[M][T] The New Personality Mafia - Page 45

On August 21 2015 02:36 Half the Sky wrote:


Seriously?

We're 44 pages into the game and you are telling me you don't have opinions on Fidei or Tubesock at least those two being the other two competing wagons?

You have/had an opinion on ruXxar and he's the leading wagon - you said previously you wanted to sheep town reads, so where are your strong town reads right now even?

On August 21 2015 02:35 Half the Sky wrote:


That is stupid if that's what it is. I personally can't tell whether people are sarcastic on forums in general without the use of emoticons or whatever. *shrug*

On August 21 2015 02:40 Half the Sky wrote:


Let's say VA votes ruXxar. Then what?

On August 20 2015 23:53 Half the Sky wrote:




Alright, so Tube, you told me that your "you scum Damdred" was in response to Fecalfeast. Fine.

You explained why you thought Damdred was useful but where are you distinguishing he's town? Is there a quote? A reaction? A response?

There are several players that are saying (besides myself) that a) he could be roleplaying as either alignment, geript himself has said he can't get a read (or positive town/not town read either way), so taking that assumption and even if he's getting reactions, how do you know he's not doing it as scum?

Am I making sense here?

On August 21 2015 02:53 Fidei86 wrote:
EBWOP (the above randomly misses out the end of a sentence that I'd started)

I just spent 15-20 minutes or so flicking back through OWS' past games. I read the first five pages of filter from his last two town games, and his last mafia game. In both, he definitely favours making lots of small posts. Furthermore, as town, he didn't seem particularly inclined to actually give reads or to make scum cases, rather all of his posts read like an ongoing dialogue with the thread. What struck me is that they all seemed to have a serious point to them, as though he was driving somewhere with them. The contrast to his scum game was subtle, but noticeable. In that, his points were responsive, but they were usually directionless. They read to me as though he was trying to stifle other people's lines of enquiry and also fill up his filter.

To me, his filter this game reads more like the scum version of OWS that I have read than the town version of OWS. In the town filter that I flicked through, he had no off-topic posts. Here, I think I saw maybe five or six? He has a few where he is just commenting on who people are. He talks about xbox controllers quite a bit. It's not necessarily scum indicative to drag the conversation 'off topic' of course, but it doesn't look like something that town OWS did before. His questions also read to me as less incisive and less fluid than his posts. His flip-flop-flip on the Tube v Ruxx lynch is particularly jarring - he still hasn't looked into Ruxxar's games, or asked anyone who played with Ruxxar previously for an opinion. If he really thinks that that is the way to tell if Ruxx is scum, he should do it.

Has anyone else played with him and get the same sense as I do? I obviously don't know the context of those games, so there could be something I'm missing.

On August 21 2015 02:26 geript wrote:
Basically, we should be lynching one of VA, Yamato, Kelsier or Chezinu. All of them know about the game. All of them have posted. None of them care to do anything or in any way help lynch actual scum. Like these votes for ruxxar who has the longest fucking filter are pretty fucking egregious when we have dickheals like these 4 who choose not to play. Lynch them. Shoot them. Tell them to go fuck themselves.