hmmmm yeah I guess the like, objective merit / behavioral case on Keirathi is better than the one on vayneauthority (who we know is capable of being utterly unhelpful as town, a fact I learned in the last game I played where I carried town to victory), but even with all these wackly claims and crap basically I still think there's at least a 75% chance that the red check was 100% on vaynauthority

Damdred

15669 Posts

April 01 2015 20:56 GMT

#4283

Start of Day 2 I received an item called a Soul Fragment, its power was that I could block two players pms if they were town if they weren't town then they would be able to freely pm. I choose the players Rsoultin and the player Kita.

I wasn't trusting of these item so I picked one person who iw as suspicious of due to his power we talked about in PM Rsoultin and one person iw as heavily town reading but someone else was suspicious of. I used the power during the start of night and RSoultin was stripped of his PM powers showing that he was town and kita was allowed to continue his showing that he was anti-town.

I have sent this message to people to confirm my story and also there is another plan in place if I survive will explain the pm afterwards.

Damdred

15669 Posts

April 01 2015 20:56 GMT

#4284

This highly suggest Rsoultin is confirmed town and kita is scum

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

April 01 2015 20:58 GMT

#4285

lol nope

Damdred

15669 Posts

April 01 2015 21:01 GMT

#4286

I'm just informing the thread of the item I used usage and the effects that were reported back to me.

Keirathi

United States4679 Posts

April 01 2015 21:01 GMT

#4287

As much as I want kita to be scum...if that's a town item, who sent it to you?

It sounds more like a scum thing :o

Damdred

15669 Posts

April 01 2015 21:05 GMT

#4288

I was really hesitant to use the item, I talked to Oneg about it briefly that I was just thinking of ignoring it. Also I have no clue who sent it to me.

item description is thus

Players with good reputation will be unable to take part in PM conversations, players with bad reputation will still be able to communicate via PM.

ExO_

United States2316 Posts

April 01 2015 21:05 GMT

#4289

On April 02 2015 06:05 Damdred wrote:
I was really hesitant to use the item, I talked to Oneg about it briefly that I was just thinking of ignoring it. Also I have no clue who sent it to me.

item description is thus

Players with good reputation will be unable to take part in PM conversations, players with bad reputation will still be able to communicate via PM.

reputation doesn't necessarily mean scum/town

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

April 01 2015 21:06 GMT

#4290

boooooom i was right

Holyflare

United Kingdom30774 Posts

April 01 2015 21:07 GMT

#4291

http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/481138-aperture-mafia-4-this-time-its-personal?page=159#3169

^ more info and stuffz to back it up

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

April 01 2015 21:08 GMT

#4292

well first off...I don't have a bad reputation. Secondly, you assume bad reputation = mafia? Did you confirm with mods?

WaveofShadow

Canada31494 Posts

April 01 2015 21:09 GMT

#4293

I mean... If you were going to reveal it in thread immediately I'm not sure why you sent it to me damdred lol

Koshi

Belgium38799 Posts

April 01 2015 21:11 GMT

#4294

WoS is mafia. I am sure. Look at case. 4 points if you count the PM thing.

batsnacks is somewhat meta. Just keep an eye out for him.

VA read is based on marv. I wouldn't lynch him tomorrow. Just to keep in back of head. Or I might lynch him if WoS suddenly gets exonerated by set-up or something else.

xfire his fake role is pretty fucking brilliant (the 0.5kp and the getting stronger when counterpart is killed). I dont' believe it is fake. I think he probably evolved like this. I did not read the thread too closely but when wanting to lynch somebody I would seriously read what he is writing. It is completely off I think, and I think you can proof it.

Kita is also underperforming. Just the same as Hapa. It is respect lynch that grows more desirable each hour. I don't think he made a single post that made me think he is town, it is activity that once changed my mind.

HTS: Couple really odd posts I can't quote out of my head, I thought she would have made more of a mark now. Watch out.

Damdred: Some mafia get stronger by killing town counterparts. Are we sure he isn't one?

Sepulchre: 2 page filter earns him a spot here. But rereading filter and using meta is advised before lynching.

Holyflare: careful. He is the lylo lynch. never before that. I got a silly reason to think he is mafia. But it might be true. I don't understand his 3p claim btw, because he isn't a vendor? I dnu. It's getting odd. At this point in time he is in the no lynch zone like I said. I don't know when lylo hits btw, stupid how mafia might still have 3 kp.

do not lynch:
rsoultin
Onegu
LighteningStrike
Obiwan
Jat
Alakaslam
Snarfs
VE
yamato
BH
Keirathi
Exo_

People I forgot are null. All people in the do not lynch list are really do not lynch. I take risks on VE/Yamato I think but there filter is funny and/or interesting.

Damdred

15669 Posts

April 01 2015 21:12 GMT

#4295

The other person I sent it to told me he would rather me post it in the thread right before resolution and I know resolution took an hour and I was watching the timer and posted it then he laughed at me and told me I still had an hour <<.

And no I don't have a concrete answer that bad reputation is 100% mafia.

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

April 01 2015 21:12 GMT

#4296

On April 02 2015 06:12 Damdred wrote:
The other person I sent it to told me he would rather me post it in the thread right before resolution and I know resolution took an hour and I was watching the timer and posted it then he laughed at me and told me I still had an hour <<.

And no I don't have a concrete answer that bad reputation is 100% mafia.

Seems like something you'd want to check....no?

Damdred

15669 Posts

April 01 2015 21:13 GMT

#4297

I have asked and I did not get a concrete answer, also why are you trying to discredit the information i'm trying to give the thread. If the item worked incorrectly the first thought that I think would come to yoru mind would be that rsoultin should be mafia if the results are reversed no?

kitaman27

United States9245 Posts

April 01 2015 21:14 GMT

#4298

The creator of the item just confirms to a obvious town player via PM that they created the item. If no one comes forward, we assume mafia created it.

WaveofShadow

Canada31494 Posts

April 01 2015 21:14 GMT

#4299

On April 02 2015 06:11 Koshi wrote:
WoS is mafia. I am sure. Look at case. 4 points if you count the PM thing.

batsnacks is somewhat meta. Just keep an eye out for him.

VA read is based on marv. I wouldn't lynch him tomorrow. Just to keep in back of head. Or I might lynch him if WoS suddenly gets exonerated by set-up or something else.

xfire his fake role is pretty fucking brilliant (the 0.5kp and the getting stronger when counterpart is killed). I dont' believe it is fake. I think he probably evolved like this. I did not read the thread too closely but when wanting to lynch somebody I would seriously read what he is writing. It is completely off I think, and I think you can proof it.

Kita is also underperforming. Just the same as Hapa. It is respect lynch that grows more desirable each hour. I don't think he made a single post that made me think he is town, it is activity that once changed my mind.

HTS: Couple really odd posts I can't quote out of my head, I thought she would have made more of a mark now. Watch out.

Damdred: Some mafia get stronger by killing town counterparts. Are we sure he isn't one?

Sepulchre: 2 page filter earns him a spot here. But rereading filter and using meta is advised before lynching.

Holyflare: careful. He is the lylo lynch. never before that. I got a silly reason to think he is mafia. But it might be true. I don't understand his 3p claim btw, because he isn't a vendor? I dnu. It's getting odd. At this point in time he is in the no lynch zone like I said. I don't know when lylo hits btw, stupid how mafia might still have 3 kp.

do not lynch:
rsoultin
Onegu
LighteningStrike
Obiwan
Jat
Alakaslam
Snarfs
VE
yamato
BH
Keirathi
Exo_

People I forgot are null. All people in the do not lynch list are really do not lynch. I take risks on VE/Yamato I think but there filter is funny and/or interesting.

See once again koshi, saying I am 100% scum and then saying it's possible for me to be exonerated 'by setup' doesn't jive.