Showdown Mafia
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 08:08 Vivax wrote: And after all, if somebody is confident enough, he will duel on his own. We should be careful after all to not become tunneled and emotional all too quickly, even though it's hard for me when confronted with HF's attempts to misrepresent my posts and paint me scum. This is important. No stupid instant duels at dawn please - town should find some kind of consensus before. On July 30 2014 08:10 kushm4sta wrote: See I think, rather than an impulsive thing, duels should be forced by town consensus between the two scummiest people. That way the voting phase will mean something. I think this makes quite some sense. Good idea. On July 30 2014 08:15 ObiWanShinobi wrote: What if the two scummiest don't want to duel each other? The reality of it is we should be able to pick our lynch before we even begin to duel, thereby ensuring that we get the correct lynch and that the mafia has no ability to manipulate the vote either way. Since everybody knows I am town, I can ensure that whoever I duel will get lynched; ergo, this is the most efficient way of lynching people since there's simply no room for mafia to maneuver when the gauntlet is thrown. If they don't want to duel each other some towny guy will have to do it but this should only really be the case if both are scum unless the scummy townie has completely different reads than everyone else. You are really overdoing it with the confidence btw. I mean it's nice and all but the more you do it the more it looks forced especially since you know that you probably won't actually be deciding the lynch. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 09:06 ObiWanShinobi wrote: "Forced" is such an unbelievably subjective term and turning this into a, "I don't like the way you're doing things" war is just a giant waste of time. Exactly. I personally think you are trying to look way more confident than you really are. That's my observation. If you can't respond to that then don't and we will both move on for now. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 09:14 ObiWanShinobi wrote: I'm not just going to let you tell people that I'm scummy for no reason and expect everything to be totally okay. If you think I'm scummy, then pressure me. I don't like the fact that you're just going "nah I don't like this lol" and then just walking away like it never happened. Well, you will have to live with it though. The end. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 08:08 Vivax wrote: Mafia can cause a lot of chaos in the eventuality that two scummy people duel each other. Imagine if they both were townies. You mislynch one, and they can push the idea that people on his wagon were scummy, then maybe they mislynch the other, and so on. Besides, if mafia so wants, they can simply refuse to duel, upon which somebody has to take up the task and pick one of the two. Seems rather unrealistical. I like the idea of having one townie guy duel somebody who is scummy, it will look one sided, but it will also be one of the opportunities where either scum shows face or has to give up on their teammate, if the target was right. Ah, right. This post. No shit mafia is in a great spot if 2 scummy townies duel each other. But how is it better to have a towny townie duel a scummy townie? We are just reducing the odds of hitting scum and we get next to zero information out of the vote. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 09:17 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Or I'll just have you lynched. Your call. Dude, stop it. You're scaring me. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 09:23 marvellosity wrote: trust me bro. it sounds better in theory but it just isn't. obi was clever because he added the point about people only wanting to duel ppl they think are mafia. if x and y are deemed scummiest but neither of them are each other's main scumread, then they just won't duel each other, and it won't really be scummy even if we try in vain to enforce the policy. the only worthwhile thing is not to be a rash asshole. Huh? Don't really get if you are agreeing or disagreeing with me right now. If people don't want to duel each other we will find a solution then. Enough of the setup talk I guess. I am still pro 2 scumy guys fighting. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 09:23 Holyflare wrote: Forgot to add that you should stop tunneling your inner koshi. Koshi nailed you though. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
Doesn't matter how he did it. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 09:50 Holyflare wrote: Palmar is good at mafia. I'm a high volume poster in every game. This is the first time he's ever made a post like that so it's different and very odd as he's only said it now in a game where he's guilty of spamming himself. Palmar is spamming? I don't think so. And his request is reasonable. Do you think it makes him scum? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 09:56 Holyflare wrote: Spam as in contentless posts. When he posted that all he had said was holyflare is 100% mafia (in which case why would he make the post asking me not to spam?) and useless afking. So it should have been suspicious to a lot of people. Really though i just wanted cav to expand on his reasoning for things because i like when people give reasons. (palmars read post turned me around on him) Ok, whatever. Carry on. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 10:52 Holyflare wrote: All he's done is say that obi is confident which = town (extrapolating on my part) and then say that this confidence if continued is probably forced. That's really it and a very odd sentiment to come into the thread with (when cav hadn't really done much more since then) Don't you think that if someone feels the need to say he is the towniest town ever and will decide the lynch in almost every post he makes it looks like he is overcompensating? Maybe he is town who knows at this point but even if he is I have trouble buying this level of confidence. And since I think he knows that we won't all blindly follow him it really serves no purpose apart from getting people to townread him. Anyways... On July 30 2014 11:05 Damdred wrote: I know its been talked about a little bit but I agree with that it should be a confident townie against his top scum read. Its to easy sometimes when two people you think look scummy to tunnel them both and just not see whats going on besides that. What is this paragraph even supposed to say? Explain please. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 11:24 Holyflare wrote: Did you read world cup though x_x? A game where cav was actually mafia and was pretty... I dunno.. Blendy/scared. No, I didn't. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 11:28 Holyflare wrote: Well do it. Also bat if you duel straight away and claim cop i would still lynch you because that's how silly it is. It is almost 5 am dude. No way I am doing this right now - i will go to bed instead. Watch out for this Damdred guy. Both posts he made somehow look awful to me. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 11:30 Damdred wrote: And yea my post wasn't as clear as I would want it to be. I would rather someone who is confident take on someone who is their top scum read than the thread pressure two people who they think are the scummiest into dueling. It is very easy for low fruit to be pushed into dueling each other and getting mislynched and the town not learning much from it. And it is less easy to just duel a low fruit? What is your point? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 11:35 slOosh wrote: Maybe he is high off vigging scum from Titanic. Who knows. Anyhows at this point I'm still feel goods about Palmar's list for reasons I mentioned earlier. Anyone feel not so good about anyone who has posted thus far? Take a look at damdred. Am I wrong or does it look like he is just saying things for the sake of having said something? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 11:38 ObiWanShinobi wrote: I don't know. For some reason I always feel like I can try to talk some sense into you, but you always shove your head up your ass instead. Whatever. Ok, ok. Maybe this guy is town. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 19:06 raynpelikoneet wrote: Food break. Cava supertown Vivax seems scummy Sloosh town Holyflare likely town kush might be town justanothertownie could be mafia Palmar's reads are terrible kush very likely town Sloosh is supertown Sloosh you're dumb Palmar's list is meaningless and dumb You mean like this one? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 20:13 ritoky wrote: here's the deal everyone, i been bread crumbing a bit; but it's time to let everybody in on this shiz. i have a bomb strapped to my chest, and it goes off at dawn. it cannot be roleblocked and it goes through protections. lucky for me, i get to bring one of you find gentlemen down with me. i just wanted some good food, jovial atmosphere, and a little alcohol to celebrate my last night on this planet. Here is my charge to every single person in the game: I want your top 2 candidates of whom should blow up with me and why. Oh and the clock is ticking, we got just under 11 hours until I go off. Don't make me RNG this. You can bomb rayn and damdred for all I care. Alternatively just choose the lurker you dislike the most. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 22:36 Vivax wrote: If I were to make an early call on Damdred I'd say that he looks like he always did and thus probably town , with a style that makes him somehow suspicious for TL standards for some reason. Not confident enough in giving a definite read but I wouldn't call him scummy. Not so sure about Jat cause he sees scummy things where I wouldn't expect them, Obi first, now Damdred and I'd like to hear more of his reasoning since his conclusions seem so much different from mine. Could be indicative of him not knowing what to do while trying to stay active as scum since he stopped talking about setup stuff, so he kind of looks for scum in places where townies already put a checkmark in a box, I happened to do that as scum and then ended up harvesting wtfs for scumreading people everyone else is townreading. I'm just putting this out there cause I don't feel confident in scumreading jat just for this, I think it is noteworthy and am curious about the responses. Next topic, since SlOosh wondered for what reasons I scumread HF: HF is a very aggressive scum player and I was amazed at how many cases he was able to crank out in GSL I think, where he carried us to victory while smurfing. I was like "Wow how do you manage to make up so much bullshit about people". "Just gotta find the scum motives in plays". Key to reading him is following: If he only posts stuff that only takes account of scum motives, and tries to paint things in the worst light possible, and doesn't try to clear townies on the way, he's likely scum. Forget activity, forget insecurity, these are not criteria for reading him. So the reason I called him scum was precisely cause he didn't just try to figure me out, he called me mafia and said that my post must have been scum motivated, way too early in the day, later he backtracked saying that for him the point was all about me picking the SlOosh post, and suddenly he was fine. This doesn't make sense cause even then, all the points about me sidetracking, and the post looking scum tryhard, should still stand for him regardless of me picking SlOosh's post. So HF can definitely be one of the scum we're looking for. But currently I'm not willing to talk to him cause I don't want this thread to become unreadable. Please tell me in detail how you are able to put a checkmark in the damdred = town box. I am listening. I already said why I don't like his posts. He doesn't seem to be saying anything of value - posting for the sake of posting. Looks like a new scum player that doesn't know what to do and how to insert himself in the thread. If that is what he does as town then we will have to wait what he does next but I don't see how you anyone could townread him for the posts he made so far. I really don't. I stand by my Obi observation btw. although he seems pretty towny lately. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 22:54 Vivax wrote: I am not able to put that checkmark confidently, but I'm not able to scumread him either cause I don't feel the posts he made are just there to make him look like he's talking. He posted stuff he seems to care about, and even though it can be summarized as 1. setup opinion, 2. opinion on me and HF, 3. opinion on Obi and 4. telling batsnacks to calm down, I have the feeling that those are simply the topics he's caring and interested about and not just some scum trying to look like he's active. That said I'd tentatively lean town on Damdred. He wasn't even able to explain his "set up opinion" and ignored me regarding it - can you? His opinion on you and HF is like the easiest thing to give and has been given by other people before - the same goes for Obi it seems. Telling batsnacks to calm down is also obvious and not alignment indicative. I could understand a nullread on him if this fits his meta but I can't accept a townread. Why can't he do this as scum? Besides rayn complaining and answering a "dumb list" with a dumb list without any other contribution he is easily the scummiest player that really has posted so far in my opinion. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 30 2014 23:30 Vivax wrote: I don't know Damdred's scum meta, he never rolled it, but I can tell that this game he doesn't look different from the others, and as said, it's somehow of a gut read based on the topics he chooses and how he talks about them. Don't really think I can persuade you further than this with more objective arguments, but if you find anything scummy besides "tries to post a lot in a scummy way", which is just as subjective, feel free to tell me about it. For now we will have to agree to disagree. I am not saying he is trying to post a lot. I am saying he has a hard time with posting anything at all which is more often than not a scum trait. You can't convince me "further" with objective arguments. Ok, I did not see any objective argument by you on this matter tbh. and I think this defense and to scumread me for attacking him is absolutely unwarranted. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 00:34 raynpelikoneet wrote: Damdred is most likely not mafia. Oh, that is good to know. Why? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 00:36 raynpelikoneet wrote: Because he always looks scummy. There is nothing he has said that makes him mafia. He is new (i think?) and i would think he would look REALLY scummy in case he actually was scum. nvm i changed my mind you are probably town too. In other words he is null. Fine whatever, I will reserve further judgement until he posts some more. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 00:54 raynpelikoneet wrote: No i really do think he is town. At least he has given some reads which i would not expect him to do as mafia regardless of Holyflare's & Vivax' alignments. That's not how i think new mafia would talk about the situation. Do you think there is any way why Palmar as town calls Vivax town? He should answer that question himself. It is not like he explained his reads in great detail so I don't really know. But he said he liked how Vivax was "fluidly" participating and he seemed to agree with his opinion on the set up discussion (even directed me to a post of Vivax). | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 01:00 raynpelikoneet wrote: Setup discussion is useless and boring. Scum want to discuss the setup because you don't need to actually say anything game related. That's why i originally scumread you. I agree - if someone only talks about the setup that is scummy but you will have to tell that to Palmar. I just told you what he said about Vivax so far. And to be fair Vivax did not only talk about the setup. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 01:04 raynpelikoneet wrote: JAT i don't like this answer because i asked YOU, right now, to answer this. Yes, and I answered in the very post you are quoting. What the hell? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 01:12 Vivax wrote: JAT tell me more how you feel about me saying that it might be indicative of you being scum when you look at people so critically I townread rather quickly. Do you think this reasoning is scummy or do you understand where I come from, regardless of whether I'm wrong or not. What kind of question is that. Of course it is understandable to think that people who attack townreads might be scummy if you are town. I am questioning your reasoning on the townread. I think townreading damdred "quickly" makes no sense at all. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 01:40 MysteryMeat1 wrote: @Ritoky, i was reading through the thread, and had you as either scum or a power role ^^ I would probably put JAT as someone who i would potentially blow up, when asked for a suggestion on who to blow up, he told you to just choose the lurker you hate the most. Theres 10 pages of thread responses, and instead of taking a guess at someone who he thinks is playing scummy, he goes with a play that imo is too safe. From my perspective its a mafia who is trying to get a mislynch on someone, without coming off as scummy. as for my second person to hit, i would choose someone from the lurkers ^^ huehuehue This guy is confirmed not reading closely. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 01:47 MysteryMeat1 wrote: Well, I think damdred is town based off the previous game i've played with him, and i believe the only reason you don't like rayn is because he told you damdred was ton. I don't agree with either of the people on your scum list. You are saying that now but in your last post you claimed that I had not given any scumreads. So what is it? You are lying. Apart from that my scumread on rayn was not because of what you said as is clearly seen in my filter. Why is rayn town? And more importantly - why was rayn town when I made that post? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 01:55 ritoky wrote: tick tock motherfuckers. seeing a lot of posting, and not much scum reading; plz step it up. You can add MM to the list. Guy made a read, was caught in a lie and then changed his reasoning after the fact with more lies. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 02:12 raynpelikoneet wrote: I think sinani would not goto "fuck you all - see you tomorrow" mode as mafia. JAT would not call me scum as mafia. This is surprisingly accurate. Why would I need to do that? It's cut and dry - he fabricated reasons for scumreading me after I called him out for lying. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 02:15 ritoky wrote: regardless of if his claim about having time is true or not, do you believe he would try that little as mafia? Yamato is famous for not trying as mafia. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 02:19 raynpelikoneet wrote: JAT why did you call Vivax out for his read on Damdred but not me? Well, I did. I did not repeat everything I said to Vivax but I did question you. I do not recall you scumreading me for attacking damdred so I was more annoyed with Vivax. Also the more people tell me his play does not look scummy the more I am inclined to reserve my judgement. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 02:21 MysteryMeat1 wrote: Your list included people who i was townreading, why wouldnt i find you scummy for trying to lynch people i think are town So what? You called me scum specifically for giving no scumreads and telling ritoky to shoot a lurker (what other people had done before me - WITHOUT further reads). Now that you are caught in a lie you changed your reasoning for scumreading me which is superscummy. Also you dodged my question: Why is rayn town? Why could I not scumread him at that point in time as town? Why is damdred town? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 02:25 ObiWanShinobi wrote: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/461330-noir-mini-mafia-chapter-2 Read and understand who exactly you're dealing with. What are you hinting at? That he did a stupid fakeclaim as town? Does that absolve him from being scum somehow? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 02:31 MysteryMeat1 wrote: Damdred is town cause thats damdreds town play, i wouldnt go as far to say that rayn is super towny, but from my perspective the only reason your scumreading rayn is cause he defended damdred. I could be wrong on this but thats what i see. These are the reasons i think your scummy. As for that game you linked, other town voted on BH as well, i even told people not to vote on him. Thats al im going to say on that matter. You are not reading the thread at all. That is not the reason I scumread rayn - I gave a reason for it and that was not it. I have no idea where you "see" that. Also I did not post this link that was Obi. If you are town please just read the thread before you post something. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 02:35 batsnacks wrote: Jat is mafia I would bet your life on it. Back to work. You don't seem to like ritoky very much. ![]() | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 02:36 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Do you get the feeling that MM is hiding anything in his posts? I see a relatively strong desire to contribute, despite the fact that I don't agree with what he's saying. No, he isn't hiding anything but he pushed me for objectively wron reasons and then tried to backpaddle to a second layer of wrong reasons when I called him out. I can't see how this comes from a towny perspective. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 02:39 raynpelikoneet wrote: Can we talk about people who are actually likely to be mafia? marv tell those people JAT is town so everyone ca shut the fuck up. It would be appreciated if marv said anything at all. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 02:44 Vivax wrote: I won't answer that question cause I don't read him as town, like you are implying cause I didn't put him into the list. He's null for the moment but did enough for me to not put him among the people not doing anything, and at least gave some opinions on the matters at hand, marv isn't the guy I feel confident reading early on anyway. I absolutely understand not feeling confident about reading him. I mean he didn't do anything alignment indicative. What did he do to deserve your effort rating? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 03:12 Vivax wrote: And where is my mafia agenda in all of this? That list post was a spontaneous courtesy to tell the thread where I stand, if I didn't include marv for reasons that are my reasons and transparent enough for everyone to see, then you still have to tell me how what I did was scummy. All you're saying is "You didn't have good reasons to not include marv herpaderp", what you aren't saying is how specifically this is supposed to make me scum. Is marv my scumbuddy and I'm trying to keep my hands off of him? Cause that would be the closest you would have to a real reason for scumreading me for what I did or did not. Let's just assume I am too dumb to see the reasons that are transparent. Would you tell me? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 03:23 Vivax wrote: If anything you're too dumb to see I'm town for all the other shit I did, so I'm not going to explicate it further and just let you do your own thing. Pick a side tomorrow when I call for a rayn vs me or a HF vs me and don't bother me further. I didn't include marv cause he did more than all the other people I included as not doing anything, the reason is that simple. I've seen posts and opinions from marv, I didn't see them from the others. Period, now stop giving more importance to rayn's awful arguments than they deserve. Oh, I am not scumreading you. But I am not sure that those duels would neccessarily be in towns best interest. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 04:05 raynpelikoneet wrote: Also points 2-4 had not happened when you called me scum so is this another Titanic III ? ^_^ Wasn't Titanic the game where Vivax did jackshit as scum? Totally different from this game... | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 04:12 raynpelikoneet wrote: It was also the game where he called someone mafia and then gave reasons that happened after he called them mafia. ![]() like on me here. the only reason that could be even semi-legit he can't reason is which happened before he called me mafia. ![]() other reasons are just bad. Yeah, I remember dat timeline case, lol. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 04:47 slOosh wrote: That unlurk timing. Heh. I think that you are unreasonably uncooperative this game. This is my perception rather than an objective statement. I know that as scum you can play a "cleaner" game. So what looks scummy without being scum? Traitor, which the previous iteration of this setup had included. It's not that far of a stretch. Could you be an uncooperative town? Perhaps. It's just ... I guess I think more highly of your town play. I don't understand your logic. Why would he play differently as traitor than as normal mafia (apart from not knowing his buddies)? And I mean why would he play the way he does specifically. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 04:58 slOosh wrote: The logic proceeds thus: Vivax is playing in a way that I construe as strange, perhaps scummy. I played in a game (Storm 2) where he played scum, and he played more "normal". Vivax is playing strange, but has the capacity to play not-strange as scum. What could explain this discrepancy? The former setup of this game included a traitor. Perhaps Vivax is the traitor, which would explain the strange behavior. That's basically my thought process. I'm still talking to him because I could just be wrong, but that's my tentative read. Meh, I think that's quite the stretch. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 05:15 Vivax wrote: You just have to look from the start of the conversation between HF and me, what kush wrote about HF's points, rayn's entrance, and SlOosh being on the sidetracks playing support for them. It looks crazy at glance, but I'm telling you that at least HF and rayn have more than enough capabilities to be such active scum. Don't be fooled into thinking that just cause they're active means they aren't scum, and the scum must be among the inactives. What you will see is them covering each other's backs against a lone guy pushing them as scum, which is the good way of playing scum. Active scum that takes control of the thread and gets townread for their activity and not scumread for the false accusations they use to get mislynches is a one way road to a loss. ______________________________________________________________________________________________________ Disclaimer: HF, rayn and SlOosh, don't reply to this message unless you talk to other people cause I won't answer your questions or rebuttals. I promise you that I won't townread rayn or HF just because of their postcount - I know that it doesn't work this way. Not sold on your theory though. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 05:26 Vivax wrote: It's okay it will look much better once I get one of them to flip. And if they're town and I'm wrong they should be among the earlier NK's. D1 is always a mess, but I hope that I will be proven correct when we have more information, and that people will remember what I said. Is there anyone in particular you want me to take a look at? Do you at least agree on ONE of the guys I'm scumreading? I don't really scumread any of them but I have to admit that I skimmed some posts from HF and sloosh. Regarding rayn - maybe he is scum but he hasn't done anything that really convinces me that he is yet. I would not duel one of them right now. I still don't like damdred and especially MM. Since you already spoke at length about damdred you could maybe look at MM. His errors could be due to sheer stupidity but what I think is really scummy is how he tried to justify his scumread on me with different reasons after I totally debunked his earlier accusations. It is like he decided to scumread me and THEN looked for reasons to do so and when he was caught he didn't apologize and admit a mistake he hastily tried to justify his position with some bs that had nothing to do with his original reasoning. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 05:45 Vivax wrote: Who is he talking to here, Rayn, Palmar? JAT didn't make a list afaik. He refers to my "scumlist" of 2 people. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 06:00 Holyflare wrote: He's not even a bomber don't even acknowledge it That's what I thought too. But it is fine he generated a healthy amount of discussion. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 05:52 ritoky wrote: Approx 1 hr out from the decision: some general candidates: batsnacks - policy for wanting to insta-duel holyflare - don't like his morbid "i gonna die tonight" whiny post marv - policy talk of how duels should go into disappearing yamato77 - ppl i read as town say yo dis guy could be mafia for 0 effort fuba - for not posting a damn thing a couple of others are out on the fringes, and could potentially make a late surge. Btw. if you are actually a bomber and seriously considering this list: My prefered target here would be yamato. I mean it is your decision and if you want to policy bomb batsnacks I can understand that but if you want to hit scum I guess you should go for yamato of that list. Don't bomb marv - if he is town this is really really bad and there is no way to know his alignment right now. Lurking is not his town OR scum meta. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
Palmar why would you do this? Please explain. I thought that the nightkill incriminates marv somewhat but why would you instantly duel. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 08:10 Vivax wrote: No, he wanted me dead and would have created a town vs town situation. There's more behind that kill than the eyes see at first glance. Maybe there is maybe there isn't. Rayn is always a good nightkill. *tinfoil hat on* Rayn can read marv. Marv did not show up all day. Rayn dies. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 19:24 Palmar wrote: There's something about this post. It feels like overjustification. I agree. On July 31 2014 19:28 Palmar wrote: Like tbh, if you're mafia I wouldn't blame you for just doing a scumclaim and trolling for a bit, that might even be the best play in the situation because it stops me from doing what I'll otherwise do which is force you and I to analyze just about every person in the game. If you stop playing now as mafia, you'll leave no links to teammates and this day will be essentially wasted for information, although the end result is a mafia killed. However if you're town, I expect you to do what you can. You have 36-ish hours to solve the game with me, let's do it. Sounds great. If we could nolynch in case we decide you are both town this could have been a not totally awful play. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
##Vote: Marvellosity | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On July 31 2014 23:57 marvellosity wrote: Yep :p <3 ambiguity. You must be pretty pissed to have rolled mafia 2 times in a row. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
We will just have to agree to disagree here. I see a small possibility of Palmar doing this as scum. You don't. Or maybe you just have more information than I have? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
![]() | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 01 2014 01:15 batsnacks wrote: If you believe discussing this isn't going to gain us anything, you shouldn't have given an opinion. What makes you think they would do this as scum? Fine. Last thing I will say to this. Marv already admitted that he could not be arsed to play. If Palmar was also scum then this is a way to gain something from marv going down because someone else would have dueled marv at some point if he had continued to do nothing. Do you consider this questioning scumhunting? Because as I said there is no merit to a discussion about this and it is weirding me out that you suddenly went into questioning mode about this kind of subject after your ealier attitude. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 01 2014 02:28 yamato77 wrote: 2 scum dead and I'm not even playing dunno if I even have to Yeah, better concede at this rate. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 01 2014 02:53 slOosh wrote: Strange that scum wouldn't use janitor powers n0 though, to obfuscate the Vivax / rayn / HolyFlare dealio. Maybe ... roleblock ... I dunno. Anyhows by arbitrary methods I'm working with this kind of list: fuba MysteryMeat1 yamato77 Vivax (???) Who belongs in this list? Who doesn't belong? Discuss. Sounds good to me. Especially the first 3 names. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 01 2014 04:01 sinani206 wrote: Well... that was interesting. Things that come to mind after ctrl-clicking everybody's filters: kush is town. sloosh neutral at the moment. Damdred probably leaning scum right now purely by gut, but no one knows what his scum is like so that's not something I want to commit to unless I'm sure. Don't understand what ritoky was trying to accomplish. Not worrying about Palmar until much later, obviously. Honestly, this game is such a shitfest that I'm glad I got to skip a bunch of it, and no one in this game has done anything more townie than even I have, besides die. Wow that sentence makes no sense. Basically, anyone could be scum from where I'm standing. I unclaim scum by the way. Wow, the classic complaining about town atmosphere without trying to improve it. Apart from the HF/Vivax start I have no idea why you think this game is a shitfest. Not at all. Do something or die tomorrow. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 01 2014 05:42 ritoky wrote: hey hey hey, i am back. bomb locked and loaded, anyone wanna sing their final song with me tonight? Yamato, Sinani, MM. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 01 2014 06:19 batsnacks wrote: I'm being serious this time I promise. I mean I could be wrong but I was serious about thinking they are mafia. Please don't drown us in all those reasons, sir. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 01 2014 06:38 batsnacks wrote: I haven't given reasons please don't drown yet. That is the point. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 01 2014 18:41 Palmar wrote: I really dc. If you guys can't figure this out from now on you deserve to lose. I've done my part. bomb mm1 or fuba or someone else I haven't noticed. Also feel free to bomb yamato for being lazy asshole. You did not do your part as long as you are not dead, sorry. But I fully supports those bombings. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
He just lists some things people have done and calls them scum for it. No explanation why they are scummy and tbh. I think most of them simply aren't. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 02:03 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Btw, I told you mm1 was town. Don't say I didn't warn you. Yeah, you were so helpful in that regard. All day you were screaming "MM is town, don't bomb him" when people were telling ritoky to kill him. So what the hell happened? Did MM get a save off on top of being bombed? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 03:08 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Actually: MM1 hardclaimed a saving role. So did ritoky really try to bomb me or did he just blow up MM1? Why would he have bombed you? How do you come to that conclusion? On August 02 2014 03:11 slOosh wrote: I'm sure ritoky bombed MM1, and scum also shot MM1 for claiming medic or whatever. Hence the lack of KP. Functionally speaking it doesn't actually matter if ritoky bombed you or not. Maybe scum shot MM maybe MM saved someone. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 04:14 kushm4sta wrote: because scum never bus right? scum never bus in a game with no downside to busing. right? hey you ungrateful fucks should be thankful that I saved you from the bored of deciding between two inactives. I am not thankful. On August 02 2014 04:15 kushm4sta wrote: im certain damdred is scum. Prove it. Now. On August 02 2014 04:24 fuba wrote: @Vivax: yes, that's what I was offering. But it doesn't really matter anymore. This actually makes it really unlikely that kush is scum, imo. If he's scum, then he just put himself up for lynch rather than have me (town) duel yamato (either MIA scumpartner or also town). I know that it wasn't decided to go with what I suggested yet, but it makes no sense for him to be scum when that option was on the table. Let's say yamato is scum with kush. How does this not make sense? I am pretty certain Kush thought this would be an easy duel for him. Apart from that we don't know if you are town since you aren't playing the game. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 04:42 kushm4sta wrote: so because he says "every post i make as a purpose" that means he think his inactive opinion is going to sway you?? Why can't busing be the purpose? Two scummy people who both look scummy, it's quite normal to bus. It is normal to bus each other while another scumbuddy is getting lynched? I don't think so. But let's say it is not impossible - this is not enough to convince me that damdred is scum. Give us reasons besides "might be bussing" please. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
Btw. Palmar you will have to do shit today too since you are still alive you lazy mofo. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
This is a dumb post. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 04:46 Vivax wrote: Here's the deal: Scum NK rayn after he scumread me, GK, yamato. It got marv instantly owned, at least I think that the kill pushed Palmar to do that. Therefore, the last scum is yamato. And since SlOosh mentioned it, last showdown game there was a traitor, so we could be dealing with 4 scum. Explain how the nk makes yamato certain scum. Not that I disagree but I think rayns GK read + his ability to read marv + he is a good nightkill anyways is more than enough for scum to kill him. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 04:48 fuba wrote: Why would scum!kush, who I got the feeling most people thought was town (myself included), put himself up for lynch just to save his mia scumbuddy? It makes no sense, particularly if they're both scum. Kush is selfish as scum, and this would be the opposite of selfish. It would be selfless AND stupid. And no shit you don't know my alignment. That has no impact other than to further provide evidence of kush being town. In the case that I'm scum with kush, he sacrificed his more active presence for me, after I suggested myself as a lynch option for no reason whatsoever. In either case, scum!kush would be sacrificing himself for a far less active scummate, and is therefore town. (Of course, this is assuming that we would have gone with my proposition, which we didn't really get to find out since only one person really commented on it). How is he sacrificing himself? I am pretty sure he thought he would win this duel easily. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 04:50 Vivax wrote: Yamato can be a fucking leader when he's town, go read him in Storm. When he doesn't play he's mafia, simple as that. That's a much better reason, yes. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 04:52 Palmar wrote: I think we should policy kush I agree. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 04:56 fuba wrote: Ohhh, that's the point of contention... I guess he isn't "sacrificing" himself. But he's putting himself in the spotlight for literally no purpose. Yamato and I are not worth saving if either of us are scum. What you're suggesting is that scum!kush, when he was previously looking town, launched a surprise duel on a townie either 1) for no reason, or 2) to delay a scum!yamato or scum!fuba lynch by a single day. And in the process he either gets himself lynched, or makes himself look really scummy for forcing a mislynch. I'm having massive trouble seeing any purpose for kush to do this as scum. I was going to tell you that not saving a teammate when there are probably only max 2 left also makes no sense but somehow your post does. On August 02 2014 04:57 kushm4sta wrote: wait so if vivax duels yamato, damdred can change himself with vivax so then it would be damdred v yamato... how is that helpful to town It could help us in specific situations where someone duels an important role. And it helps because he can prove his role. Although it does not confirm his alignment 100%. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 05:08 Vivax wrote: I just want to get yamato out of the way asap. There's not much content to be had with still quite a few players so I don't know how having them post their final reads will change much. We're dealing with a scum team that has been super unmotivated, so it will be simple. If there's one active left after we got rid of the inactive guys, then we have to find him with analysis. One thing at a time though and the next one is yamato. Great that you are sure about yamato. I couldn't care less. Today we lynch one of kush and damdred and not yamato and I would prefer to make this decision after some discussion. Why would we waste our time hammering without any need. This duel is not as clear as the last one. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
Why don't you let the guy defend himself? | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
Such helpful. Wow. Dude, let him explain himself. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
The martyr role. Both town and scum had martyrs. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 07:13 Palmar wrote: Damdred's claim is too good too, and too chill for him, then again I think Kush isn't mafia either. I just think he's in over his head. Not everyone can be Palmar. We should probably keep policy lynching everyone who duels someone that is not yamato. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 03 2014 00:13 Vivax wrote: Since it was kinda strange how he kept trying to find weaknesses in the claim while saying he believed him to be town. Well, he kinda has to. Although I felt the same way - he was asking loaded questions, tried to make damdred look back without that much reason. On August 03 2014 00:28 kushm4sta wrote: vivax, if "trying to find weaknesses in his claim" you mean i thought his power was useless to town and could belong to either alignment, then yes. Except I looked at the last game and town had a similar role, ##ceasefire which stopped the duel, so that lead me to the conclusion that it's probably a town role. Huh? I think those roles are pretty different. I still think we should kill Kush here and the reason is that there are good reasons for damdred to be town and for Kush much less/he has at least a chance to flip mafia. And I am not talking about the blueclaim. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 02 2014 19:56 Palmar wrote: Kush-san must commit sudoku to keephis honor Is this your final answer? I thought you wanted to take a look at their filters. If everyone feels lazy we might aswell hammer kush. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 03 2014 15:57 yamato77 wrote: unfortunately I think you'll all be sorely disappointed if you lynch me tomorrow if only marv was here to tell me how bad I was playing, but alas, he's dead He probably already did so in your qt. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 03 2014 13:46 sinani206 wrote: Don't understand the unvote. Someone has to die. I may have had a scum lean on Damdred earlier but at this point I don't think he is lying. kush did a stupid and green is preferable over blue. ##Vote: kushm4sta This guy should also die at some point. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 08 2014 06:35 Palmar wrote: oh god. It's all your fault. You killed to many mafia and then town went lazy. I blame you. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 08 2014 06:53 Damdred wrote: Lol ill never be able to afk again i didn't have to do anything tbh sloosh and viv were so tunneled i had to shoot jat when i did he would of revisited me. You can bet your ass I would have -_- | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 08 2014 08:27 iamperfection wrote: Jesus Christ the filter length of the entire mafia team was 6 pages. I want to cry... | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 08 2014 08:42 Damdred wrote: That's the thing i wasn't afk i was here the whole time waiting for talking god Poor guy. | ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
| ||
justanothertownie
16316 Posts
On August 08 2014 08:48 Damdred wrote: Fuck i can't tell if marv is being condescending or not rofl, I know that feeling | ||
| ||