[N] Sicilian Mafia Style - Page 8

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 03 2013 11:51 GMT

#1766

On August 03 2013 20:48 marvellosity wrote:
Should have masoned me babe x

I kinda wanted to but Oats was an obv-pick because he was obv-town and i needed to talk with someone about when/how to claim. I also wanted to mason Sloosh cause i wanted to figure out his scumbuddies but that didn´t obviously work out. :/

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 03 2013 11:55 GMT

#1767

I would really like someone to give me an opinion on about what i should have done with my claim? Was it the best course of action? I was afraid of rolecop and i felt like if i didn´t claim right at the game start i would have been insta-mislynch if rolecopped by scum/town.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 03 2013 13:30 GMT

#1771

filter
Ver could you explain me why you came into conclusion that my claim + being silenced did not make me town considering this:
1) If i was mafia pardoner i would have totally made one of the best mafia roles useless for my team.
2) I would have used another very strong power (silence) on myself, when i have established a very good PM network with Gumshoe, Oats, and DrH, Vivax, marv (by proxy). Gumshoe has promised to claim his role to me (that one i majorly fucked up, i somehow thought everyone was blue in this game and that it was somehow known :/ ).

I would have wasted 1/3 mafia powers on D1 on something that does not make me confirmed town and definitely does not put my team into better position considering the other options.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 03 2013 14:06 GMT

#1773

Why is it better to not claim than to claim? I am withholding town information that does not benefit us at all? I certainly should never pardon anyone (although if i was online at the late D1 i would have pardoned VE because the lynch was so stupid).

Only thing that can happen if i do not claim is that i pretty much get insta-lynched if there is a rolecop who cops me.

EDIT: You have a fair point in the copycat role. Role-vig is gonna shoot someone anyways, i would accept myself as a mafia shot as it removes the doubt on my role/alignment.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 03 2013 14:57 GMT

#1778

Chezinu was obviously town, his play was hilarious when he put all his green reads as red and faked a cop that way. I laughed my ass of when discussing this with Koshi in the game. :D

EDIT: tbh i don´t think i would have ever figured out vayne. wp dude.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 03 2013 16:55 GMT

#1786

I can´t understand why marv was all over you the whole game. You were 100000x townier in this game than in NWM where you were clearly scum. ^^

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 03 2013 16:59 GMT

#1788

VE i am sorry for not being around and pardoning you. :/

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 03 2013 18:15 GMT

#1791

No, you would have nuked someone (Sloosh) on D2 and we would have lived happily ever after. I thought you were scummy at the start of D1, but everything you did when you claimed and from on that was so 100% town.

Whatever i swear might not hold ;D

EDIT: I would not even care if i got lynched as you had a KP that could kill mafia.

raynpelikoneet

Finland43270 Posts

August 03 2013 18:31 GMT

#1793

I kinda agree with you SnB, but the SK balances the game very well.
If the SK is not however competent, scum lose pretty quick.

Look at the game. Town mislynched once before D4. And that was because of VE´s derp. You still had the game "maybe won" if you could kill THE KOSHI!! PM´s can also help mafia, you just need to use them with a different mindset (ie. fishing for powers (see gumshoe, rofl me), figure out SK, push your agenda).