On April 30 2016 08:49 Tictock wrote, among other things:
From my pov we have confirmed town Tumble, Koshi is is almost certainly town (or deserves the win if mafia), Shape who is probably town from DYH's D1 push and my shitty reasoning from earlier. Which leaves HtS and Gum.
I don't like the comment "or deserves the win if scum". I don't know whether that's because I think it's scummy, or entirely because that's a stupid phrase. Just leave it out. Say, "Koshi is almost certainly town." There. 1 scum point awarded to TT for saying something so bad, like town would award scum a win for playing so well.
onto relevant points
I think your Shape townread is unfounded, but it's an odd read for scum to make, because Shape is a totally viable mislynch target for scum.
arrrghhh I have weak reasons but strong vibes