EPTOn August 21 2015 03:28 Tubesock wrote:
Obi, other than me, who would you lynch? Why?
Obi, other than me, who would you lynch? Why?
Rux for posting garbage.
Yam/Chezinu for doing nothing.
Otherwise idk.
[M][T] The New Personality Mafia - Page 46
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
ObiWanShinobi
United States8089 Posts
Rux for posting garbage. Yam/Chezinu for doing nothing. Otherwise idk. | ||
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
| ||
|
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
| ||
|
Tubesock
United States2726 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:23 JudgeJudy wrote: I just re-read Chezinu's filter and I'm satisfied enough to ##Vote Chezinu. We really should start consolidating on a couple of targets so it's not a last minute thing that comes down to the three people who happen to be around at the deadline. I didn't further talk about Fidei because he showed up and we chatted for a couple hours. Nothing really new to add. I still think he's best lynch. He's really nice so I kinda feel bad but then I read his stuff and it's like uhhhhhh what? His response about Damdred was mostly about Damdred the player not how he was in this game nor if he would lynch him or not. Several other people pointed out how he didn't answer questions but he sure is nice. yeeeeaaaaaah. Scum. Granted, Chezinu hasn't done much. What do you think of how he went after Damdred or Ritoky? I liked it felt towny to me. His downsides are that he isn't continuing it, and other than knowing his 4 current townreads, no one knows if he still scums Damdred or Ritoky. How does that outweigh 2 others who are doing some majorly weird shit? Let's even forget Fidei, ruXxar was slinging scum on anyone just to see if anything stuck. I guess you can call that scumhunting by reaction testing? But that seems pretty far fetched to me. I don't see how lynching Chezinu is higher prob mafia than Fidei, ruXxar or coinflipping half a dozen lurkers. | ||
|
Half the Sky
Germany9029 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:12 Tubesock wrote: @geript - I'd be fine with Yam, Kels, VA, LT, Beneather as policies. Although Ben will be modkilled I'm sure so basically equivelant to a no vote in a way. I liked Chezinu early on. It's probably also because he's one of my favorite players to read so I don't want to lynch him as he's fun. kinda bummed he got one of the serious players. He hasn't really done anything since but sheep cool kids. So haha yeah pretty strong reason to not lynch a guy That's actually a really poor reason not to lynch a guy or even townread them. A mafia player can townread someone and sheep someone for bad reasons, those same points were being brought up I believe against Rels. The bias on Chez is understandable since I recall you have your ways with some of the harder players to read (generally) but someone being "fun" I don't value the same as being town, I realise it's a personality game and I can understand a tone read on someone being lighthearted (normally) associating with being town, but I don't see the way you've listed as a valid reason for being town. Also why is your vote still on Fidei? The other two I realise have been afk for a bit, but... | ||
|
ObiWanShinobi
United States8089 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:36 Tubesock wrote: I didn't further talk about Fidei because he showed up and we chatted for a couple hours. Nothing really new to add. I still think he's best lynch. He's really nice so I kinda feel bad but then I read his stuff and it's like uhhhhhh what? His response about Damdred was mostly about Damdred the player not how he was in this game nor if he would lynch him or not. Several other people pointed out how he didn't answer questions but he sure is nice. yeeeeaaaaaah. Scum. Granted, Chezinu hasn't done much. What do you think of how he went after Damdred or Ritoky? I liked it felt towny to me. His downsides are that he isn't continuing it, and other than knowing his 4 current townreads, no one knows if he still scums Damdred or Ritoky. How does that outweigh 2 others who are doing some majorly weird shit? Let's even forget Fidei, ruXxar was slinging scum on anyone just to see if anything stuck. I guess you can call that scumhunting by reaction testing? But that seems pretty far fetched to me. I don't see how lynching Chezinu is higher prob mafia than Fidei, ruXxar or coinflipping half a dozen lurkers. Fidei is a bad lynch. Put your vote somewhere else. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:31 WaveofShadow wrote: Cmon bby. You know as well as I do that that's not particularly effective. The fact that you think ruxxar shouldn't be lynched based on filter, even though half of that filter is pregame spam is what's egregious. It's more than just filter Wave. I've explained it a few times in thread. He says stupid shit as town. He's for the most part kept talking and is acting unafraid. He's got a longer filter than most (hell most haven't broken 2-3 pages. There's lots of reasons to think he's a bad flip. | ||
|
Half the Sky
Germany9029 Posts
Tube did you even read some of Fidei's latest posts? Maybe I'm biased because I know his play better but how the hell is he still a top scumread? | ||
|
ObiWanShinobi
United States8089 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:39 geript wrote: It's more than just filter Wave. I've explained it a few times in thread. He says stupid shit as town. He's for the most part kept talking and is acting unafraid. He's got a longer filter than most (hell most haven't broken 2-3 pages. There's lots of reasons to think he's a bad flip. Can you explain to me why it's town!bad and not just him being scum? | ||
|
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
By the way I was thinking about it and if Lord Tolkien is FecalFeast, I am fairly vocal about my preference toward scum I too am liking fidei more and more, still voting yamato until he does something I like. | ||
|
Lord Tolkien
United States12083 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:42 Fecalfeast wrote: + Show Spoiler + By the way I was thinking about it and if Lord Tolkien is FecalFeast, I am fairly vocal about my preference toward scum I too am liking fidei more and more, still voting yamato until he does something I like. 1) Finally, someone figured it out. Now I can stop RPing and/or shitposting. 2) I am not, however, scum. So nyaaaaah. This is the same line of reasoning that I called out for being retarded when geript says: there's like an 80% chance that a Blazinghand role is scum". Role speculation based on flavor is bad and should make you feel bad. For instance, http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia#3 Hearthstone Mafia. Tirion Fordring as a scum role? Kelthuzad and Rexxar as a town role? lel. | ||
|
Half the Sky
Germany9029 Posts
That was a hypothetical, and you completely missed the point of what I was asking. I could have asked the similar question - what if VA gets modkilled? There's a reason I'm asking (either way) like this. Don't even need to comment on everyone - shit the top issues alone will do. A number of people have stopped roleplaying so there's some beginning point (since you commented on it earlier.) Hell, what if VA is scum? I mean I'd say just "waiting" the way you are is quite scummy, with <4h remaining... | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:41 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Can you explain to me why it's town!bad and not just him being scum? Can you explain why any of yamato/VA/Chez/Kelsier are town!lurking instead of scum!lurking? And no, I'm not going to bother trying to analyze the game super heavily so long as we're allowing people to literally not play the fucking game whatsoever. I'm going to go with what I think and the best odds. Like there's literally not a point. The cases on him aren't very good. They don't address the points that have been brought up that make him a bad flip whatsoever. They continue to ignore the actual problems that we have in this game. Bottom line, we can't let Kelsier/VA/Yam/Chez anywhere near lylo. Because there's super fucking coin flips; it's better to clear the problem children now and analyze the game when we get to that point later. | ||
|
Half the Sky
Germany9029 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:49 Lord Tolkien wrote: 1) Finally, someone figured it out. Now I can stop RPing and/or shitposting. 2) I am not, however, scum. So nyaaaaah. This is the same line of reasoning that I called out for being retarded when geript says: there's like an 80% chance that a Blazinghand role is scum". Role speculation based on flavor is bad and should make you feel bad. For instance, http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/469686-hearthstone-mafia#3 Hearthstone Mafia. Tirion Fordring as a scum role? Kelthuzad and Rexxar as a town role? lel. On #2, then who is? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
The great chez must be a monster | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:50 Damdred wrote: The damdred rule has never failed and to simplify this rule into trolling and being scum read is an injustice the world has never seen. The great chez must be a monster It's time to stop trolling Damdred. | ||
|
Lord Tolkien
United States12083 Posts
It could be fucking anyone. Just stop relying on role meta to try and figure it out. I'm actually putting on my serious face, so I'll be back in 1hr do to #townthings. | ||
|
Tubesock
United States2726 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:38 Half the Sky wrote: On mobile, bear with me.... That's actually a really poor reason not to lynch a guy or even townread them. A mafia player can townread someone and sheep someone for bad reasons, those same points were being brought up I believe against Rels. The bias on Chez is understandable since I recall you have your ways with some of the harder players to read (generally) but someone being "fun" I don't value the same as being town, I realise it's a personality game and I can understand a tone read on someone being lighthearted (normally) associating with being town, but I don't see the way you've listed as a valid reason for being town. Also why is your vote still on Fidei? The other two I realise have been afk for a bit, but... Course it's a bad reason it's mostly because I like the guy. You guys are towning Fidei because he's nice. That's literally it. | ||
|
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:50 Damdred wrote: The damdred rule has never failed and to simplify this rule into trolling and being scum read is an injustice the world has never seen. The great chez must be a monster You're still scum eh? | ||
|
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
On August 21 2015 03:52 Tubesock wrote: Course it's a bad reason it's mostly because I like the guy. You guys are towning Fidei because he's nice. That's literally it. nope | ||
| ||
