Newbie Mini Mafia LV - Page 36

On May 02 2014 09:35 Epishade wrote:

I think you made a mistake, I didn't townread sweetfrost. I scumread him with my scumteam post, and then I made this post because his vote made little sense to me. It kind of contradicted with what I thought earlier about the scumteam consolidating votes, but then I found reasoning for it (in that he could switch later) and wanted to explain that as an appendage to my scumteam post.

Sweetfrost did little to actually defend himself. Lynching him gave us information to move forward. It sucks that he ended up being town, but I don't think voting for him was the "wrong" move given the information we had to work with at the time.

As for your claim that I was piggybacking on Bunny's vote on Sweetfrost:
I may have been doing that a bit. I generally want to see what other people think about my theories before I try pushing them. Other people may see things that I overlooked. If it turns out that they agree with them, I figure I didn't overlook anything and I'll continue with my theory. It might make me look scummy, but I think it'd look worse withholding this information if someone else found it later - but I did the same thing before with Tamburini. I made my scumteam post, then Meat agreed with me and voted for Tamburini, and then I voted for Tamburini as well. I believe my theories are correct when I come up with them (who wouldn't believe in their own theories?), but I always accept the possibility that I'm probably way off. I judge other people's acceptance of my theories as to how well my theories are and if I should continue with them or not.

Even if Bunny didn't end up voting for Sweetfrost though, I still would have. It was a toss-up between Tamburini and Sweetfrost for me, and I felt that Sweetfrost was a better pick between the two.

I did switch a lot too. One of those switches was on Eden, but that was only because I thought there could only be 1 potential vigi in the game. Eden cleared that up for me and I admit I read the rules wrong. And, hell, everyone was just arguing for and against Tamburini and Sweetfrost that I didn't know who to pick. Ended up going with Sweetfrost in the end obv, but I didn't make up my mind until a couple hours before the lynch.

On May 02 2014 09:40 Epishade wrote:


Can you explain why this is for me, as a new player?

On May 02 2014 09:52 sqrtofneg1 wrote:

Well, generally you just don't.
Unless you're me, and you think you're gonna get killed N1, and you're vanilla town, so you have nothing to be afraid of.

On May 02 2014 09:57 Epishade wrote:
Very well, I can wait until the next day to make my case if I'm still alive.

On May 02 2014 09:55 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
@Bunnies, how was your finals?
How do you feel about being able to talk at night?
Okay, serious question now.
If you were vigi, who would you kill, other than yellow? Would it be a kill for information, or would it be a kill in an attempt to catch mafia?

On May 02 2014 10:10 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
I mean, someone might look really scummy, but there might be someone who's been acting strangely (like tambo). If I were vigi, I'd kill tambo. It would wield the most information.

On May 02 2014 10:14 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
Well, if I were vigi, tambo is highly unlikely vigi.

As for the amount of mafia games, do you mean here on team liquid? This is my third team liquid game, and aside from that, I've only played irl mafia. I've played irl mafia for about 4 years now, I think.