|
On February 13 2014 03:03 marvellosity wrote:
no, I have no theories beyond VA right now.
This seems kind of silly to me, especially if you'er tunneling him solely to the exclusion of finding anyone else.
I don't understand why we're not lynching Keirathi for example and ignoring literally DAYS of geript play just because of one massive post.
Marv you never answered me (or Oats) regarding the business right after the rayn flip. I want to know what people think of Oats because he's a huge ??? for me and I'm not staisfied with only one scum on my list right now.
|
I actually disliked Keirathi play more than Geript play. But yes. If not HF then Keirathi is an excellent choice.
|
Can we has filter link to Keirathi? tyty
|
On February 13 2014 04:06 WaveofShadow wrote:
Can we has filter link to Keirathi? tyty
done
|
Reading his case now, I'm still honestly not sure why we're not lynching Keirathi. One post after replacing somebody who didn't look particularly good shouldn't be enough even IF people aren't lynching him because 'give him a chance' or some shit.
He uses the word 'contrived' to talk about VE but that perfectly describes the case in general.
It could be bias because I have a townread on VE but his describing the thought of Cora's lynch being 'worrying' is exactly what I would have done were I around (yes I know marv but we've been over this) and I probably would consider that exactly as VE did. I'm not sure why his describing it as such even makes him scum.
Another thing I thought about was somebody posted recently (in a postgame or something somewhere? I don't remember) that Keirathi is supposedly some sort of meta master. Where's the meta in this case on VE? (Am I wrong wiht thsi point?)
|
Like I'll be the first to admit the since (and including) Shadow game VE's play has been nowhere near the calibre it was when I started playing with him, but that's been consistent across the last few games in which he's played, including this one.
I don't think his passivity makes him scum because as scum he could have done way less at this point and still gotten by, and without attempting to give the he has either---reasoning itself which msot people find bad/scummy (and yet the kind that I would give myself as town).
I really think Keirathi is nitpicking at little things VE has done surrounding lynch targets when he could probably find equal reasoning (apathetic, throwing votes around, little--->no explanation regarding dropping stuff) around people in the rest of the game. Grack, for one. It looks like he chose a likely mislynch target (as VE says himself) and tried to cook something up halfway believable that would get himself through the day. It's not sufficient imo to get VE lynched, clearly you guys KNOW this because you're not voting him, but it was enough to apparently make nobody consider him all day.
And again nobody has even bothered to consider geript's past play today (and specifically what I wrote about him---Oats mentioned it when yelling at me but didn't bother actually discussing it)
Geript/Keirathi should be the lynch.
|
I'm down for stopping potential shenanigans.
##unvote
##vote: vayneauthority
|
EBWO: attempting to give the *reasoning he has either
|
On February 13 2014 04:06 Grackaroni wrote:
I actually disliked Keirathi play more than Geript play. But yes. If not HF then Keirathi is an excellent choice.
Can you explain why?
And or read what I wrote/comment?
Risen you as well (or are you going to ignore my poitns because of 'buddying' for the 5th time this game)
|
I'm down for lynching any of ve, keir, hf, va
|
|
|
So you think Oats is town then?
Can you explain why?
|
I don't think anything of oats. I don't try to read him.
|
The only reason his band isn't there is because I forgot about him
|
On February 13 2014 04:33 Risen wrote:
I don't think anything of oats. I don't try to read him.
I try to have this attitude but I can't help but try to read him. At least I can actually understand the words coming out of his mouth; that's the only reason why I wouldn't read anybody (sorry Slam).
|
Apparently my sheer presence has the uncanny ability to completely destroy any and all thread activity.
Is anyone around at ALL that wants to discuss something?
Or is everyone content on letting the VA slide through without further discussion? Just tell me now, I'll switch my vote and fuck off 'till post-deadline.
|
Dnu my man. VA sounds like a good lynch. Activity level is against him flipping scum but w.evs
|
11589 Posts
I like that someone else noted the lack of effort VE has put into his reads.
I don't know if I buy the whole "I know I look bad" spiel from him. Instead of attempting to explain his reads, he's just self-admonishing and skating by for it. meeeeeeeeeeeeeh
I'm interested to see how Keirathi comes back. He's basically stakes his whole play so far on calling VE mafia (he didn't even TRY to defend his ass reasoning for calling me mafia).
Just for fun, I went back and looked at the getmoript filter from LXI, and the style of his play there is quite similar to geript's play this game. He was relatively low-content, and low-activity. This game, as I've already stated, has an odd progression in modes from geript. It's a conscious decision to troll, no? Then why is he so surprised when Palmar calls him out on it? Honestly, reading the exchange again with knowledge of how both players have played since really makes it clear that Palmar was spot on at the time.
I'm going to filter Wave some time soon. My impression is mixed. He reads geript scum as well, but honestly, that's not that convincing. I don't remember a single stance he's taken on my alignment the whole game. I know day 1 he was all "VA is town" and stuff when Koshi called him mafia, so there's definitely something to be said about how unsettling this VA lynch is at the moment.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
meh. I could lynch not-VA I guess. Maybe one of Holy/Keirathi.
I'd like Palmar to come say things, I'm kinda busy this evening.
|
United Kingdom36161 Posts
On February 13 2014 04:22 Risen wrote:
I'm down for stopping potential shenanigans.
##unvote
##vote: vayneauthority
On February 13 2014 04:25 Risen wrote:
I'm down for lynching any of ve, keir, hf, va
can anyone tell me how these posts even come close to going together?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
