i disagree with you though i think there's a very real chance darth is town. that post i quoted recently is pretty town. he basically says:
here are LS's reads -> oh wow they line up fairly close to mine -> wait a second, he thinks i am more mafia than rels -> shouldn't he think the opposite if he agrees with me and disagrees with rels? -> pressure him on this point.
On February 25 2016 04:53 darthfoley wrote: @Rels I still think your "VA is being aggressive" line is bullshit. Your explanation was basically just him throwing a few names out early. How is that aggressive when there's NO explanation? I guess Kush plays every game aggressive then because of his random scum list 1.1 1.2 lists. Aggressively implies that he's pushing his reads. He's done no pushing, and seems very happy with me being scum read, stating over and over how great it's going to be when "we go up 2-0" we = ???
is more or less the same as mine with different words, yet you are awarding town points while awarding me scum points. Either that VA read is good or it is not. You are applying different criterias for different players.
just in case you didn't know i coached darth pretty much the same way i coached you if that helps you read him at all.
On February 25 2016 04:53 darthfoley wrote: @Rels I still think your "VA is being aggressive" line is bullshit. Your explanation was basically just him throwing a few names out early. How is that aggressive when there's NO explanation? I guess Kush plays every game aggressive then because of his random scum list 1.1 1.2 lists. Aggressively implies that he's pushing his reads. He's done no pushing, and seems very happy with me being scum read, stating over and over how great it's going to be when "we go up 2-0" we = ???
Ritoky's read:
On February 25 2016 03:35 ritoky wrote: 4) VA did his town meta thing
is more or less the same as mine with different words, yet you are awarding town points while awarding me scum points. Either that VA read is good or it is not. You are applying different criterias for different players.
just in case you didn't know i coached darth pretty much the same way i coached you if that helps you read him at all.
@bum: VA declares multiple people as town or mafia within his first 3 posts as town and gives no reasons. usually he calls people mafia if i remember right, but i would have to check. as mafia he tries to talk to people at the start of the game. i said earlier in thread though, i used this meta read in his last game (star wars) to find him as mafia early, so it is possible he adapted.
idk i don't have the best read on VA, i generally think he is a less spammy but similar player to me. he posts trolly shit sometimes, he likes gifs, he makes reads in ways that not necessarily everyone is convinced by or understands. which isn't helpful.
but the helpful part i guess is that i think he is like me a bit in the way that with both of us if we are stubborn, funny, obstinate, or a dick then counter intuitively we are probably town; and if we are making friends and nice then we are probably mafia.
this could be a gross misrepresentation of myself and VA but it's the way i think about it.
@OWS can you cite some specific posts about your LS read? i looked through your filter and saw in the large post you said he had solid town reasoning, then later you said you weren't wavering at all and still thought he was town.
also you have not said a word about rels since he has posted, in your filter you said he hasn't posted so why talk about him, so what do you make of him and his case on DF?
basically LS is WAYYYYYYYYYYYY more concerned with people reading him town than really legitimately attempting to find mafia imo; rels isn't even considering the possibility that LS is mafia for a reason that he really hasn't explained other than LS typed in caps and is just tunneled on darth which is unlike his normal approach as town which he is more even handed in his analysis.
darth is the only 1 of the 3 who actually seems to be attempting to determine both the other players in his cell's alignments. plus i quoted one of his posts earlier and it was some straight up town mindset shit i taught him a couple games ago of how to proceed as town. the only thing that gives me slight pause about him is rels doesn't have a bad point about "ritoky = town hero for VA read; rels = shitter" when our reads weren't terribly dissimilar.
On February 26 2016 05:31 Rels wrote: Ritoky you're posting bullshit. You scumread me before because I wasn't sure on both ls and df; now you're scumreading me because I am too sure of ls. Ive posted exactly why ls is town, contrary to what you've just said. Either prove its wrong or shut up.
On February 24 2016 22:46 Rels wrote: LS => no idea one way or another, it will become clear when he is up for lynch. Would like Damdred's read on him.
On February 25 2016 07:05 Fecalfeast wrote: Alright so here's the list: Most confident LS - He knows his meta as scum is to not post at all and this game most of his posts are spammy and benign (I think I used the word benign already this game oops) shapelog - I think OWS and Damdred look way more towny Vivax - He's pushing on VA for something I honestly think is plausible. Two people with bum in their name is something that would throw me off I think. SL - Seems right. Breshke - I don't know, tbh, but the way vivax is pushing VA makes me think it's not VA Least Confident
WHAT ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME? I HAD POSTED EVERYTIME I WAS ACTUALLY AROUND WHEN I NOT PLAYING GAMES OR IN CLASS -.- THIS IS UTTER BULLSHIT YOU ARE DEAD WRONG BUT YOUR JUST DUMB TOWN..............
Town
then you proceed to say "meta cuz capslock cannot be faked" which is horseshit to me. especially if you have used the meta case before and he knows about it.
and before i found it scummy that you had literally a stronger opinion on every other player in the game than the 2 people who you know had a 1 in 2 shot at being scum. especially when both people running for mayor wanted your cell to be for certain in the first 3.
On February 26 2016 07:03 LightningStrike wrote: Oh nice Breshke was scum Time for us to go 2-0 boys! Darth you may post your baby seals ##Vote: darthfoley
On February 26 2016 07:03 LightningStrike wrote: Oh nice Breshke was scum Time for us to go 2-0 boys! Darth you may post your baby seals ##Vote: darthfoley
why does breshke being scum implicate darth?
I had darth as scum via PoE if you had checked out my reads post Hence why I said he should post his baby seals.
your post made it sound like they were related, if not then nevermind