On April 19 2016 08:53 DoYouHas wrote:
This is actually something I disagree with you on. Some of the best reads you can get on players is when they are under pressure. Imminent lynch is some of the truest pressure in the game. People posting convincing things right before they get lynched isn't a guarantee of townieness but it certainly shouldn't be discarded as NAI.
Sure but i don't know how a mafia response would differ from a town response here, or like how do those particular things Fidei said differ from what mafia would do. So he basically said:
- "Please do not lynch me" -- why would mafia want to get lynched here? Why wouldn't mafia try to not get lynched here?
- "I'm liking Artanis and Kugari and Tumblewood from these latest interactions." -- He likes random three people for no explained reason (a player who is leading his lynch, and other two who are NOT on his wagon NOR the opposing wagon of boxerfred). I mean if he is going to appeal to some people as mafia, i am not sure who would else would be more "perfect" people to appeal to? Furthermore, when he presents his reads at night 1 he calls all of those three people mafia!!! 
So yeah, not really seeing it here.
On April 19 2016 10:42 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On April 19 2016 06:23 raynpelikoneet wrote:On April 19 2016 04:41 disformation wrote:
Like only slam dunk town were CHodge and Fidei. Who made for two super easy nightkills...
I disagree with this btw. I would have killed Artanis/Damdred/DYH as mafia every night over them, regardless of their reads. CHodge's reads on D1 basically were (based on his filter);
- calls basically every person he talks about "possible mafia".. oh well.. that was it
Fidei was only a good NK if mafia thinks he was copped N1 (which is a reasonable assumption i agree). There was nothing much townie in his filter.
Apparently you missed my posts. I was Chodge and the only person wanting to lynch scum. Other than DYH, I had my town reads right and wanted to lynch RB and then probably look at Artanis after N1 (I got busy during N1). Fwiw, I think I lynch Artanis or RB D2. But idk for sure for obvious reasons.
First of all Gossemerr was also by your definition "wanting to lynch mafia" since he also voted for Race Bannon. Was he not pushing enough then? I wouldn't say you were pushing a mafia lynch at all -- just because noone listened to you, and this is the closest thing to a push:
On April 06 2016 14:36 CHodge wrote:
I for right now will guess with voting Race Bannon, however, I'm not terribly against lynching most players to my terrible displeasure.
..which happened right after you made an ACTUAL case on GlowingBear?????
Yeah you had some townreads right. You also called half of the game scum and didn't really push anyone. Like really push (in fact if i discount the words "i am voting for.." from your posts it looks like you don't even think RB is your top scumread). I am not sure why you are talking about your N1 since you didn't make any posts at night 1 so whatever you thought then didn't end up in the thread. People cannot read your mind, now can they?
EPT
