III Titanic Mini Mafia: MS Paint Edition - Page 55

On March 19 2014 22:12 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Now this is the point and this is a perfectly valid stance.
Calling him town is not a valid stance at that time.

On March 19 2014 22:18 Holyflare wrote:
well koshi had the same stance as me?

Actually Holyflare's case on Hopeless is really good. I think Hopeless is mafia. He in fact DID reference to the scooby-doo game where Holyflare was town, he used the exact wording so he has read the game. Then he gives another example fully knowing Holyflare has done the same thing as both alignments and therefore his "case" (or accusation, i don't even know what the hell that is) is an outright lie. Hopeless is mafia, Holyflare is town. I have no fucking idea why DarthPunk does not get that. I also don't get why he is fixated in me/Coag thing. There is nothing to say about it and Holyflare apparently does not think either of us is mafia because he has not brought that up. DP thinks both of us are town, why the fuck does he want to question anyone about it? Maybe he is scum.

Hopeless says this:

This is complete bullshit. Absolutely terrible logic. I am either town in which case you should not lynch me or i am scum in which case you should lynch me. This is "if this happens then X if not then Y", not a read. That dude is mafia. thrawn looks much better for pointing this out. Especially this line from Hopeless:

Second time his story does not match with what he said earlier. Earlier he clearly said "otherwise he's likely town", and when thrawn points out the "conditional crap" (i loved that thrawn) he suddenly does not have a read any more, which is contradictory to what he said before. Lynch with fire. Mafia.

On March 19 2014 22:10 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Koshi show me those posts where you tell why Coag is town. Maybe i am missing something because i can't find it in your filter.

On March 19 2014 08:28 Koshi wrote:
I need better punctuation sometimes.
Point is: Coag typed stuff to type stuff. Even though it was disruptive, it was not scummy.

On March 19 2014 08:36 Koshi wrote:
Well, it is a bit over the top. But faking anger (or showing it) works as town on TL. I did it in survivor because I knew it would get the pressure off me and as town that is also important. The difference here being that it is really early in the game but still.

I am not sold on coag scum atm at all.

On March 19 2014 09:17 Koshi wrote:

This is how Koshi looks at Coag

Coag post seal (cool he is town) ---> Coag is superactive (cool now he is even more likely town) ---> Coag posts something lets-call-it-silly (w.e) ----> rayn goes ham (ok let's support rayn and see if Coag responds properly) ---> Caog responds quite rage likely (I am back ok with Coag) ---> 120 posts related to coag that are hard to read (fuck this shit, I am not lynching Coag)

On March 19 2014 22:21 Koshi wrote:

It was not that Coag is town. But that you were painting him too red for something that wasn't extremely bad in my eyes. I also wanted you to look at other people and not spend all time on Coag. It wasn't doing the town atmosphere any favors. Looking back at my filter I was pretty protective about Coag from the get go but like I said, I am talented.

On March 19 2014 22:06 Koshi wrote:

I should. Because I am smart & talented.

It was obvious to me he was town. I told you why a couple times but you wouldn't listen. So pls don't tell me I didn't told you why you should have stopped the tunnel. I did so in 3 different posts.

On March 19 2014 22:10 Palmar wrote:


How about you explain exactly what your issue is? Your read is an associative read because he didn't include DP in the mix of his lynch targets.

Should we lynch thrawn for it?

On March 19 2014 22:24 raynpelikoneet wrote:
You NEVER explain why you think Coag is town. NEVER. In any of those posts Koshi.

On March 19 2014 19:38 Koshi wrote:

Give me your opinion on rayn in 2-3 lines pls.

On March 19 2014 22:25 Hopeless1der wrote:

he was constantly explaining why coag was not scum. In light of the fact that there are only two alignments in the game, a binary function of notscum=town should apply.

On March 19 2014 22:23 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Now this is interesting considering this:

Care to explain how the green and red go together?

On March 19 2014 22:23 Holyflare wrote:


I want to discuss him and it's nothing to do with association it's reads that don't add up with motives:

Says me and dp are town but wary that one of us is full of crap - gives himself a scum on one clause

Says i could be scum because of fluff related to dp but ignores everything else

Says dp could be scum because of x, y, z, a, b, c but the doesn't poe dp after saying all the things I've pointed out about dp.

Either he agrees with me in which case i shouldn't be poe'd because he's sheeping me or he disagrees with me and i shouldn't be poe'd because he said I'm probably town


It's a fault of mindset

On March 19 2014 22:28 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Show me one legit reason from Koshi's posts that can be considered as a towntell.

On March 19 2014 22:28 Koshi wrote:

Well. That is awkard.
It wasn't obvious from the start and yesterday I was somewhat conflicted but with a clear head I could totally have seen him town. Somewhere I knew he was town, even though one can never be sure sure.

On March 19 2014 21:09 Palmar wrote:


I like this Koshi.

Fuck yeah arbitrary parameters.

On March 19 2014 22:31 Holyflare wrote:
Hopeless it's like i care but i really don't. This is nothing like hogwarts, there's no red check it's thrawn posting something that doesn't make sense. Either respond about it or respond to something else but stop using scenarios that don't apply.

On March 19 2014 22:32 raynpelikoneet wrote:

So you are saying you did not consider him town yesterday but you still kept defending him with no real reasoning and tried to make me do something else but didn't tell me what i should do instead. Which is also pretty weird considering your stance in last games (also in this game at the start) has been "shhep marv & rayn, they totes right on D1 if town".

Yes Koshi, that is really awkward and i would like to hear how you explain this.

On March 19 2014 20:06 Koshi wrote:

[snip]

Djodref
You are scummy for that very mehhhhh post about rayn not reacting on VE his seal.
+ Show Spoiler +

1) DP clearly uses meta on rayn to say that rayn is likely town for ragequitting like that. He says "Do you really think rayn would fake this rage quit thing as scum?". But you ignore the good meta point DP makes and adds some generic thing about how scum loves to go afk and stop contributing.
HOWEVER
You are talking about rayn here, the guy that just spammed up the entire thread with his push on Coag. Is that generic evasive scumplay? You do not mention this behavior at all, you do not mention what happened in the thread at all, you do not give opinions on anything. You just picked out 1 post and gave some lines that made it look like you were scumhunting.
The fact is that he did nothing more than arguing with Coag until that point. I didn't play for more than a year so I have no idea of rayn meta but it looked to me that it was a very easy way to not post in the thread.
2) The thing about the seals is just bad.
rayn obviously ignored the first drawn seal from Coag & VE. After rayn asked me why I was defending Coag and I used the seal in Coag his defense, rayn asked Coag if it was the real seal and only after Coag posted his real seal rayn went afk. The first seals posted by Coag and VE had nothing to do with rayn going AFK and rayn didn't react on BOTH seals.
And I find it strange that he ignored the first seal given his reaction to the "real" one.

Conclusion: I do not know if you are lost town or lost scum. But I hope you pick up your game and start posting your ideas into this thread. Stop asking questions but just post your ideas and we will comment on what you think. Build your scumreads like that and automatically you will be seen as town.