Titanic Mini Mafia! - Page 207

On August 05 2013 05:42 IMCaptainJackSparrow wrote:
@Koshi

You played the farthest thing imaginable from "perfect" D3. You literally just sheeped Rayn and hz and then lurked again, only to de-lurk when you had 3 votes on you. How is that a "perfect town" D3?

On August 05 2013 05:46 justanothertownie wrote:
I think I made pretty clear that I'm absolutely sure about Koshi and FT being scum. What should I ask them? FT doesn't need to be here answering any questions it seems. Still he avoided being lynched 2 times and it probably will be the third time tomorrow while koshi just throws shit at everyone.
Fine, I will look closer into stutters/oats the tomorrow/the day after that but we can only lynch one person this day and I would like to see the nightkill before (although it would surprise me if it's not a confirmed townie who dies).

On August 05 2013 05:51 Koshi wrote:

I didn't just sheep on XRZ. I clearly, very very clearly said why I was on XRZ. The lynch on XRZ was not a bad lynch. The reasons that I gave were more than enough to lynch him without him defended on that.

What bad is:
-Making a million association cases that prove that it is not bad to lynch XRZ anyway. (how does 1 defend himself against that, you don't even ask the guy questions?)
-Starting the day with some insane vigor to get XRZ lynched and then actually succeeding in 60 minutes when all the other people are asleep, then when these other people join the thread not listen to them and just tunnel XRZ into the ground.


THIS DOES NOT MAKE RAYN AND HZ SCUM. BUT IT IS FUCKING HORRIBLE TOWN PLAY. and perfect scum play.

On August 05 2013 05:46 justanothertownie wrote:
I think I made pretty clear that I'm absolutely sure about Koshi and FT being scum. What should I ask them? FT doesn't need to be here answering any questions it seems. Still he avoided being lynched 2 times and it probably will be the third time tomorrow while koshi just throws shit at everyone.
Fine, I will look closer into stutters/oats the tomorrow/the day after that but we can only lynch one person this day and I would like to see the nightkill before (although it would surprise me if it's not a confirmed townie who dies).

On August 05 2013 05:48 Clarity_nl wrote:
Yeah it's gonna be me or rayn fo sho

On August 05 2013 05:53 IMCaptainJackSparrow wrote:

If it doesn't make then scum why are you talking about it?

On August 05 2013 05:54 justanothertownie wrote:

Possible. I could imagine CJS being killed too.

Koshi, I think everyone gets that you don't like rayns and hzs play by now. Would you stop it now?

On July 30 2013 09:28 justanothertownie wrote:
Ok. Still the most likely scumteam for me is now (if this check is for real):
hzflank, FirmTofu, Malongo + maybe rayn or oats.
Details tomorrow.

On August 05 2013 05:53 raynpelikoneet wrote:

If you are mafia that´s an easy way out. You buss two of your teammates because you only need to lynch Stutters after that. What differentiates you from Stutters? Why are you town over him, because i am pretty sure everyone else is town? Stutters is saying the same stuff you are. Hell, if we could flip Koshi & FT right now and they both flipped mafia how am i going to tell which one of you/Stutters is mafia because you both look equally good/bad and you are not trying to do anything to look better than the other one?

I can´t tell you what you should be asking them. That eliminates the purpose of "proving why you are town" because i would be giving you the correct answers in the first place. You should be figuring out how to expose mafia and prove why you are town and then convince the rest of the town of it.

It´s not my job to do that for you.

On August 05 2013 05:59 Koshi wrote:
Also, I don't believe FT is scum. At least he looks through the bullshit. I don't see scum doing that.

On August 05 2013 05:58 hzflank wrote:
Can we read anything new into this now that we know Malongo was scum?

On August 05 2013 05:57 Koshi wrote:

It doesn't prove they are scum. But you think I am scum because I obviously troll/derail the thread/make it bad to scumhunt. These 2 do it unobvious and you are not seeing it.

Sure I would like to discuss with JAT on how he thinks I am scum and how I think he is scum. But in the meantime we got to read 1000 posts about how XRZ is scum and who the scumteams are. In which we are all mentioned. So our first reaction was to defend us there.
I didn't even bother doing that on my phone. But I can tell you that thinking on persuing JAT was far from my mind. Silly me.

On August 05 2013 06:02 Clarity_nl wrote:


Yes it was disruptive in a way.
But are you trying to say you do not see townies trying to make an effort in the both of them?
Do you think a scum hz, who is pretty confirmed before he started pushing xrz, would put all that effort into all of the association stuff just to bury a discussion about the xrz lynch, which was pretty much going to happen anyway once he made some very valid points.

I don't get you.

On August 05 2013 06:05 raynpelikoneet wrote:
I can tell you that you should be arguing with your scumreads, ask them specific questions about your other scumreads. You should already know what you expect them to answer. As mafia it´s often hard to keep your story straight and town would not win these games if mafia didn´t fuck up or if mafia did always act naturally towards each other. Most mafia players can´t do that, and any mafia player can´t do that all of the time. That´s what exposes them and that´s how you get out of a bad spot if people think you are mafia.

The one of you four who is town is our best (and pretty much only) chance of winning by starting discussion between these four people. For me/hz/Clarity/Cora/Oats it is incredibly hard to tell the difference between you all because you have not been interacting with each other for a long time.