I don't really mind people criticizing me >_< please don't take me disagreeing as anything other than wanting more explanation. I am super pleased to get feedback from other people on my play this game, and I should have said so already. Thanks to marvellosity, justanothertownie, Koshi, and Blazinghand for the feedback on what I did well or poorly - this is helpful to me and I do want to keep rethinking points of my play. I feel even if I don't enjoy a game I should be able to take things from it to improve.
My confusion to you guys on Palmar is sort of this-
It seems to me like you read Palmar as town d4 due to two parts of meta (Palmar-meta and TL-meta).
I do feel I looked into Palmar meta and didn't give me support either way - it's fine to say he doesn't post like that as scum getting lynched, but I didn't see him post like that as town getting lynched, so it's a wildcard. I felt he was likely to post a ton more on d4 if he was a lynch target given his low activity d2 and d3, so to me it all felt pretty much in line with expectations.
I don't really know TL-meta enough to use it, but I'm a little surprised (and honestly, kind of disappointed) to hear that scum players don't put up that kind of defense on this site. I don't know if that would convince me, though
As to Blazinghand, I don't really know which option to take as to the mislynch yet - I feel like (as most things in my play do) what I do will just depend more on the specific game than an overriding heuristic. That was kinda what I meant earlier - here, I felt that game was the best heuristic, but largely because I couldn't use many others.
Oh and just to be clear, although the host error added an unpleasant aftertaste, please understand I don't mind at all. I think it would have been bad if the game was cancelled (particularly for players like bunnies, it would suck to have 3 games cancelled in a row) so I think your call was the best given the situation. These things happen and even if it threw me off, when I found out mderg was scum I was incredibly impressed he would make that play! It may not have actually happened, but it was neat to feel like I was so wrong, lol.
|
EPT
