2p2 Vanilla Werewolf 13er - Page 6

On September 28 2014 06:58 Killing wrote:


You're telling me you can do nothing with the information that both I and Bat are town?

On September 28 2014 07:02 Killing wrote:
Fuck that, I outted early. I'm getting the most info out of it before I out it.

On September 28 2014 23:45 justanothertownie wrote:

What a helpful read.

On September 25 2014 08:34 Fecalfeast wrote:
The fact that nobody was using the voting thread made me think they were joke votes. That's why I didn't use the thread anyway.

Lol I actually like your case holyflare

On September 28 2014 23:52 justanothertownie wrote:

So, do you think he is mafia or why are you asking?

On September 28 2014 23:57 justanothertownie wrote:

Meeeh. I think that's a weak read. I mean I agree with you that he isn't very scummy because to me his play looks pretty similar to last game but anyone could say that really. The case wasn't that bad for the start of the game.

On September 28 2014 23:58 Holyflare wrote:
The only reason to kill gb is for seer searching. Dunno if he claimed vt at the start of the day. The kill is pretty irrelevant anyway.

Really don't like Palmar's recent posts at all. Super silly town reads that aren't even certain and has nothing to do with the main wagons or anything to do with what happened at deadline or any actual analysis of anything

On September 29 2014 00:01 batsnacks wrote:
Palmar is repeating himself.

On September 29 2014 00:02 justanothertownie wrote:

That's true but I still think that is not enough to townread him.

On September 29 2014 00:01 justanothertownie wrote:

I really am the wrong person to ask here. I have an abysmal track record for catching scum HF. He is responsible for 2 of my recent failures.

On September 28 2014 12:13 Superbia wrote:
This day fucking hurt to read, especially having to do it in one go.

Holyflare - I don't think the game would even progress without him. Town until there's a check or a scumslip.

Killing - Hard claims seer with a fake red, but later switches it to a double green check (one of which is conveniently dead). Like what the fuck are you even doing here? No cop would out here since you're giving town virtually nothing. Feels like scum trying to test the waters and see if they can bait out a counterclaim and get away with it. Doesn't help that he just literally ragequits the game right after, which scum loves to do. If it wasn't for the fact that we only have 1 PR I would lynch him right now, as it stands I don't even want to take the slightest risk when it comes to possibly lynching cop. That being said, I don't really believe it.

batsnacks - If there was a third party role, this would be the guy. He's playing the game upside down or something. Scumreads 2/3 of my town and townreads my current scum. Shit like this also stands out:
You played last game, Palmar stepped it up big time during d2. This read makes no fucking sense, just by reading Palmar's last game you should know this (specifically his d2 play). And then there is post #1132. Why don't you just admit that you soft claimed? You can't start the day off like that and expect people not to think you're soft claiming. It would've been fine in my eyes if you just backed off, but instead you make that overly defensive post. It just doesn't make any sense from a town perspective. Decently sure bats is scum, but I actually don't like a scumteam with both killing and bats, their interaction was too close, if that makes sense. I feel like we'll only hit 1 between the 2. Vote doesn't go on him because of the slightest possibility of Killing actually being cop.

Palmar - Actually really like Palmar's d2 and I'm not sure why so many people are giving him shit. He's straight to the point and no bullshit. It really seems like he is trying to defuse the clowning around soft claiming for an hour and straight up filter the information. It also helps that this made it way easier for me to read parts of d2. Liking Palmar as town.

Fecalfeast - Stepped up his d2 play in my eyes. He's saying relevant shit and is active with regards to relevant subjects (I also have to admit that I liked the jokes about sheeping). Get the feeling this guy might be town but I want to wait a little before I put him in my towncircle. He's definitely not a lynch for now.

justanothertownie - His posts feel a lot less vanilla-town this day and I like it. Didn't even have to visit the filter to notice his posts! Him pinging out killing also let to the weak cop claim, so if killing flips scum JAT is pretty much confirmed town. Leaving him null for now. Also not a lynch for now.

Will elaborate on other people who stand out (notably Sky at this point) come tomorrow, after I've had some sleep. Also we really need to resolve the Killing claim because my two primary scumreads are ironically the entire cop circle thing. I don't know if cop should counterclaim at this point though. I would rather take a bigger chance on a mislynch and for cop to have a possible red check on d3 at this point, followed by a double (and with slight possibility even triple) hit. I either scumread in the Sky/Obi/Haru group tomorrow, or new posts cause me to re-evaluate, or I'm completely clueless where to put my vote.

On September 29 2014 00:09 justanothertownie wrote:

I don't think this is true.

On September 29 2014 00:13 batsnacks wrote:
If you guys don't want to vote Palmar look at these people:



That sentence makes me think FF could be scum. In the fanfic he was never worried about posting. He posted stuff like this:



I think he's been more reserved in general this game.

Also maybe look at obiwan. He looks scummy too.