|
Message GMarshal if you request a ban please ^_^
Also when the game you're sitting out is over!
~GMarshal |
United States22154 Posts
On September 06 2014 00:07 Amiko wrote:
Newbie LVIII - Disney Mafia
Daydreamarine and MihZaaa - requesting 1-game inactivity ban (and earlier failure to vote)
lilwade - requesting 1-game inactivity ban for modkill (and earlier failure to vote), but a warning may be better.
abuse - requesting only a warning for inactivity modkill.
Also, Chairman Ray completed sitting out the game.
Daydream received more than one pm per cycle reminding him to vote/post/submit a night action or to encourage him to speak with his coach. His activity and content improved over the course of the game after initially seeming to really misunderstand how the game worked, so I hope he'll sit his out his ban and play again. I don't know if he has a valid reason.
MihZaaa just stopped posting for a few phases. I don't know if he has a valid reason.
Lilwade also received reminders to vote / post / etc. I reminded him in the mafia QT to post in the thread, and although he did post something in the QT and not the thread (causing me and his mafia partner to joke he could still be modkilled) he then actually didn't post in the thread and was modkilled. He explained to me that he had gotten a 404 error, and because he was active before and after the post, I tend to believe this is true, so if you feel a warning is more appropriate that's fine with me.
Abuse was modkilled for failing to post, but I think his activity was usually on the good side and I was really mixed over whether modkilling him was appropriate when he failed to post for 30+ hours. He was going to a wedding. I wouldn't want more than a warning.
Ok, going with warning for lilwade, everything else approved as posted
|
Cell Mini Mafia III Requests:
A warning for batsnacks for playing against his win condition. He spent the last few hours of the day berating everyone and voted himself until just before the very end. Also a warning to Lilwade for playing against his win condition, having made a grand total of 14 posts, most of which one liners. There were more than a few moments where Town was frustrated as he posted in his Newbie game and didn't in the Cell game.
|
Blazinghand
United States25560 Posts
I'd probably warn Lilwade just for inactivity, which I think is more fitting. The posts he DID make weren't like, anti-wincon or anything. He just wasn't active or trying to play at all. You see Artanis, a prerequisite for playing against your win condition is to, well, play.
|
On September 06 2014 07:23 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
Cell Mini Mafia III Requests:
A warning for batsnacks for playing against his win condition. He spent the last few hours of the day berating everyone and voted himself until just before the very end. Also a warning to Lilwade for playing against his win condition, having made a grand total of 14 posts, most of which one liners. There were more than a few moments where Town was frustrated as he posted in his Newbie game and didn't in the Cell game.
The reverse was also true; he got modkilled in the newbie, a heavy blow to his teammate.
Just warn him not to join two in the future.
|
United States22154 Posts
On September 06 2014 07:23 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
Cell Mini Mafia III Requests:
A warning for batsnacks for playing against his win condition. He spent the last few hours of the day berating everyone and voted himself until just before the very end. Also a warning to Lilwade for playing against his win condition, having made a grand total of 14 posts, most of which one liners. There were more than a few moments where Town was frustrated as he posted in his Newbie game and didn't in the Cell game.
Approved
|
idk if slam is still banned but he's always sitting out my games and I'm lazy so there's that. If he wasn't given credit for sitting out that other game then he should get it.
|
Season of the witch mafia is over.
No bans.
Warning for Robik for breaking a rule and getting modkilled.
|
United States22154 Posts
On September 17 2014 07:14 Palmar wrote:
Season of the witch mafia is over.
No bans.
Warning for Robik for breaking a rule and getting modkilled.
done
|
Also tbh, I've probably played like 15 games since I got that warning! I want to get off Mr. Bones Wild Ride the warning list!
|
United States22154 Posts
On September 21 2014 05:35 Palmar wrote:
Also tbh, I've probably played like 15 games since I got that warning! I want to get off Mr. Bones Wild Ride the warning list!
also done :D
|
On September 20 2014 07:15 GMarshal wrote:Show nested quote +On September 17 2014 07:14 Palmar wrote:
Season of the witch mafia is over.
No bans.
Warning for Robik for breaking a rule and getting modkilled. done
APPEAL!
|
Blazinghand
United States25560 Posts
TL Mafia LXVIII has many modkills, but I will not be punishing those who got modkilled after I did the serious crackdown on behaviour and enforced normal TL Forum standards. I will address what I believe to be the troublemakers from the game; after the flame war started, people got mad and started flaming back, and I do not blame them for this.
1 game ban for Marv for requested he be modkilled without a reason.
1 game ban for Rayn for flaming and forcing me to modkill/replace him.
Warning for Koshi for repeatedly posting in question text asking me to modkill people. This is not appropriate, and he should have just PMed me.
Warning for Robik for flaming and making the situation worse early on. This is not a ban, because Robik shaped up and did a good job of not stepping out of line the rest of the game. He did not give me cause to modkill him.
If people believe these punishments are too light, or not strong enough on the people who got modkilled later, bear in mind that the goal here isn't to prevent Rayn or Marv, who are generally excellent players, from ever playing. And most of the people I had to modkill or deal with were just reacting to the awful game thread. Light but just punishments for the sources of the awfulness.
|
TAIWAN NUMBAH WAN5956 Posts
I personally would think that robik, while he did not get modkilled, was one of the main reasons why the thread went out of hand and deserves more than just a warning. But maybe that is just me
|
Blazinghand
United States25560 Posts
I would consider a ban for Robik. I was unsure whether it would be more appropriate for a warning or a ban for him; he did help start the flame war.
|
I support marv ban. Maybe more. than just 1 game. The least he could have done was ask for replacement privetly. Publicly asking to be mod killed was just way over the line imo.
I think robiks warning is just. I don't think it should be more, i agree with the latter section of what BH had to say.
(which i think should be valued appropriately)
Rayn should be getting a larger ban imo. he was literally screaming in the thread. and thats it. Even after several warnings, he continued to ignore you, and shit post.
i think BC should be getting a warning. He got mod killed for failure to vote. (as well as anyone who failed to vote that game)
|
Agree on rayn for reasons stated in the other thread.
Rayn continually acts like this and makes games not fun to play in, continually gets banned, comes back and does the same thing.
If I have to read 'fine fucking lynch me but then promise you'll lynch so and so he's 100% fucking some you shit fuck fucking fuck' one more time... '
|
|
|
On September 23 2014 07:37 WaveofShadow wrote:
Agree on rayn for reasons stated in the other thread.
Rayn continually acts like this and makes games not fun to play in, continually gets banned, comes back and does the same thing.
If I have to read 'fine fucking lynch me but then promise you'll lynch so and so he's 100% fucking some you shit fuck fucking fuck' one more time... '
?
|
On September 23 2014 07:37 WaveofShadow wrote:
Agree on rayn for reasons stated in the other thread.
Rayn continually acts like this and makes games not fun to play in, continually gets banned, comes back and does the same thing.
If I have to read 'fine fucking lynch me but then promise you'll lynch so and so he's 100% fucking some you shit fuck fucking fuck' one more time... '
100% agree with this
|
On September 23 2014 07:20 Blazinghand wrote:
TL Mafia LXVIII has many modkills, but I will not be punishing those who got modkilled after I did the serious crackdown on behaviour and enforced normal TL Forum standards. I will address what I believe to be the troublemakers from the game; after the flame war started, people got mad and started flaming back, and I do not blame them for this.
1 game ban for Marv for requested he be modkilled without a reason.
1 game ban for Rayn for flaming and forcing me to modkill/replace him.
Warning for Koshi for repeatedly posting in question text asking me to modkill people. This is not appropriate, and he should have just PMed me.
Warning for Robik for flaming and making the situation worse early on. This is not a ban, because Robik shaped up and did a good job of not stepping out of line the rest of the game. He did not give me cause to modkill him.
If people believe these punishments are too light, or not strong enough on the people who got modkilled later, bear in mind that the goal here isn't to prevent Rayn or Marv, who are generally excellent players, from ever playing. And most of the people I had to modkill or deal with were just reacting to the awful game thread. Light but just punishments for the sources of the awfulness.
No punishment for BC?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
