn't push lunatic, I was just hoping my post would start some discussion while I'm away.

That makes it 2 "town slots" I've pushed. I really can't see what you like about either of them. I actually dislike scott's posts more than I did Race Bannon's (alignment wise).

explAin dood

Race Bannon simply posted gibberish which is obnoxious and annoying but not really alignment indicative.

scott made a list of people who had their vote on Race Bannon and took picked one of those to push. It doesn't take a town hero to call BTDT out on that. Then he gives town points to J Roc for having called out the same post by BTDT. He also liked silentwarrior's post regarding Kelsier which I didn't like for reasons already stated.
His thoughts so far seem superficial and lacking any sort of depth. And that's something I see as scummy, more so than one obviously bad post.

So do you think btdt's post was shit or good?

it was bad

So you're scumreading scott because he's scumreading btdt for making a shit post?

The scumread itself is not my issue with scott. I'll try to explain it again.

btdt's post basically had a big sign with "That's bad for town" attached to it. Scott scumread him for that,nothing wrong with that, though a bit superficial.
Then he also townread J Roc for voicing the same concerns about the post with the big sign. Calling out such a post is really not a reason for townreading somebody.
He also liked silentwarrior's post about Kelsier. Kelsier carrying a huge sign saying "anti town".

That's just way too superficial for me. There's no effort to really figure people out in there, just focusing on single posts with imo very little value. It's like he's following a simple line of seeing a obviouslybad post -> seeing people calling those posts out -> townreading those people. I'd expect a townie to put a bit more thought into it than that.

This post makes me much more in favor of a silent lynch over mderg now that I've read his filter

Show nested quote +

So I'm not sure of anything on Stutters.

>silent votes mderg to survive

Skynx

Turkey7150 Posts

August 04 2016 19:50 GMT

#796

On August 05 2016 04:46 Rels wrote:

Show nested quote +

No, Lunatic is the lynch

Okay since you are here, why is silent town? Why you defended him intentionally or unintentionally all game?
Take your time.

Skynx

Turkey7150 Posts

August 04 2016 19:52 GMT

#797

Celestial, Moosy, Onegu come here we are about to lynch completely blind target don't let it happen, read 39-40 why he's not the best lynch.

Rels

France13467 Posts

August 04 2016 19:58 GMT

#798

On August 05 2016 04:50 Skynx wrote:

Show nested quote +

Okay since you are here, why is silent town? Why you defended him intentionally or unintentionally all game?
Take your time.

I'm not sure he's town. But all of these are more likely to flip scum than silentwarrior:
Lunatic KSC Moosy

As to why silent might be town:
I can see his thoughts process in all his posts. Everything he says is logical. If you scumread him for activity, please the only other game he played on this website: he also played a low activity game with long posts. He made a huge case on someone just before end of night. That is something a townie is way more likely to do than scum.

-Celestial-

United Kingdom3867 Posts

August 04 2016 20:00 GMT

#799

I'm back now from being out. Not caught up yet.

No alternative wagon makes me feel very icky though.