EPTLast game Yamato wrote off "GB as too scummy to be scum" low and behold GB flipped scum at the end game and yamato miss hammered d1 (was palmars crazy witch game so like day 2 lylo) So I'm not going to let someone by just because they were scummy and it was obvious.
Mission Mini Mafia - Page 19
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
Last game Yamato wrote off "GB as too scummy to be scum" low and behold GB flipped scum at the end game and yamato miss hammered d1 (was palmars crazy witch game so like day 2 lylo) So I'm not going to let someone by just because they were scummy and it was obvious. | ||
|
batsnacks
United States4466 Posts
On September 03 2014 07:29 Tehpoofter wrote: I realized that afterwards lol Oh its a voting thread well dammit. Will update. I think that his actions are scummy easy to find or not if he plays like that its scummy. Are you telling me you think that what he has done is townie? IF not you should vote for him. None of micchans posts have made me think anything about his alignment. I do think he is probably the easiest target right now though, right ahead of 3d12 who you also scum read. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On September 03 2014 07:38 batsnacks wrote: None of micchans posts have made me think anything about his alignment. I do think he is probably the easiest target right now though, right ahead of 3d12 who you also scum read. Do you agree that the points I made are what scum does? If not what about them seems town? Also what makes you so sure that Micchan and 3d12 are both town? Who do you think is mafia? | ||
|
Vivax
21972 Posts
You imply somebody, in this case poofter, is scummy for going after easy targets which is nonsense. You have a bunch of people playing the game, some play the game with more effort than others. When those playing with effort scumread those who play with less effort then yes, the target is easy but the motivation behind it is largely understandable. The hardest part of playing scum is putting effort you don't actually have to put into the game cause there's nothing for you to solve. So explain to me what the hell you're trying to achieve with this stuff on tp. | ||
|
Vivax
21972 Posts
| ||
|
batsnacks
United States4466 Posts
On September 03 2014 07:47 Tehpoofter wrote: Do you agree that the points I made are what scum does? If not what about them seems town? Also what makes you so sure that Micchan and 3d12 are both town? Who do you think is mafia? I agree that the points you raised are what scum does sometimes, I'm still null on both of them though. I never said either of them were townie in any way; I am not leaning town on either of them. I just don't think they're any scummier than than X person or Y person right now. I do wish micchan would post more. I don't know who is mafia yet. You going after the two easiest targets makes me want to scum read you but I'm apprehensive because of certain things. You double voted micchan, that's not a mistake I associate with mafia. You're receptive to questions. You're not just running around calling people scum for no reason, even if I don't feel as strongly as you do about your reasons. If you were curious, you are at least 1 town point higher micchan for responding to me. On September 03 2014 07:48 Vivax wrote: 1) So bats, do you think in terms of who is easy to lynch or in terms of who is town or not. 2) You imply somebody, in this case poofter, is scummy for going after easy targets which is nonsense. 3) You have a bunch of people playing the game, some play the game with more effort than others. When those playing with effort scumread those who play with less effort then yes, the target is easy but the motivation behind it is largely understandable. The hardest part of playing scum is putting effort you don't actually have to put into the game cause there's nothing for you to solve. 4) So explain to me what the hell you're trying to achieve with this stuff on tp. 1) Both and I think the two are related. 2) Your words not mine. In my personal experience, mafia prefers easy over difficult. 3) I agree with what you said here. 4) tp happened to be online at the same time as me, so we're talking. I had questions, he's had answers. I think we've made progress. My objective in talking with tp is to play the game and try to figure things out. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
Bang Marry Kill Reads list. Marry: No one yet although I got my eyes on Vivax and Kush to see if they might let me put a ring on it. Bang: Vivax - His reads have aligned with mine I liked the way he answered the buddying question I asked him last night he felt like he while disagreeing with me had a townie mindset. Kush - Initially he seemed to actually give a shit (thinking of Heavy Weight Game/World Cup style of Kush) Which got me all happy in the pants would love to see more though for now he can get it. Oats - I have you in bang for now your initial entrance seemed townie and different from Palmar's witch game. I would love to hear more of what you have to say about my Micchan case and get some interactions with you. Kill - Micchan - See my case on him he hasn't posted hardly anything and what he has posted has just set off scum alarms every single time we should all be voting this dude! Link to the post! The_Templar - His read on 3d12 that I was questioning him on felt really odd to me it seemed like to me a mafia either soft defending a newbish scumbuddy or soft defending a townie enough to hopefully not get blamed for his lynch. If his mission was defend several townies or a buddy this would make sense something about reading his post felt forced to me. I know also Templar as scum can come out of the gates firing as scum in the newbie game I saw him play in he had the 2nd if not the biggest filter and I think this reminds me of that game. 3d12 - Your apologetic tone I disagree with batsnacks that it is mainly a townie view point. You agreeing with Damdred felt like an attempt at buddying as well which I don't care for. I understand your new but I haven't gotten the newbie town vibe from you. Also the association with Templar is scummy to me as I pointed out above. 27nb - I think you overreacted to my trolly call out on you as well as Obi's vote and the post before you left where you said "Good luck making me look scummy day 1" felt REALLY weird to me. I think that your amount of contribution is very low for a town!bunnies. This seems a lot like your play when we were mafia in Cell Mafia II. Null - The rest of you not on the list honestly don't have a strong feeling about Batsnacks first post was useless and the questioning of my motives on Micchan seems townie but I disagree with your logic completely so hard for me to see it from a town mindset but the act of doing it is a little townie. Damdred/Kita/Obi - I don't have anything substantial on you guys as of yet. To all of you so I can read you a bit better where do you stand? Have you voted Micchan yet? | ||
|
kushm4sta
United States8878 Posts
| ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
| ||
|
batsnacks
United States4466 Posts
On September 03 2014 08:22 kushm4sta wrote: but who would you fuck he said he would bang vivax | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On September 03 2014 08:22 kushm4sta wrote: but who would you fuck bang and fuck are synonyms. Marry means fucking a bunch. Yo vote Micchan with me thnx. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
vivax/kush/oats atm. | ||
|
batsnacks
United States4466 Posts
On September 03 2014 08:24 Tehpoofter wrote: I just went to the front page to find a voting thread for this game and don't see it or at least the link isn't working.... am I slow in the head or is there no voting thread? This implies that voting in this thread is counting On September 02 2014 22:20 HaruRH wrote: Vote Count – Day 1 27ninjabunnies (0): Tehpoofter (0): The_Templar (1): batsnacks batsnacks (2): kushm4sta, Obiwanshinobi Micchan (1): Tehpoofter Obiwanshinobi (1): Oatsmaster Not voting (-): Everyone else Currently, batsnacks is set to be lynched with 2 votes. Please contact the mods if the vote count is incorrect. Thank you! Day 1 will end in (19:30 GMT (+00:00)). | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
On September 03 2014 07:25 batsnacks wrote: The OP says a voting thread will be used. I should probably take my vote off templar in that case. I didn't think it would count when I voted. ##unvote @tehpoofter : Are you intentionally choosing easy targets? Also your vote was already on micchan? Oh I read this as if there was a thread seeing now that was wrong. | ||
|
Tehpoofter
United States2911 Posts
| ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
Mostly Townish Tehpoofter - Wouldn't look into on day one due to activity. Generally agreeable. Vivax is an incredibly lazy scum from my experience, which isn't on par from what we've seen so far, which makes me lean town. He did pick up a spot where templar seemed to change opinions about myself, which shows he is reading. Wouldn't lynch. mderg - This is kinda silly but I'm leaning town due to "I thought a bit about how to deal with missions". The mafia team obviously wouldn't think about how to deal with the missions. It's always possible that he is mafia pretending to think about them to throw us off, but I'm not leaning that way right now. Damdred - "I really like the idea of trying to break the mafias mission as we go towards the Eo" This quote shows interest in generating a plan, which is generally townie thing to say. Again, probably a silly thing to make a read off of, but he would have to look pretty bad the second half of the day to consider lynching. batsnacks - "I don't know who are mafia yet" is generally something a townie will say earlier on in my opinion. Need more content. The_Templar - Townie....I think. obi does seem just as....blunt I suppose I'm look for....in the past games that I looked through as both alignments. I don't have a great feel one way or the other here. Scummyish oats is flying under the radar, which I associate with the last time he was scum that we played together. Effort seems suspect based on mentioning how he can't remember certain details multiple times. His posts make me think he has read the last 3-5 posts in the thread, picked one of them to reply to and moved on. kush is someone I usually think is scum. Whenever I look through his past games, as soon as I think I've found a pattern, he flips the opposite alignment and I need to throw the idea out the window. His speculation about templar having to post a "long post" as a mission was really poor and I don't see that as something a town player sees as likely so I have him closer to mafia than town right now, but I'd probably want to hear more opinions from others about his overall play so far. Micchan is definitely the low hanging fruit of the cycle. Typically I like pushing these types of lynches just as much as mafia do. I'm having trouble envisioning a scenario where he would be helpful on day three. The comment about 3d diverting attention seems sensationalized to me. His other post is a complaint without doing anything and a unnecessary defense. I might put myself in a bad spot if he flips green, but he may be my preferred lynch right now. I want to reread 3d since there were a bunch of things he said that rubbed me the wrong way, but I want to avoid the confirmation bias. I've ignored bunnies for the most part so I will reread her as well. I remember that she was commenting about a few things way past it being relevant, but that's about it. | ||
|
Vivax
21972 Posts
| ||
|
Vivax
21972 Posts
| ||
|
kitaman27
United States9245 Posts
| ||
|
Vivax
21972 Posts
On September 02 2014 11:10 kitaman27 wrote: It would be a scum read if he does this repeatedly. It's too early to go after that for a single post. If he starts interacting with the thread, then I'm not as concerned. Who do you find worse, 3d12 or batsnack? On September 03 2014 05:23 The_Templar wrote: I'm here again for another hour, as I am still working out kinks in my schedule. Sorry for being inconsistent about this. 3d12: I was initially a bit skeptical upon rereading this but 3d12 has not been too bad since then. He also gave the same read on ObiWan later (a move by kita which I seem to have messed with a bit). This is a decent post, although I don't entirely agree with it. Mafia would love an excuse or some way to cause chaos and force a mislynch so making a weird off topic post (that hopefully makes them a null read) and random voting could work (although, either possibility is very odd). He didn't really explain his thoughts on vivax/kush very well in this post. But, he did try to clarify his opinions in his next post. I don't like this post, but at least he's giving reasoning on his thoughts on Obi and Poofter. His read on Oatsmaster is very odd if he actually suspects him. (BTW the posting rule is 1 post/1 vote per day/night cycle not 12 hours) This is a worthless post that only serves to claim town when he's been very serious all game. He should at least address bunnies, even if it's just to give a read. If you think bunnies' activities make her lynchable right now you should probably explain the posts she has made... This for me falls into the category of a post that should have caught your attention and forged your opinion on him into a red way. | ||
| ||
Welcome to the game. (And my suspect list, lol)
