EPTOn November 15 2013 07:33 Umasi wrote:
Idk if you'd say wishy-washy, I was pretty uncapitulating on the entire 'vanesco is scum' thing
I just didn't push it hard :|
but yeah if rayn hadn't green claimed I'd be dead
Show nested quote +
On November 15 2013 07:24 thrawn2112 wrote:
all of it except the first line where I talk to rayn was written before rayn's check. I was about to post it and then I refreshed the page, saw the claim, added the first line, then I decided not to post it
+ Show Spoiler +
whatever rayn. i've been burned by like 3 of your town fake claims in the past so idgaf. i'm gonna post that shit anyway
Ok here's why I didn't like this post. He doesn't give any solid scum reads. At this stage in the game, after 3 cycles, 80 pages, and only a few people left in the game, how can he not have a scumread? I think that all townies should have at least 1 person that they are extremely suspicious of so it's odd that Umasi doesn't. He talks about being "less sold on sylencia being town" and he bounces some other names around... but nowhere in that post does he really talk about anything regarding scumhunting or reasons why someone could be mafia. It's as if Vanesco has been the only read he really wanted to talk about all game, and now that Vanesco is gone he doesn't have anything to talk about.
I finished reading his filter and my impression of his filter is the same as my impression of his last post. His only real contributions are talking about Vanesco... anytime he talks about anyone he is so so soooo wishy washy.
His night actions don't look good either. His roleblock of rayn was terrible. He says he did it because...
"I jailed rayn because he was pretty townie throughout day one in terms of activity/pressure/etc, but scummy for the gumshoe swap, and didn't feel quite right.. so if he was town I figured he'd be in danger, and if he was scum I might block an action, so win-win."
His stated motives are way too ambiguous for that to have been his preferred action! I expect a witch's 1st choice to be extremely well thought out, does that look thought out at all?
I stand by my earlier claim that this post suggests he doesn't care about the lynch at all. I think what I said was something along the lines of unemotional wishy washy uninterested scumminess?
In summary, Umasi has been extremely wishy-washy all game about anyone that isn't Vanesco. His night actions are odd.... yeah this bro's scum, methinks.
all of it except the first line where I talk to rayn was written before rayn's check. I was about to post it and then I refreshed the page, saw the claim, added the first line, then I decided not to post it
+ Show Spoiler +
whatever rayn. i've been burned by like 3 of your town fake claims in the past so idgaf. i'm gonna post that shit anyway
On November 12 2013 15:45 Umasi wrote:
I won witchcraft N2
Tracked Cephiro, he didn't visit anyone
I have a pretty solid amount of work coming up in the next few days, will be largely participate, will try to get in when I can.
I guess in revelation of cephiro being town, I'm less sold on Sylencia being town...Although I'm still loathe to go down that path and lynch Syl. That said, it basically leaves Sn0 and one of koshi/hopeless for me, although I'll bounce Syl/koshi/hopeless around. Kinda weird how Vanesco was 'suspicious' of Sn0, so...idk if that frees him from suspicion or not, but it's a mark in his favor imo.
('suspicious' isn't meant to implicate sn0, just how vanesco couldn't have been legitimately suspicious of anyone.)
I won witchcraft N2
Tracked Cephiro, he didn't visit anyone
I have a pretty solid amount of work coming up in the next few days, will be largely participate, will try to get in when I can.
I guess in revelation of cephiro being town, I'm less sold on Sylencia being town...Although I'm still loathe to go down that path and lynch Syl. That said, it basically leaves Sn0 and one of koshi/hopeless for me, although I'll bounce Syl/koshi/hopeless around. Kinda weird how Vanesco was 'suspicious' of Sn0, so...idk if that frees him from suspicion or not, but it's a mark in his favor imo.
('suspicious' isn't meant to implicate sn0, just how vanesco couldn't have been legitimately suspicious of anyone.)
Ok here's why I didn't like this post. He doesn't give any solid scum reads. At this stage in the game, after 3 cycles, 80 pages, and only a few people left in the game, how can he not have a scumread? I think that all townies should have at least 1 person that they are extremely suspicious of so it's odd that Umasi doesn't. He talks about being "less sold on sylencia being town" and he bounces some other names around... but nowhere in that post does he really talk about anything regarding scumhunting or reasons why someone could be mafia. It's as if Vanesco has been the only read he really wanted to talk about all game, and now that Vanesco is gone he doesn't have anything to talk about.
I finished reading his filter and my impression of his filter is the same as my impression of his last post. His only real contributions are talking about Vanesco... anytime he talks about anyone he is so so soooo wishy washy.
His night actions don't look good either. His roleblock of rayn was terrible. He says he did it because...
"I jailed rayn because he was pretty townie throughout day one in terms of activity/pressure/etc, but scummy for the gumshoe swap, and didn't feel quite right.. so if he was town I figured he'd be in danger, and if he was scum I might block an action, so win-win."
His stated motives are way too ambiguous for that to have been his preferred action! I expect a witch's 1st choice to be extremely well thought out, does that look thought out at all?
On November 10 2013 15:48 Umasi wrote:
Cephiro has done nothing to make me more or less suspicious since the lynch occurred. More annoyed, since I was also looking forward to his claiming strat, but it can't be helped I suppose.
Still prefer vanesco as a lynch
##vote: vanesco
Cephiro has done nothing to make me more or less suspicious since the lynch occurred. More annoyed, since I was also looking forward to his claiming strat, but it can't be helped I suppose.
Still prefer vanesco as a lynch
##vote: vanesco
I stand by my earlier claim that this post suggests he doesn't care about the lynch at all. I think what I said was something along the lines of unemotional wishy washy uninterested scumminess?
In summary, Umasi has been extremely wishy-washy all game about anyone that isn't Vanesco. His night actions are odd.... yeah this bro's scum, methinks.
Idk if you'd say wishy-washy, I was pretty uncapitulating on the entire 'vanesco is scum' thing
I just didn't push it hard :|
but yeah if rayn hadn't green claimed I'd be dead
yeah that's what I was trying to say. you weren't wishy washy about Van, but the way you pushed that case made me think of scum kushm4sta's "haha i'm smart I know who scum are" busses. you were wishy washy about everything else, those two points combined made it look like a buss.
