Ego Mini Mafia - Page 10

On April 11 2013 16:11 DarthPunk wrote:
Looking back on it that axle wagon really raped the scum team.

On April 11 2013 16:11 DarthPunk wrote:
Looking back on it that axle wagon really raped the scum team.

On April 11 2013 17:18 DarthPunk wrote:


It's kind of funny that you and marv were yelling at me/calling me stupid so much for calling you scum day one.

On April 11 2013 19:56 Dandel Ion wrote:
I already said I won't use LR again.

But the game was balanced as fuck, so whateveeeeeeer.

On April 11 2013 20:35 sciberbia wrote:
I'm strongly in favor of true RNG.

I don't think you can argue that scum played as well as town in this game. Good scumplay is defined per the win condition as not dying. All 3 scum died. It's not like it's not within their power to not die. If they had all played the towniest games of their lives they would surely have won. Not saying it's easy but I'm saying the better team won.

Mafia is a team game. As long as the setup is such that the better team will usually win that is fair in my book.

In most team games you can make fair teams for every game but a key feature of mafia is that knowing who is on your team ruins the game. I think it takes away a lot of the spirit of the game if marv knows going in that either palmar or ace must be scum.

edit: another reason I don't like it is that it puts newer players at a completely unfair disadvantage. All the vets know what teams would be considered balanced but newer players may not.

It also unfairly advantages players who personally know the host and what he would be likely to do.

imo it is much more fun to try to figure out whether someone is scum by analyzing their filter and interactions with other players than playing guess-what-the-host-thought-would-be-fun.

On April 11 2013 20:35 sciberbia wrote:
I'm strongly in favor of true RNG.

I don't think you can argue that scum played as well as town in this game. Good scumplay is defined per the win condition as not dying. All 3 scum died. It's not like it's not within their power to not die. If they had all played the towniest games of their lives they would surely have won. Not saying it's easy but I'm saying the better team won.

Mafia is a team game. As long as the setup is such that the better team will usually win that is fair in my book.

In most team games you can make fair teams for every game but a key feature of mafia is that knowing who is on your team ruins the game. I think it takes away a lot of the spirit of the game if marv knows going in that either palmar or ace must be scum.

edit: another reason I don't like it is that it puts newer players at a completely unfair disadvantage. All the vets know what teams would be considered balanced but newer players may not.

It also unfairly advantages players who personally know the host and what he would be likely to do.

imo it is much more fun to try to figure out whether someone is scum by analyzing their filter and interactions with other players than playing guess-what-the-host-thought-would-be-fun.

On April 11 2013 21:02 DarthPunk wrote:


That actually happens all the time.

On April 12 2013 00:07 DarthPunk wrote:
To be fair. Ace/marv/palmar all being town wasn't even a major reason that town won this game. Vets often play badly just like everyone else. So if we are talking about balancing 'vets' I really don't see the point.

On April 12 2013 00:10 DarthPunk wrote:


Yeah I don't buy that argument. I am not in favor of 'balanced' set ups but I think that you can have a basic idea of who is more likely to play better as scum.

Town not so much. But some players just don't try as hard as scum I think, and it is really obvious.