EPTOn April 05 2014 03:12 Koshi wrote:
The Horseman Death is SK. But probably not.
The Horseman Death is SK. But probably not.
I'm actually a DT :OOOOOOOO
Catastrophe Mafia - Page 115
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
VisceraEyes
United States21170 Posts
I'm actually a DT :OOOOOOOO | ||
|
justanothertownie
16320 Posts
On April 03 2014 22:14 IAmRobik wrote: Ummmm, what else. Oh right. If I'm alive tonight, I'm going to be using my night action on Joey (it's nothing bad). I suggest no one target Joey or myself. It might turn out poorly for you. Do you think he is lying? If he is not lying then claiming this as scum wouldn't be very smart, would it? | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
On April 05 2014 03:00 LSB wrote: Why would they out themselves if they had a separate win condition from the town? Palmar seems to indicate that not all third parties are antitown I actually think 3p would be a good asset for town since the roles in this game seem weird (at least looking at my own, lol). I am glad to seek a jointwin. | ||
|
Foolishness
United States3044 Posts
![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/8fir1hH.png) Edition 3. Day 1 of Catastrophe. BREAKING NEWS! ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/FGm5RA2.jpg) We interrupt for this breaking news bulletin! For the first time in the entire game so far a great list of mafia suspects was posted! We now go live to the post itself: On April 04 2014 23:54 kitaman27 wrote: How is he my third scummiest dude? These players are higher up on the chopping block for me: iamp Amiko Hope killing syllo Keirathi and maybe Koshi (VE?) Kitaman has shocked the entire player base by posting a list of mafia suspects that actually makes sense and is congruent with the actions of the thread. This is especially surprising since Kitaman had posted earlier in the day that he was a bit too busy to even be playing the game. "I told everyone early on in the game that my time was limited," Kitaman told us in an interview. "Jokes on them! LOL I've actually been carefully reading everything!" The list is so good that Kitaman is looking to apply it for the Best Game Post award. This wouldn't be the first time he's collected an award for dumpstering an entire scum-team on day 1. "It's posts like these that give me hope for the future," says esteemed mafia expert Foolishness. "Personally, I'd replace Keirathi and Koshi with Djodref and tehpoofter, and there's probably no reason to include VE. But otherwise this list probably wraps up most of the game." The JubJub Journal™ - Apr 4, 2014. | ||
|
justanothertownie
16320 Posts
| ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
| ||
|
VayneAuthority
United States8983 Posts
although I dont agree entirely but ya know majority lynch and all. take this as a vote on killing that isn't useless | ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
This game has been noted by obvious mafias. People that play so mafiaish that they scream "LYNCH Me". Unfortunatly it has grown to the point where it may well as be more mafia than town. Such is the life in TL. OBV Mafia (just click filter): Djodref, sandroba, VA, gumshoe - Note obv mafia is not a definative statement but more of a general filter impression. VayneAuthority - Although not directly antitown, it seems pretty clear that he does not have the towns interest in mind. If he ever comes up to be lynched, expect him to explain that the town's win condition does not include him. He would make a great vig target but alas I don't have KP Keirathi - Previously I've posted about Keirathi here http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/447045-catastrophe-mafia?page=67#1323 On the good note he has began to talk about game related things. On the bad note, there is very little difference from what he did before. Known for the BH train, but "Replacements are scum" is lazy and not alignment indicative. I've created a very own "Make your own Keirathi Ad Lib" Pick a player ____ Pick an alignment ____ + Show Spoiler + [Player] is probs ____ Killing - People have pointed out that Killing is playing much differently than how he did as mafia in foundations. Yet the same can be said about people playing differently in their second game from their first. Meta reading off of one game is pretty suspicious IAmRobik. It is hard to find in a game someone with more setup related talk and less reads than I do, but killing does fit that bill. His horse fishing certainly is pretty questionable. After all, if the horses were antitown, does he seriously expect them to say that? I think he is interested in the impact of horses on other alignments in the game. http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/447045-catastrophe-mafia?page=111#2217 This post stands out by being his longest post, and the one that seems to be contributing reads. Analysis on spam seems to me as desperate, next of which are pure personality analysis. We have no way of knowing if this personality analysis is legit, but what strikes out to me is in no time is there any mention of Techpoofter being anti-town, or acting scummy (aside from the spam analysis). To me this is "Oh shit my filter has no content, let me post something". | ||
|
Holyflare
United Kingdom30775 Posts
| ||
|
Keirathi
United States4679 Posts
So I went back and read through (part of) the context of the thread between those two posts, particularly what was happening around the time of the null read. And the really weird thing is that there was absolutely no one calling Poofter scum before that post except for this one little thing: On April 04 2014 10:28 kitaman27 wrote: No real explanation other than it feels good to vote him. Tehpoofter and Koshi are my top two bad guys at the moment. I'll likely pursue them tomorrow since I'm heading to bed right now. Suppose I could vote one of them, but don't feel like it. Kita mentioned him in passing, and Wave bounced one little question back at him. So why was Paperscraps getting so defensive of Poofter at that point? If you recall, his exact words (rearranged for your reading pleasure) were: On April 04 2014 10:46 Paperscraps wrote: Also for anyone scum reading Tehpoofter, his posts so far are neutral. This is using video mafia meta as a baseline, so probably not to accurate. Basically it's just really weird to me that he 1) felt the need to defend Poofy there from, well, nothing and 2) how in his defense he also downgrades his green read to a null read *AND* leaves himself an out by saying "so it's probably not accurate". Paperscraps and Poofy both scum? | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
On April 04 2014 23:05 Oatsmaster wrote: Ok so I just read Amiko's filter. Its bad. Totally useless and superfluous question that leads to no good answer. And he just keeps asking people to consider that Paper is scum due to the clearly not role related reversing. I dont understand why he has such strong feelings that Paper is doing it outside of his role makes him scummy. He never ever explains, just states it as fact. He also mentions Balla a fair bit but never gives a read on him which is really odd. yeah so basically both BH and Amiko want to lynch paper for not great reasons, marv's reason is the only good one. Man if he was here this would be so much easier. Fuckkkkkk. @Oats: kitaman27 replicate his play in Dr. Who (ongoing) game and it was a focus of d1. Tehpoofter is in the same game, so I wanted to see if he was trying to make some deeper play. About balla I was going to make a read based on where he went, then he subbed out. I don't really think BlazingHand can address why Balla proposed a random vote and give any meaningful information so I didn't bother pursuing it. I think paperscraps is lying to town. Yes, town can lie to town. But, I think scum is more likely to lie to town. | ||
|
VayneAuthority
United States8983 Posts
| ||
|
Koshi
Belgium38799 Posts
Today we do what marv wants. BUT NOT TOMORROW (unless we lynch scum, then we follow marv his lead. Unless he decides to be evil again. But he wont. Probably. He will die I guess. If we lynch scum.) | ||
|
Palmar
Iceland22633 Posts
On April 05 2014 03:01 Amiko wrote: @Palmar (I meant substantial reads, not like "townpile" vs "scumpile" which I am mostly discounting so far) I have not seen him in this continuity. | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
On April 05 2014 03:10 justanothertownie wrote: But why would scum/3rd party claim it? - Mafia deter shots from themselves via this claim from vigis/3p. So, vigis shooting are more likely to hit town. - 3p same thing; except they probably don't care who dies. (rayn's roleclaim suggested he needed some other 3p though) - 3p indicates their alignment to prepare to joint win By the way, pretty much everything I am saying about Robik also applies to kitaman27 and generally, I think. | ||
|
justanothertownie
16320 Posts
On April 05 2014 03:39 Amiko wrote: - Mafia deter shots from themselves via this claim from vigis/3p. So, vigis shooting are more likely to hit town. - 3p same thing; except they probably don't care who dies. (rayn's roleclaim suggested he needed some other 3p though) - 3p indicates their alignment to prepare to joint win By the way, pretty much everything I am saying about Robik also applies to kitaman27 and generally, I think. So you think Robik is lying about being immune and also mafia/3rd party together with Killing? | ||
|
Amiko
United States1725 Posts
Nothing specific I can think of to say about robik/killing right now, sorry. | ||
|
justanothertownie
16320 Posts
On April 05 2014 03:45 Amiko wrote: I tend to think he is immune because in the only scum game I read of Robik he considered fakeclaiming but then hesitated and ultimately didn't do so. I think that reflects some discomfort with fakeclaiming, so I don't think he is likely to do so d1 when he doesn't have to do so. Nothing specific I can think of to say about robik/killing right now, sorry. If you think he isn't fakeclaiming - isn't it a protown thing to tell town that targeting him/Killing could be harmful? I don't see what mafia gains by doing so. | ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
On April 05 2014 03:49 justanothertownie wrote: If you think he isn't fakeclaiming - isn't it a protown thing to tell town that targeting him/Killing could be harmful? I don't see what mafia gains by doing so. Mafia has much more KP than town, though in this case there is probably zero chance that mafia would waste KP on him. So I wouldn't call it alignment indicative | ||
|
LSB
United States5171 Posts
On April 05 2014 03:53 LSB wrote: Usually claiming vet is antitown because Mafia has much more KP than town, and it is less likely that town would shoot you. Though in this case there is probably zero chance that mafia would waste KP on him. So I wouldn't call it alignment indicative | ||
| ||
