Personality Mafia 2 - Page 5

On March 14 2013 03:09 marvellosity wrote:


yes

On March 14 2013 03:11 Acrofales wrote:


Yeah, but I think three duds would also be stupid. So one of them is probably real. It's worth waiting and seeing which.

On March 14 2013 05:00 Foolishness wrote:
Well if you want to be conceited about it then that's fine too. I mean I could care less about you, I'm here to win.

On March 14 2013 05:27 prplhz wrote:
i assume that scum did it to make me look worse because i've already attracted some heat. i don't know why they want me voting vivax though but if he's really town then maybe that's why. they could have made me vote anybody but they'd probably not want me to vote scum.

On March 14 2013 08:53 supersoft wrote:
You cannot all be scum:
















I command you to unvote.

##UNVOTE

On March 14 2013 10:06 slOosh wrote:
He is also 100% sure that yamato is scum so that's a null point.

Instead of pointing out the (what should be) obvious gaping logical holes of scum Foolishness' "case" in determining the three reads, you go after something inane. C'mon - rip it apart marv!

There is actually plenty of reason to lynch yamato first - him flipping red does a lot to the current playing field, which is why I'm waiting on supersoft / Foolishness.

On March 14 2013 10:28 strongandbig wrote:


Would town Marv really try and run "I'm town because I've posted more one liners than in any of my previous scum games"?

Like, really?

On March 14 2013 13:46 Acrofales wrote:
I have skimmed your filter in NMM 33, but it's hard to get a proper impression without reading more. At first glance you seem more dogged and pushy here than in NMM 33, however as Mocsta said, it was your first game ever.

I don't have time to really read that game right now, I might tomorrow. In the meantime there are Yamato, Prom, Marv and DI who know that game far better than I do. I trust them to do a better job than I ever could of any meta analysis of your scum play.

Prom, Yamato, Marv, DI: what do you think of Cora?

I'm off to bed.

On March 14 2013 08:07 Foolishness wrote:
But in your first post you seemed to accuse Vivax, and now you two seem to be butt-buddies. Aren't you contradicting yourself?
No. In my first post I thought Vivax was suspicious, and I hinted at my reasoning. That story post was made in haste after reading the thread and I called him out based on gut instinct from his filter. I was in a rush cause it's the end of the school quarter here and I'm quite busy (e.g. research paper due, finals, etc.). Later in day 1 I examined the thread and I had time to analyze a few people (more on who these people are later in this post). I looked at Vivax's history and realized I made a mistake. There is a post in my filter which explains why. It should be noted that while Vivax is rather spammy and not the most coherent at times, it is 100% clear that he is putting in an effort to figure things out and get things done for the town.

Okay, it's definitely clear that yamato77 is mafia, but what of your other reads?
I will talk about marvellosity in a bit. After the nuke incident I believe that Crossfire is mafia. His nuke against me was an incredibly rash thing to do, especially after people in the thread were saying to hold off on killing me one more day (the same people who include a mod-confirmed townie). It makes sense from a mafia perspective. I just nuked one of their teammates so they are screwed, since dodging a nuke is near-impossible. They see this and realize that I'm on the right track in figuring them out (say for example I'm correct about marvellosity) so they nuke me immediately to prevent me from causing further damage. I myself, as mafia in past games, have done this many times. Some person comes out in the thread and kills a teammate or posts a big analysis that's very bad for our team, I shoot them immediately to stop them from doing further damage.

Also consider the fact that crossfire was in no danger of getting killed at the moment. If he was about to get lynched I can see sending out a nuke as a last ditch effort to survive or make something happen (hey I just kinda did it, though my motivation is way different). It was completely out of the blue, just as yamato's day vigi was completely out of the blue.

I analyzed this guy day 1 but didn't come up with anything conclusive. On one hand he hadn't done anything to exhibit being mafia, but nothing striking to say he was for sure town either. With his nuke shot we now know where his agenda is and what side of the town he's on.

On March 14 2013 21:32 Vivax wrote:
Forgot to add Dandel to the possible scum.

Oats is likely just bad townie.

On March 14 2013 21:34 Dandel Ion wrote:

Please make a list with your top 15 scumreads.

On March 14 2013 21:39 Vivax wrote:
Funny boy.not.

On March 14 2013 21:49 Vivax wrote:
Why don't you tell me why all on the yamato wagon were town instead (Cora likely town) and thus, all mafia were on Bugs/Crossfire/me/something else than yamato?

Some stupid townies say it's concerning when I play "normally", it's like asking me to play crazy and anti-town just to not get lynched. I don't know what's up with people. They think I'd play the same in every game, I'm not that stupid as either alignment, and I keep learning more about this game.

On March 14 2013 22:42 Vivax wrote:
+ Show Spoiler +
My townreads are my not-scumreads, Mengenlehre. Go on.

On March 14 2013 22:41 marvellosity wrote:
THAT is what i want to talk about right now. Or Foolish constantly demanding a long case from me when syllogism clearly articulated that mafia Foolish gets pissy when he doesn't get a nice long case on him.

Like Dandel. Tell me what you think about what I said about slOosh, tell me about what you think about what I said about Corazon, and how Foolish has a strong townread on him.