Generic Boring Mini Mafia - Page 39

On May 21 2015 03:31 Damdred wrote:
Not even a comment on my post obi sadness

On May 20 2015 15:02 Qwerty! wrote:
cant say i was expecting scrib to defend me like that, but ive been successfully pocketed

ObiWanShinobi is scum mostly because of scriberbias case. i noticed two additional reasons.

1. inconsistent tone

obi normally plays as he pleases, and is willing to be aggressive, disagree with people, and doesnt really care what others think of him. this game has many examples of this. however, there is one post that is a major departure from this:i dont really see this post coming from a town obi at all (given the tone of the rest of his posts this game). Town can be headstrong and stubborn, town can be apologetic and meek, but its really hard to see both in such a short time period.

And it's not like obi put out enough content to fully correct his being useless, but his tone completely reverted to his original complete confidence.

2. i feel a tone change once the lynch started shifting to vivax. this isnt necessarily an issue, but obi's tone (to me) seems to be smug, which isnt really fitting for a townie who was just up for lynch.

---

as for onegu... i checked my meta more carefully, and i was mistaken about the frequency that he complains about being town. this is pretty embarrassing...

still, its a point against him, and im suspicious of him.

another reason he is scummy is how aggressively he commented on plynches and inactives (his second read of the game is on me), when i know that he hates inactives, shown by this post from Student Mafia VIII.
And from this game:I bolded the inconsistency. I find it really strange that onegu is inconsistent about how his stance on less active players,
And a final example. From someone who hates plynching inactives?

By the time of the lynch, Onegu expressed suspicions on the following:
Qwerty!
GlowingBear
Sealoz
Shockey
Vivax
Oatsmaster
Palmar (more on this later)
scriberbia

I don't really see a sense of direction here at all. he's fanning out and giving him as many lynch choices as possible.

He's also really heavily following the thread sentiment on all of his votes (Sealoz and then Vivax). Policy voting me isnt enough to change this.

Finally, his discussion with palmar makes no sense. First he seems disappointed that Palmar disappeared, and he says that he disagreed with Palmar's first read. Palmar never explains his Damdred scumread. Still, Onegu alternates between begging Palmar to come back and solve the game and being potentially willing to lynch him.

---

my head is hurting (i got a cold ), this is about it from me for tonight, i think. will answer any questions though.

not really sure about the third mafia yet, though some of stutters' early posts were really suspicious (specifically the way he referenced how assassination mafia changed his mindset).

On May 20 2015 07:08 Damdred wrote:
I think Obi is a sub optimal lynch on day one and how he acts around the lynch and during the night is more telling in context then when he's being a bastard under pressure generally.

And I disagree I thought Palmar case was good as did a few other people, it's easy to say x has a town lean but it's different when that lean does absolutely nothing for 36 hours which is alignment indicative of that person

On May 21 2015 04:17 ObiWanShinobi wrote:
I'd agree that I'd like Palmar to look at qwerty because he hasn't done so yet.

On May 20 2015 16:37 sciberbia wrote:
Oh damn. I just realized whose smurf Qwerty might be. And if he is who I think he is, he has a very strong reputation as a scum player and I might have to seriously worry about him being scum after all.

Qwerty what do?

On May 19 2015 04:01 Onegu wrote:
Then he says we should switch to palmar for???? Not really sure I guess because palmar hasnt done anything...

On May 21 2015 04:55 Damdred wrote:
I think he's always a scary player but looks pretty towny