Newbie Student Mafia X - Page 85

On May 29 2015 06:07 plotspot wrote:
Right I have no experience with it. If you think it's unusual, let's ask cakepie after the game why that is, do you agree?

On May 29 2015 06:11 disformation wrote:


That is basically my whole problem. The setup IS unusual no matter how I think about it. And if you or batsnacks are lying this stance might make town lose.

On May 29 2015 06:19 batsnacks wrote:
@disinfo My d2 play made enough sense for you to vote with me for the same reasons I did.

On May 29 2015 06:17 plotspot wrote:


Are you sure you have checked all the possibilities (also from the side of mafia) and came to the conclusion that it is unusual? No one is lying we are simply unclaimed blue roles, that's all there is to it. We should avoid talking about, it can only benefit mafia considering CClaiming.

On May 29 2015 06:21 disformation wrote:


Upon rereading it N2, I found it strange that your only interaction with bunnies was asking her for a read on barakos.

On May 29 2015 06:29 batsnacks wrote:


I am intentionally less useful at night, especially when I'm the cop. It makes sense if you think about it.

On May 29 2015 06:28 batsnacks wrote:


I would tell you this as either alignment:

4 blues in this setup is unusual.

Meaning it wouldn't be terrible for you to be at least slightly suspicious of my claim. I think tiktok is objectively the most likely to be telling the truth. If you don't understand why you can ask.

We should definitely -not- avoid talking about it. Mafia is never going to cc anything for the rest of the game it would be suicide at this point. If you don't understand why you can ask.

Here is every possibility:

• plots is lying. The blue roles are mason-mason-cop.
  
• batsnacks is lying. The blue roles are mason-mason-roleblocker
  
• plots and batsnacks are lying. The blue roles are mason-mason.
  
• plots and batsnacks are telling to truth. The blue roles are mason-mason-roleblocker-cop.
  

Assume anyone lying is mafia. Nothing else is possible.

On May 29 2015 06:32 disformation wrote:


meant to say "upon rereading your D2 behaviour during N2".

On May 29 2015 06:37 batsnacks wrote:


That was definitely not my only interaction with bunnies d2. I was the first person to vote bunnies. I started the wagon on her. I repeatedly asked her about bill. When she responded I followed up and asked for her comments on bill's big post that got everyone off his back. I asked her for reads on everyone.

On May 29 2015 06:39 disformation wrote:


rereading. please stay tuned.

On May 29 2015 06:41 plotspot wrote:
Or maybe if you have time you can explain to me why mason-mason is so strong. In my inexperienced eye they are just two confirmed towns to each other, and this gives them some sort of potential to sheep and defend each other, but I cannot see how it's related to these night-activity roles. I feel like I compare bananas and apples.

On May 29 2015 06:28 batsnacks wrote:


I would tell you this as either alignment:

4 blues in this setup is unusual.

Meaning it wouldn't be terrible for you to be at least slightly suspicious of my claim. I think tiktok is objectively the most likely to be telling the truth. If you don't understand why you can ask.

We should definitely -not- avoid talking about it. Mafia is never going to cc anything for the rest of the game it would be suicide at this point. If you don't understand why you can ask.

Here is every possibility:

• plots is lying. The blue roles are mason-mason-cop.
  
• batsnacks is lying. The blue roles are mason-mason-roleblocker
  
• plots and batsnacks are lying. The blue roles are mason-mason.
  
• plots and batsnacks are telling to truth. The blue roles are mason-mason-roleblocker-cop.
  

Assume anyone lying is mafia. Nothing else is possible.

On May 29 2015 06:09 disformation wrote:
Yeah, I agree that we should stop talking about roles and claims that much and just lynch the scummiest person around.

On May 29 2015 06:52 batsnacks wrote:


Mason-mason is strong because they can confirm each other town to the rest of the town. Unfortunately breshke died without saying who his partner is, but I think tiktok is telling the truth because if he is mafia he is risking being cced by breshke's partner (if breshke has a partner).

2 masons are almost as strong as 1 cop for town.

Using this game as an example:

I am the cop and I got two green checks before I will inevitably die tonight, so godfathers not considered I was able to get two checks.

If two masons confirm each other town, that's very similar to two checks.

On May 29 2015 07:03 Tictock wrote:
@ Bats

If you even have the slightest doubt that I am not Bre's partner.

I'm here, ask away.

I still need to look through your filter and double check that I believe your Cop claim. Besides that one slim point I made, I really was willing to believe it earlier. It matches up with your play being somewhat lurky and you not always giving us great reasoning for stuff. I also think you doubting your own checks now given unknown setups means you are more willing to look at this game critically, which makes you obv town.