Newbie Student Mafia XI - Page 119

On June 21 2015 19:21 Rels wrote:
OK oats I'll reread everything tomorrow before taking a stance. But you lied in this post.

That is exactly what you did day 3 to kickstart.

On June 21 2015 17:19 WaveofShadow wrote:
I'm going to tell you something you're not going to like. I'm done with you. I don't see how a town Oats could possibly play THIS horribly. Even for you. It reeks of scummy desperation and a bad choice of mislynch.
##vote: Oatsmaster

Trfel/Ruxxar you're next.

On June 21 2015 23:03 WaveofShadow wrote:
So I just noticed something interesting.
The timing of oats claim comes after he can be sure town doesn't have a cop.
He waits for everyone in the town to have posted to confirm rather than claim early in the day.

You ask 'but wave, everyone had posted already waayyy before oats claimed!' Look at the timing of trfels post. He posts and leaves before the idea of cop claiming comes up. Oats waits until he posts the second time to be absolutely sure its safe. (This actually means trfel is probably town?)

It's obvious to me where votes need to be today. I have proof now oats is scum but the rest of you need to choose one way or another. Objectively the claim and his 'proof' is awful but I suppose im just biased considering my position. Either way i'm not going to spend what time I have arguing with him either so you guys can do what you feel is right and I'm going to do what I can to help find the final scum. Probably not much until tomorrow though as its fathers day today.

So I just noticed something interesting.

On June 21 2015 13:37 WaveofShadow wrote:
Scum between Oats/Trfel/Ruxxar
ezpz.
66% chance boyysssss

On June 21 2015 23:33 WaveofShadow wrote:
Unfortunately shouting 'I know im town therefore oats must be scum' isn't helpful to everyone else that doesn't know my alignment. I've already shown two ways that you're faking it. Your explanation of your scum reading kickstart is horseshit.

Go ahead and explain away and bring all the horseshit you need to. Hopefully town doesn't buy into it but at least I'm doing all I can.

On June 21 2015 23:53 Oatsmaster wrote:

For like the 3rd damn time, why would I fakeclaim such a shitty check?
I havent seen any answers from anyone.

You dont seem worried that being lynched means town lose the game.
You dont seem worried at all.

On June 22 2015 00:33 ruXxar wrote:


I have to agree with the point oats is making here.

If he was fake claiming cop, why wouldn't he say that he red checked me or rels?
It would be such an easy win for the mafia.

On June 22 2015 04:50 Rels wrote:
Yo, between two drinks, here is a message to Oats, as he probably will be sleeping when I wake up tomorrow:

Oats, I'm not believing your claim right now.
But ... it makes a little bit more sense than I thought. You didn't attack batsnacks during D2. You ignored Kickstart during D3.

So. Please show me a previous game of yours where you do something like that. If it exists, show me a game where you are a cop and you did one of the following:
- you didn't claim a redcheck, but tried to attack him with arguments
- you didn't breadcrumb
- you attacked a greencheck to throw off mafia members

On June 22 2015 07:05 ruXxar wrote:
So here's where I am at:

I really want to lynch oats, nothing would please me more, he's been nothing but a useless townie all game.

However, my brain is telling me that if there's a godfather in the game, there has to be a cop.
On top of that, it's a newbie game. Chances are the setup will be pretty default with a medic/cop.

Assuming this I see two scenarios:

Either oats is fake-claiming and we have a cop that has yet to claim.
Or, he's telling the truth and wave is mafia.

All of my beeing really wants to lynch oatsmaster, but I can't reasonably convince myself that there somehow is a godfa ther but not a cop.

If the real cop is out there, please claim so my world will make sense again.

On June 21 2015 15:34 Trfel wrote:
How does TL+ help you search the thread faster? (not accusing, just wondering)

On June 21 2015 12:41 Oatsmaster wrote:
To be fair, i wrote that post right after wave asked you a bunch of questions but before you went all "oats sucks, he has to be mafia or we blame him for the loss"

It's fine, but you aren't gonna lynch me at the end of the day. For sure.

Btw can we nolynch? We should no lynch if we can.